Investing in a franchise is one of the most significant financial decisions you'll make as an entrepreneur. While the allure of joining an established brand like Massage Envy franchise can be compelling, the key to making an informed decision lies in thoroughly understanding the Franchise Disclosure Document (FDD). This comprehensive FDD review serves as your roadmap to evaluating whether a Massage Envy franchise aligns with your financial goals, operational capabilities, and long-term business objectives.

The franchise disclosure document is a legally mandated document that franchisors must provide to prospective franchisees at least 14 calendar days before any binding agreement is signed or payment is made. This document contains 23 distinct items that cover everything from the franchisor's business background and litigation history to financial performance representations and franchisee obligations.

What This Analysis Covers

This in-depth analysis examines each of the 23 FDD items for the Massage Envy franchise system, providing you with:

• Detailed breakdowns of initial investment requirements and ongoing fees
• Critical evaluation of franchisor obligations and support systems
• Transparent disclosure of litigation history and potential red flags
• Financial performance data (when available) to help project potential returns
• Territorial rights analysis to understand your competitive positioning
• Operational requirements that will impact your day-to-day business management

Whether you're a first-time franchise investor or an experienced multi-unit operator, understanding the nuances of the Massage Envy FDD is essential. This analysis cuts through the legal language to provide actionable insights that will help you make a confident, informed decision about this franchise opportunity.

Important Note: This analysis is based on the Massage Envy Franchise Disclosure Document dated April 29, 2024. The wellness and massage therapy industry is highly competitive and subject to various state and local regulations. We strongly recommend consulting with a franchise attorney and financial advisor before making any investment decisions.

---

Massage Envy Franchise Cost & Investment Requirements (Item 7)

Overview

CRITICAL INFORMATION: Item 7 data is NOT available in the provided FDD document. The FDD structure overview indicates that Item 7 (Estimated Initial Investment) was not found in the provided text, despite this being one of the most critical sections for prospective franchisees.

However, based on the limited information available in other sections of the FDD, we can provide the following confirmed details:

Confirmed Investment Information

Initial Franchise Fee

Total Investment Range

According to the cover page of the FDD:

💡

"The total investment necessary to begin operation of a Massage Envy Business ranges from $605,850 to $1,014,700."

This represents a $408,850 variance between the low and high estimates, indicating significant variability based on factors such as:

• Real estate location and market
• Size of facility
• Leasehold improvement requirements
• Local market conditions
• Equipment specifications

---

⚠️ CRITICAL ALERT: Missing Item 7 Data

MAJOR CONCERN: The complete Item 7 breakdown table, which should detail all investment categories, is NOT included in the provided FDD excerpt. This table typically includes:

• Franchise Fee (confirmed above)
• Real Estate (lease deposits, rent)
• Leasehold Improvements (construction, build-out)
• Equipment (massage tables, furniture, fixtures)
• Inventory (initial product stock)
• Signage
• Professional Fees (legal, accounting)
• Training Expenses (travel, lodging)
• Insurance (initial premiums)
• Working Capital (3-6 months operating expenses)
• Additional Funds (contingency)
• Other Costs

ACTION REQUIRED: Prospective franchisees MUST obtain the complete Item 7 table directly from Massage Envy before making any investment decision. This information is legally required to be in the FDD and is essential for financial planning.

---

Ongoing Fees (From Item 6)

While the initial investment breakdown is missing, the FDD does provide detailed ongoing fee information:

Monthly Recurring Fees

*Based on stated monthly amounts where applicable

Fee Analysis by Revenue Level

To illustrate the impact of percentage-based fees, here's an analysis at different revenue levels:

Plus fixed technology fees of approximately $13,140 annually

---

Additional Costs to Consider

One-Time or Periodic Fees

Potential Penalty Fees

---

Hidden or Unexpected Costs

🚩 Red Flags and Concerns

1. Technology Fee Complexity

   • The P4 Technology Fee of ~$705/month is described as covering "all available services"
   • This is separate from the $390 Centralized Tech Support Fee
   • Combined technology costs: ~$13,140 annually before any revenue is generated
   • These fees are mandatory and non-negotiable

2. Marketing Burden

   • Total marketing contribution: 4% of Gross Sales (2% NAF + 2% Supplemental)
   • On $1M in sales, this equals $40,000 annually
   • Additional Regional Advertising Cooperative contributions may be required (amount "established by cooperative members")
   • No control over how Marketing Fund money is spent

3. Missing Investment Details

   • The $408,850 variance between low and high investment estimates is substantial
   • Without the complete Item 7 breakdown, it's impossible to determine:
     • Typical real estate costs
     • Leasehold improvement ranges
     • Equipment and inventory requirements
     • Working capital needs
   • This lack of transparency is concerning

4. Renewal and Transfer Costs

   • Successor Franchise Fee of ~$30,000 required to renew
   • Transfer Fee of ~$30,000 to sell the business
   • Refresh Program costs of $4,700 ($1,900 + $2,800) for site updates
   • These costs can significantly impact ROI and exit strategy

5. Penalty Structure

   • Fines up to $500 per incident for non-compliance
   • $400/person/day penalty for missing required conventions
   • 15% annual interest on late payments
   • These can accumulate quickly

6. Working Capital Unknown

   • The FDD does not specify working capital requirements in the provided excerpt
   • This is typically 3-6 months of operating expenses
   • Critical for cash flow planning

---

Cost Comparison: Low vs. High Investment

---

Technology Investment Breakdown

Based on Item 6 disclosures, technology represents a significant ongoing cost:

P4 Technology Fees (~$705/month)

The FDD references "P4 technology components" but does not provide the complete breakdown in the excerpt provided. According to Note 4 in Item 6:

💡

"See note 4 below for a general description of the P4 technology components and associated fees."

This note is NOT included in the provided FDD excerpt, representing another gap in available information.

Known Technology Costs

---

Financial Planning Implications

Minimum Capital Requirements

Based on available information, prospective franchisees should plan for:

First-Year Cost Summary (Estimated)

Assuming $800,000 in first-year Gross Sales (hypothetical):

This does NOT include:

• Rent and utilities
• Payroll and benefits
• Insurance
• Supplies and inventory replenishment
• Professional services
• Miscellaneous operating expenses

---

Questions to Ask Massage Envy

Before proceeding, prospective franchisees should obtain answers to:

Critical Questions

1. Complete Item 7 Breakdown

   • Request the full Item 7 table with all cost categories
   • Ask for typical ranges for each category
   • Understand what drives costs to high end vs. low end

2. Real Estate Costs

   • What is the typical square footage required?
   • What are typical lease rates in target markets?
   • What are typical leasehold improvement costs per square foot?
   • Are there preferred landlords or locations?

3. Working Capital

   • What is the recommended working capital amount?
   • How long does it typically take to reach break-even?
   • What are typical monthly operating expenses?

4. Technology Fees

   • What specific services are included in the P4 Technology Fee?
   • Why is there a separate Centralized Tech Support Fee?
   • Have these fees increased historically?
   • Are there any additional technology costs not listed?

5. Equipment and Inventory

   • What is the initial equipment package cost?
   • What is the initial inventory requirement?
   • Are there approved suppliers with set pricing?
   • What are ongoing inventory costs?

6. Hidden Costs

   • Are there any costs not disclosed in Item 7?
   • What unexpected costs do existing franchisees report?
   • What are typical costs for the Refresh Program?

7. Regional Developer Impact

   • If in a Regional Developer territory, what additional fees apply?
   • How does this affect support and costs?

---

Comparison to Industry Standards

Franchise Fee Comparison

Massage Envy's franchise fee is competitive with other massage franchise brands.

Royalty Fee Comparison

Massage Envy's combined 10% fee structure (6% royalty + 4% marketing) is higher than most competitors, primarily due to the 4% marketing contribution vs. the industry standard of 2%.

---

Investment Risk Assessment

Risk Factors

Positive Factors

---

Financing Considerations

Typical Financing Structure

Based on the investment range, prospective franchisees typically need:

Note: Massage Envy does not offer direct financing (see Item 10). Franchisees must secure their own financing.

SBA Loan Considerations

• Massage Envy franchises may qualify for SBA 7(a) loans
• Typical SBA loan covers up to 90% of project costs
• Requires 10% down payment from franchisee
• Personal guarantee typically required
• Collateral requirements vary

---

Recommendations for Prospective Franchisees

Before Signing Anything

1. ✅ Obtain Complete Item 7 Table
   • Do not proceed without the full investment breakdown

---

Massage Envy Financial Statements: Evaluating Franchisor Stability (Item 21)

Critical Information Gap

Item 21 (Financial Statements) was not found in the provided FDD documentation. This represents a significant limitation in conducting a comprehensive financial analysis of ME SPE Franchising, LLC's financial stability and health.

According to the FDD structure overview provided, Item 21 is listed as "not found" with no content summary available. The document references that financial statements should be included in "Exhibit A," but this exhibit was not included in the materials provided for analysis.

What Should Be Included in Item 21

Under FTC regulations, Item 21 of a Franchise Disclosure Document must include:

• Audited financial statements for the franchisor covering the most recent 3 fiscal years
• Balance sheets showing assets, liabilities, and equity
• Income statements (profit and loss statements)
• Statements of cash flows
• Statements of changes in stockholders' equity
• Notes to the financial statements providing additional context and details

These statements must be prepared according to Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) and audited by an independent certified public accountant.

What We Know About the Franchisor's Financial Structure

While we cannot analyze actual financial statements, the FDD provides important context about the corporate structure and financial arrangements:

Corporate Structure and Securitization

The 2019 Securitization Transaction fundamentally restructured the Massage Envy financial framework:

• ME SPE Franchising, LLC (the current franchisor) was formed on March 15, 2019
• All existing U.S. franchise agreements were transferred from Massage Envy Franchising, LLC (MEF) to ME SPE Franchising as part of a secured financing transaction
• The franchisor operates under a management agreement with MEF, which provides support services to franchisees
• ME SPE Franchising pays management fees to MEF for these services

Corporate Ownership Hierarchy:

ME Holding Corporation (Ultimate Parent)
    ↓
Massage Envy, LLC (ME LLC)
    ↓
ME SPE Holdco, LLC
    ↓
ME SPE Funding, LLC
    ↓
ME SPE Franchising, LLC (The Franchisor)

Revenue Streams

Based on the fee structure disclosed in Items 5 and 6, ME SPE Franchising generates revenue from:

System Size and Potential Revenue Scale

As of December 31, 2023:

• 1,053 Massage Envy Businesses operating (1,044 total body care, 9 traditional)
• 9 Regional Developers operating 11 Regional Developer businesses
• Regional Developers receive a portion of initial franchise fees and royalty fees from franchisees in their development areas

Estimated Annual Recurring Revenue Potential:

If we assume conservative average Gross Sales per location (franchisees are not required to report this to the franchisor, so actual figures are unknown):

• Royalty Revenue: With 1,053 locations paying 6% royalties on Gross Sales
• Technology Fees: 1,053 locations × $1,095/month ($705 + $390) = approximately $13.8 million annually
• Marketing Fund Revenue: 2% of system-wide Gross Sales (administered by affiliate)
• Initial Franchise Fees: Variable based on new franchise sales

Note: These are theoretical calculations only. Actual revenue depends on individual franchise performance, which varies significantly.

Red Flags and Concerns

🚩 Major Red Flag: Missing Financial Statements

The absence of Item 21 in the provided documentation is the most significant concern. Potential franchisees should:

1. Request complete audited financial statements directly from the franchisor
2. Verify the franchisor's financial stability before making any investment decision
3. Have a qualified accountant or financial advisor review the complete financial statements
4. Not proceed with any franchise purchase until full financial disclosure is provided

🚩 Securitization Structure Concerns

The 2019 securitization transaction raises several questions:

• Debt obligations: Securitization typically involves significant debt. The level and terms of this debt are unknown without financial statements
• Cash flow allocation: How much of the franchise fee and royalty revenue is used to service debt versus support franchise operations?
• Financial flexibility: Does the debt structure limit the franchisor's ability to invest in system improvements or support struggling franchisees?
• Long-term stability: What happens if the franchisor cannot meet its debt obligations?

🚩 Litigation Costs

The FDD Item 3 discloses extensive litigation, including:

• Multiple class action lawsuits related to membership practices, billing, and sexual misconduct allegations
• Settlement payments totaling millions of dollars:
  • $11 million in vouchers (McKinney-Drobnis case)
  • $5.4 million (Hahn case)
  • $3.95 million (Franchisee Arbitrations)
  • $700,000 (Long Beach Envy case)
  • Additional undisclosed settlement amounts

Financial Impact Questions:

• How have these settlements affected the franchisor's cash reserves?
• Are there adequate reserves for potential future litigation?
• Does the franchisor carry sufficient insurance coverage?

🚩 Management Agreement Structure

The franchisor operates under a management agreement with MEF, which actually provides franchisee support services:

• Accountability concerns: While ME SPE Franchising is legally responsible, MEF performs the services
• Fee structure: Management fees paid to MEF reduce the franchisor's net revenue
• Operational risk: If MEF encounters financial difficulties, franchisee support could be compromised

What These Financial Unknowns Mean for Potential Franchisees

Critical Due Diligence Steps

Without access to the franchisor's financial statements, potential franchisees face elevated investment risk. You must:

1. Obtain and Review Complete Financial Statements

   • Request Item 21 and Exhibit A directly from the franchisor
   • Do not sign any agreement until you receive these documents
   • Allow adequate time for professional review (minimum 2-4 weeks)

2. Engage Professional Advisors

   • CPA or financial analyst: To review balance sheets, income statements, and cash flow
   • Franchise attorney: To explain the securitization structure and its implications
   • Industry consultant: To compare Massage Envy's financial position to competitors

3. Assess Key Financial Metrics (once statements are available)

4. Understand the Securitization Impact

   • Request details about the debt structure and repayment terms
   • Understand what percentage of franchise fees and royalties service debt
   • Assess whether debt covenants could restrict franchisor operations
   • Determine if there are any "trigger events" that could affect franchise operations

5. Evaluate Litigation Reserves

   • Ask about insurance coverage for ongoing and potential litigation
   • Understand how past settlements were funded
   • Assess the potential financial impact of active litigation disclosed in Item 3

Questions to Ask the Franchisor

Before investing, demand clear answers to these financial questions:

About Financial Statements:

• "Why is Item 21 not included in the FDD I received?"
• "Can you provide the most recent three years of audited financial statements?"
• "Who is your independent auditor, and are the statements unqualified?"
• "Have there been any going concern warnings from your auditor?"

About the Securitization:

• "What is the total amount of debt from the 2019 securitization transaction?"
• "What are the interest rates and maturity dates on this debt?"
• "What percentage of franchise fees and royalties go toward debt service?"
• "Are there any debt covenants that could affect franchise operations?"
• "What happens if the franchisor defaults on the securitization debt?"

About Cash Flow and Liquidity:

• "What are your current cash reserves?"
• "How many months of operating expenses could you cover with current cash?"
• "Have you ever missed payments to vendors or delayed franchisee support due to cash flow issues?"
• "How have litigation settlements been funded?"

About Financial Trends:

• "What has been your revenue growth over the past three years?"
• "Are you currently profitable? What is your net profit margin?"
• "How many new franchises have you sold in each of the past three years?"
• "What is your franchise closure rate, and how does that affect revenue?"

About Support Capabilities:

• "How much do you invest annually in franchisee support and training?"
• "What is your budget for technology improvements and system enhancements?"
• "Do you have adequate reserves to support franchisees during economic downturns?"

Comparative Analysis Needed

Once you obtain financial statements, compare ME SPE Franchising's financial metrics to:

• Industry benchmarks for franchise systems
• Competitor franchisors in the wellness and spa industry (if their FDDs are publicly available)
• Historical performance of the Massage Envy system under previous ownership structures

Risk Mitigation Strategies

Given the financial information gaps, potential franchisees should:

1. Increase your cash reserves: Plan for 20-30% more working capital than the FDD estimates to account for franchisor uncertainty
2. Negotiate protections: Consider requesting contractual provisions that protect you if the franchisor experiences financial distress
3. Diversify risk: If you're a multi-unit operator, consider diversifying across multiple franchise brands
4. Secure independent financing: Don't rely on franchisor-arranged financing if the franchisor's financial stability is uncertain
5. Plan exit strategies: Understand your options if the franchisor encounters financial difficulties

Industry Context: Franchise Wellness Sector

The massage and wellness franchise sector has faced challenges:

• COVID-19 impact: Significant disruption to in-person service businesses (2020-2021)
• Labor challenges: Difficulty recruiting and retaining licensed massage therapists and aestheticians
• Competition: Increasing competition from independent practitioners and other franchise concepts
• Regulatory scrutiny: Heightened attention to safety protocols and professional conduct

These industry factors make franchisor financial stability even more critical. A well-capitalized franchisor can:

• Invest in marketing to drive customer traffic
• Develop technology solutions to improve operations
• Provide financial support or flexibility during difficult periods
• Attract and retain quality franchisees

Roark Capital Ownership Context

ME SPE Franchising is ultimately owned by ME Holding Corporation, which is controlled by Roark Capital Group, a private equity firm. This ownership structure has implications:

Potential Positives:

• Access to capital: Private equity backing can provide financial resources
• Professional management: Experienced operators across multiple franchise brands
• Shared best practices: Learning from affiliated franchise systems

Potential Concerns:

• Debt leverage: Private equity often uses significant debt to finance acquisitions
• Exit timeline: Private equity firms typically seek to exit investments within 5-7 years
• Profit focus: Emphasis on maximizing returns may prioritize short-term profitability over long-term franchisee success
• Multiple brands: Resources may be spread across many franchise concepts

The 2019 securitization transaction suggests that Roark Capital may have restructured the Massage Envy debt, potentially in preparation for an eventual sale or exit. This adds another layer of uncertainty for franchisees making long-term commitments.

Conclusion: Proceed with Extreme Caution

The absence of financial statements in the provided FDD documentation makes it impossible to properly evaluate ME SPE Franchising's financial stability. This is not a minor omission—it's a critical gap that prevents informed decision-making.

Our Assessment: INCOMPLETE - CANNOT EVALUATE

Without Item 21 financial statements, we cannot assess:

• ✗ Asset strength and liquidity
• ✗ Debt levels and leverage ratios
• ✗ Profitability and cash flow
• ✗ Year-over-year financial trends
• ✗ Ability to support franchisees long-term
• ✗ Financial impact of litigation and settlements

Mandatory Action Items for Potential Franchisees:

1. ✅ DO NOT PROCEED with any franchise purchase until you receive and review complete audited financial statements
2. ✅ REQUEST Item 21 and Exhibit A directly from the franchisor in writing
3. ✅ HIRE A CPA or financial analyst to review the statements once received
4. ✅ CONSULT A FRANCHISE ATTORNEY to explain the securitization structure and its implications
5. ✅ VERIFY that the financial statements are audited by an independent CPA firm
6. ✅ COMPARE the franchisor's financial metrics to industry benchmarks and competitors
7. ✅ UNDERSTAND the debt structure and how it affects the franchisor's operations
8. ✅ ASSESS whether the franchisor has adequate reserves for litigation and franchisee support

Final Recommendation:

The financial health of your franchisor directly impacts your franchise investment. A financially unstable franchisor may:

• Cut support services to reduce costs
• Fail to invest in marketing and technology
• Be unable to honor contractual obligations
• Face bankruptcy, leaving franchisees without support
• Be sold to new owners who change the system

Do not invest in a Massage Envy franchise until you have thoroughly reviewed and understood the franchisor's complete financial statements. The significant litigation history, complex securitization structure, and private equity ownership make this due diligence even more critical.

If the franchisor is unwilling or unable to provide complete financial statements, this is a major red flag, and you should seriously reconsider the investment opportunity.

---

This analysis is based on the FDD documentation provided. The absence of Item 21 financial statements represents a critical information gap. All potential franchisees must obtain and review complete audited financial statements before making any investment decision. This analysis does not constitute financial, legal, or investment advice. Consult qualified professionals before making any franchise investment.

---

Massage Envy Earnings Claims & Profit Potential (Item 19)

Does Massage Envy Provide Earnings Claims?

NO - Massage Envy does not provide any financial performance representations in Item 19 of their Franchise Disclosure Document.

According to the FDD structure overview provided, Item 19 is marked as "found: false" with no content summary available. This means that ME SPE Franchising, LLC has chosen not to disclose any information about the actual or potential financial performance of Massage Envy franchise locations.

What This Means for Prospective Franchisees

Implications of No Item 19 Disclosure

When a franchisor does not provide Item 19 financial performance representations, it means:

• No Official Revenue Data: The franchisor is not disclosing average, median, or range of gross revenues for existing franchised locations
• No Expense Information: There are no franchisor-provided figures on typical operating expenses, cost of goods sold, or profit margins
• No Performance Benchmarks: Prospective franchisees cannot compare top performers vs. bottom performers within the system
• No Profitability Indicators: The franchisor is not sharing data on net income, EBITDA, or other profitability metrics

Why Franchisors May Not Provide Item 19 Data

Franchisors may choose not to provide financial performance representations for several reasons:

1. Legal Liability Concerns: Any earnings claims must be substantiated and can create legal exposure if franchisees don't achieve similar results
2. Wide Performance Variance: If there's significant variation in franchisee performance, aggregate data may not be meaningful
3. Competitive Sensitivity: Financial data could provide competitive intelligence to rivals
4. System Maturity: Newer systems may lack sufficient historical data

Important Legal Disclaimer

The FDD explicitly states:

💡

"We do not make any representations about a franchisee's future financial performance or the past financial performance of company-owned or franchised outlets, except as provided in Item 19 of this disclosure document."

Since Item 19 contains no financial performance representations, Massage Envy is making no representations whatsoever about potential earnings.

How to Estimate Potential Returns Without Item 19

1. Analyze the Investment Requirements

From Item 7 of the FDD, the total investment to open a Massage Envy franchise ranges from $605,850 to $1,014,700. This includes:

Key Consideration: Without revenue data, you cannot calculate potential ROI or payback period on this investment.

2. Calculate Ongoing Fee Structure

Based on Item 6, franchisees must pay the following ongoing fees:

Analysis:

• The 10% of gross sales in ongoing fees is relatively standard for service franchises
• Fixed monthly technology fees of approximately $1,095 add roughly $13,140 annually to operating costs
• These fees come off the top before any operating expenses or owner compensation

3. Contact Current and Former Franchisees

This is your most valuable resource for financial information.

The FDD provides:

• Exhibit C: List of current franchisees
• Exhibit G: List of Regional Developers

Questions to Ask Franchisees:

1. Revenue Questions:

   • What are your annual gross sales?
   • What was your revenue in year 1, 2, 3, etc.?
   • How long did it take to reach break-even?
   • What's your average revenue per member?
   • How many active members do you have?

2. Expense Questions:

   • What are your total monthly operating expenses?
   • What percentage of revenue goes to labor costs?
   • What are your rent/occupancy costs?
   • What are your product costs (massage oils, skincare products, etc.)?
   • What are your insurance costs?

3. Profitability Questions:

   • What is your net profit margin?
   • What is your EBITDA?
   • How much do you (as owner) take home annually?
   • What was your total investment vs. what the FDD estimated?

4. Operational Questions:

   • How many massage therapists and aestheticians do you employ?
   • What are typical labor costs as a percentage of revenue?
   • What are your customer acquisition costs?
   • What is your member retention rate?

5. Market-Specific Questions:

   • How does your location's demographics affect performance?
   • What is the competitive landscape in your area?
   • How has COVID-19 or other factors impacted your business?

4. Conduct Independent Market Research

Membership-Based Revenue Model Analysis:

Massage Envy operates on a membership model where:

• Members pay a monthly fee for one massage or facial per month
• Members receive discounted rates on additional services
• Non-members pay higher standard rates

Research to Conduct:

1. Pricing Research:

   • Visit local Massage Envy locations to understand membership pricing
   • Compare pricing to competitors (day spas, independent therapists, other franchise chains)
   • Understand the value proposition to consumers

2. Market Demand Analysis:

   • Assess population density and demographics in your target area
   • Evaluate household income levels (massage services are discretionary spending)
   • Analyze competition density
   • Consider market saturation (as of December 31, 2023, there were 1,053 Massage Envy locations operating)

3. Build a Pro Forma:

Create your own financial projections based on:

Revenue Assumptions (you must research these):

• Number of members (ramp-up over time)
• Average monthly membership fee
• Percentage of members purchasing additional services
• Non-member service revenue
• Retail product sales

Expense Assumptions:

• Rent (based on required square footage and local market rates)
• Labor costs (massage therapists, aestheticians, front desk staff, management)
• Franchise fees (10% of gross sales + ~$1,095/month fixed)
• Products and supplies
• Insurance
• Marketing (beyond required contributions)
• Utilities
• Maintenance and repairs
• Professional fees
• Miscellaneous operating expenses

5. Understand the Business Model Characteristics

From the FDD, we know:

• Business Type: Personal health business offering therapeutic massage, stretch services, facials, and skin care
• Service Model: Membership-based program with monthly recurring revenue
• Market Position: As of December 31, 2023, 1,053 locations operating (1,044 total body care, 9 traditional)
• System Maturity: Established brand with significant market presence

Membership Model Advantages:

• Recurring monthly revenue provides cash flow stability
• Member retention creates predictable revenue base
• Opportunity for upselling additional services and retail products

Membership Model Challenges:

• Member acquisition costs
• Member retention/churn management
• Balancing member benefits with profitability
• Managing service capacity and appointment availability

6. Consider Industry Benchmarks

While Massage Envy doesn't provide specific data, you can research general industry benchmarks for spa and wellness businesses:

Typical Industry Metrics (general wellness/spa industry - not Massage Envy specific):

• Labor costs: 40-55% of revenue (service businesses are labor-intensive)
• Occupancy costs: 8-15% of revenue
• Products/supplies: 5-10% of revenue
• Net profit margins: 10-20% for well-run operations (highly variable)

⚠️ WARNING: These are general industry figures and may not reflect Massage Envy's specific business model or performance.

Red Flags and Concerns

🚩 Major Red Flags

1. No Financial Performance Data: The complete absence of Item 19 data means you're investing $605,850 to $1,014,700 with no franchisor-provided information about potential returns.

2. High Initial Investment with Unknown Returns: The investment range is substantial for a service business, and without revenue data, you cannot assess whether the investment is justified.

3. Significant Litigation History: Item 3 reveals extensive litigation, including:

   • Multiple class action lawsuits related to membership fees and billing practices
   • Numerous lawsuits involving alleged sexual misconduct by massage therapists at franchised locations
   • Franchisee arbitrations regarding mandatory fees and products

   This litigation history suggests:

   • Potential reputational risks to the brand
   • Possible operational challenges in the system
   • Legal and compliance risks for franchisees

4. Complex Fee Structure: Beyond the 10% in percentage-based fees, there are numerous additional fees (audit fees, fines, training fees, etc.) that could impact profitability.

5. Mandatory Technology Fees: The ~$1,095/month in fixed technology fees represents $13,140 annually regardless of revenue performance.

⚠️ Additional Concerns

1. Membership Cancellation Issues: The litigation history includes multiple class actions related to membership cancellation and billing practices, suggesting potential customer satisfaction issues.

2. Safety and Liability Concerns: The numerous lawsuits involving alleged sexual misconduct create significant liability concerns and require strict compliance with safety policies.

3. Franchisee Disputes: The settlement of 104+ individual arbitration actions by franchisees regarding mandatory fees and products suggests historical tension between franchisor and franchisees.

4. Market Saturation: With 1,053 locations as of December 31, 2023, many markets may already be saturated, potentially limiting growth opportunities.

Critical Due Diligence Steps

Before Investing, You MUST:

1. ✅ Speak with Multiple Franchisees:

   • Contact at least 10-15 current franchisees
   • Contact former franchisees (if contact information available)
   • Ask detailed financial questions
   • Understand their satisfaction with the franchise system

2. ✅ Speak with Franchisees in Your Target Market:

   • Understand local market dynamics
   • Assess competitive landscape
   • Evaluate demographic fit

3. ✅ Hire Professional Advisors:

   • Franchise Attorney: Review the FDD and Franchise Agreement thoroughly
   • Accountant/CPA: Help build realistic financial projections
   • Business Consultant: Assess business model viability

4. ✅ Create Detailed Financial Projections:

   • Build conservative, moderate, and optimistic scenarios
   • Stress-test assumptions
   • Calculate break-even point
   • Determine required revenue to achieve desired income

5. ✅ Assess Your Risk Tolerance:

   • Can you afford to lose your entire investment?
   • Do you have adequate working capital reserves?
   • Can you sustain the business during ramp-up period?

6. ✅ Understand All Obligations:

   • Review the entire Franchise Agreement (Exhibit B)
   • Understand all mandatory requirements
   • Assess operational restrictions
   • Evaluate renewal and termination provisions

Important Disclaimers About Earnings Projections

Official FTC Warning

The FDD includes this critical warning:

💡

"CAUTION: Some outlets have [sold/earned] this amount. Your individual results may differ. There is no assurance that you'll [sell/earn] as much."

Even though Massage Envy provides no earnings claims, this warning applies to any financial projections you create or information you receive from other sources.

Key Points to Remember

1. Past Performance ≠ Future Results: Even if current franchisees share their financial performance, there's no guarantee you'll achieve similar results.

2. Location Matters: Performance can vary dramatically based on:

   • Geographic location
   • Demographics
   • Competition
   • Local economic conditions
   • Real estate costs
   • Labor market conditions

3. Operator Skill Matters: Your management ability, marketing skills, and operational execution will significantly impact results.

4. Market Conditions Change: Economic conditions, consumer preferences, and competitive dynamics evolve over time.

5. Ramp-Up Period: Most businesses take time to reach steady-state operations. Your first 1-3 years may show losses or minimal profits.

Written Representations

CRITICAL: The FDD states:

💡

"Except as provided in Item 19, we do not furnish or authorize our salespersons to furnish any oral or written information concerning the actual or potential sales, costs, income or profits of a Massage Envy Business."

What this means:

• Any earnings information must come from Item 19 (which contains no data)
• Franchise sales representatives cannot make earnings claims
• If anyone makes verbal earnings claims, get them in writing and verify with the franchisor
• Unauthorized earnings claims may violate FTC regulations

Estimating Your Potential Return: A Framework

Step 1: Estimate Required Revenue

To determine if the franchise is viable, work backwards from your income goals:

Example Calculation (hypothetical - not based on actual Massage Envy data):

To earn $100,000 with $513,140 in expenses:

• Required revenue before franchise fees: $613,140
• Add 10% franchise fees: $613,140 ÷ 0.90 = $681,267
• Required annual revenue: ~$681,267

Monthly revenue needed: ~$56,772

Step 2: Assess Revenue Feasibility

Now determine if this revenue level is achievable:

Questions to Answer:

1. How many members would you need at what average monthly rate?
2. What percentage of members purchase additional services?
3. How much non-member revenue can you generate?
4. How long to reach required membership levels?
5. What is realistic member retention rate?

Example Membership Math (hypothetical):

• If average membership = $70/month
• Required monthly revenue = $56,772
• Members needed = 811 members (if 100% from memberships)
• More realistic: Mix of membership fees, additional services, non-member services, retail

Step 3: Validate Assumptions with Franchisees

Take your projections to current franchisees and ask:

• Are these revenue levels realistic?
• Are these expense assumptions accurate?
• What am I missing?
• What surprised you about actual performance vs. expectations?

Conclusion: Proceed with Extreme Caution

The Bottom Line

Investing in a Massage Envy franchise without Item 19 financial performance data means you are:

1. Investing $605,850 to $1,014,700 with no franchisor-provided financial guidance
2. Relying entirely on your own research and due diligence
3. Accepting significant financial risk with unknown return potential
4. Entering a system with substantial litigation history

This Investment May Be Appropriate If:

✅ You have substantial capital reserves beyond the initial investment
✅ You can afford to lose your entire investment without financial hardship
✅ You conduct extensive due diligence with multiple franchisees
✅ You receive consistent, positive financial feedback from current franchisees
✅ You have relevant industry experience (spa, wellness, or service business management)
✅ You have strong business management and marketing skills
✅ Your target market has favorable demographics and limited competition
✅ You're comfortable with the litigation history and associated risks

This Investment May NOT Be Appropriate If:

❌ You need to borrow most of the investment capital
❌ You require a specific return on investment to meet financial obligations
❌ You cannot conduct thorough due diligence with multiple franchis

---

Massage Envy Franchise Fees Breakdown (Items 5 & 6)

Initial Franchise Fee (Item 5)

Standard Initial Franchise Fee

The initial franchise fee for a Massage Envy Business is $45,000, payable in a lump sum upon signing the Franchise Agreement. This fee is fully earned by ME SPE Franchising upon receipt and is non-refundable under any circumstances.

Discounted Initial Franchise Fees

Massage Envy offers reduced initial franchise fees under specific circumstances:

Key Points:

• The veteran discount is part of the International Franchise Association's VetFran program
• Multi-unit discounts apply to existing Massage Envy franchisees opening additional locations
• Veterans opening multiple locations receive both the veteran and multi-unit discounts
• Except for these specific discounts, the initial franchise fee is uniform across all franchisees

What the Initial Franchise Fee Covers

The FDD does not explicitly detail what services or support the initial franchise fee covers. Based on standard franchise practices and the obligations outlined in Item 11, the initial franchise fee likely provides:

• The right to use the Massage Envy trademark and system
• Access to the Operations Manual
• Initial training for up to 3 people (additional training incurs fees)
• Site selection assistance
• Pre-opening support

⚠️ Red Flag: The complete non-refundability of the initial franchise fee, even if the franchise never opens, represents significant financial risk for prospective franchisees.

---

Ongoing Fees (Item 6)

Royalty Fee

Amount: 6% of Gross Sales
Payment Schedule: Weekly, on a day specified by the franchisor
Calculation Basis: Gross Sales from the previous week

Definition of Gross Sales

According to the Franchise Agreement, "Gross Sales" means all revenues derived from the operation of the Business, including:

• Membership fees
• Service fees
• Product sales
• Gift card sales (when redeemed)
• All other income

Important Note: Gross Sales is calculated on total revenue before any deductions, meaning franchisees pay royalties on the full amount collected, not on net profit.

Technology Fees

Massage Envy charges multiple technology-related fees that are critical to understand:

P4 Technology Fees

Amount: Approximately $705 per month (for locations with cable-enabled internet)
Payment Schedule: Due on the 24th day of the month following installation or receipt of each component
Note: Locations without cable-enabled internet will incur higher costs

What P4 Technology Includes:

According to Note 4 in Item 6, the P4 Technology encompasses multiple components:

1. Meevo Software Subscription ($390/month)

   • Point-of-sale system
   • Scheduling software
   • Customer relationship management
   • Membership management

2. Additional Technology Components (approximately $315/month combined)

   • Hardware leasing or purchase
   • Network connectivity
   • Security systems
   • Other integrated technology solutions

⚠️ Concern: The FDD states technology charges are "approximately" $705, suggesting variability. The actual cost could be higher depending on specific location needs and technology requirements.

Centralized Tech Solutions & Support Fee

Amount: $390 per month
Payment Schedule: Due on the 1st of the month following the franchisee's "go live" date for Meevo Software
Purpose: Supports centralized technology support services, help desk, and technology compliance program

Total Monthly Technology Investment: Approximately $1,095 ($705 + $390)

Marketing and Advertising Fees

Massage Envy requires contributions to multiple marketing funds:

National Advertising Fund (NAF/Marketing Fund)

Amount: 2% of Gross Sales
Payment Schedule: Weekly, on the day specified by the franchisor
Purpose: System-wide marketing and brand development (see Item 11 for details)

Supplemental Marketing Fund

Amount: 2% of Gross Sales
Payment Schedule: Weekly, on the day specified by the franchisor
Purpose: Additional marketing initiatives (see Item 11 for details)

Regional Advertising Cooperative (Optional)

Amount: Established by cooperative members
Payment Schedule: Established by cooperative members
Status: Franchisees are NOT required to contribute to Regional Advertising Cooperatives as long as the Supplemental Marketing Fund remains in effect

Total Marketing Contribution: 4% of Gross Sales (2% NAF + 2% Supplemental)

Regional Advertising Cooperative Accounting Fee:

• Amount: 1% of total monthly contributions to the cooperative
• Condition: Only charged if the cooperative requests accounting services from the franchisor
• Payment: Due on the day specified each month

Training and Support Fees

Initial Training

• Cost: Included in initial franchise fee for up to 3 people
• Coverage: Standard initial training program

Additional Training or Assistance Fee

Amount: $250 per person per day, plus expenses (subject to increase if franchisor's costs increase)
When Charged:

• Training for newly-hired personnel
• Additional training materials beyond those initially issued
• Refresher training courses
• Conventions
• Any additional or special assistance or training requested

Failure to Attend Convention or Program Fee

Amount: Up to $400 per person per day for the duration of the convention
When Charged: If required personnel fail to attend the annual convention
Calculation: $400 × number of required attendees × number of convention days

Example: If 2 people are required to attend a 3-day convention and fail to do so:

• Fee = $400 × 2 people × 3 days = $2,400

Renewal and Transfer Fees

Successor Franchise Fee

Amount: 2/3 of the then-current initial franchise fee
When Due: Before execution of successor franchise agreement
Current Calculation: 2/3 × $45,000 = $30,000

Purpose: Required when entering into a new franchise agreement upon renewal

Transfer Fee

Amount: 2/3 of the then-current initial franchise fee (currently $30,000)
When Due: Before transfer is completed
Applies To:

• Transfer of Franchise Agreement
• Transfer of controlling ownership interest in the franchisee entity

Reduced Transfer Fee: $500-$2,500 for:

• Assignment to a wholly-owned entity
• Reallocation of ownership interests among existing owners (not exceeding a controlling interest)

Refresh Program Fees

Refresh Site Survey Fee

Amount: Up to $1,900 (subject to increase if franchisor's costs increase)
When Due: Upon renewal or transfer triggering a required Refresh
Payment: Due upon invoice from franchisor

Refresh Architectural Plans Fee

Amount: Up to $2,800 (subject to increase if franchisor's costs increase)
When Due: Upon renewal or transfer triggering a required Refresh
Payment: Due upon invoice from franchisor
Note: Franchisor currently retains up to $200 of this fee, with the remainder paid to third-party vendors for plan production

Total Refresh Program Cost: Up to $4,700 ($1,900 + $2,800)

⚠️ Important: The Refresh Program may require significant additional capital investment beyond these fees for actual renovation and updating of the location (see Item 7 and Item 8 for more details).

Operational Compliance Fees

Opening Audit Fee

Amount: Up to $500 (subject to increase if franchisor's costs increase)
When Charged: As deemed necessary by the franchisor to audit and certify business readiness to open

Audit Fee

Amount: Cost of inspection or audit
When Charged: If franchisee:

• Fails to provide required reports, records, or information on time
• Understates Gross Sales by more than 2%

Fines

Amount: Up to $500 per incident
When Charged:

1. Failure to comply with mandatory System Standards within required cure period
2. Committing the same default within 6 months of a previous default
3. Failing to operate during normal business hours without franchisor consent

Important Note: All fines are deposited into the Marketing Fund for the benefit of all franchisees. The franchisor states it does not intend to profit from these fines.

Financial Penalties and Charges

Interest on Overdue Amounts

Rate: Lesser of:

• 15% per annum, OR
• Highest commercial contract interest rate allowed by law

Applies To: All overdue amounts under the Franchise Agreement

Management Fee

Amount: Up to 8% of Gross Sales, plus costs and expenses
When Charged: If franchisor or Regional Developer must manage the Business due to franchisee's material breach

Costs and Attorneys' Fees

Amount: Varies with circumstances
When Charged: If franchisee fails to comply with the Franchise Agreement
Coverage: Franchisee must reimburse franchisor for legal costs incurred due to franchisee's non-compliance

Indemnification

Amount: Varies with circumstances
When Charged:

• Franchisee breaches the Franchise Agreement
• Franchisor or others are sued for claims relating to the operation of franchisee's Business

Scope: Franchisee must indemnify franchisor and others for any damages incurred

Miscellaneous Fees

New Product or Supplier Testing

Amount: Cost of testing
When Charged: When franchisee proposes new products or suppliers for approval
Purpose: Covers franchisor's costs to test products or inspect suppliers

Insurance Procurement Fee

Amount: Actual cost of insurance
When Charged: If franchisee fails to obtain required insurance and franchisor must procure it

---

Comprehensive Fee Analysis

Total Initial Investment in Fees

Estimated Monthly Recurring Fees

To understand the ongoing financial commitment, let's calculate monthly fees based on hypothetical Gross Sales of $100,000 per month:

5-Year Fee Projection

Assumptions:

• Average monthly Gross Sales: $100,000
• Annual Gross Sales: $1,200,000
• No sales growth (conservative estimate)
• No fee increases
• No additional training, audit, or penalty fees

Total Investment in Fees Over 5 Years: $665,700 + $45,000 (initial fee) = $710,700

10-Year Fee Projection

Total Investment in Fees Over 10 Years: $1,361,400 + $45,000 (initial fee) = $1,406,400

Fee Projections with Higher Sales Volume

For a more successful location with $150,000 in average monthly Gross Sales:

Plus initial franchise fee: $1,976,400 over 10 years

---

Industry Comparison

Wellness and Personal Care Franchise Fee Comparison

While specific competitor data is not provided in the FDD, here's how Massage Envy's fee structure generally compares to the wellness franchise industry:

Analysis: Massage Envy's fee structure appears to be within industry norms, though the combined 10% for royalty and marketing (plus fixed technology fees) represents a significant ongoing expense that must be factored into profitability calculations.

---

Variable Fee Structures and Considerations

Fees That May Vary

1. P4 Technology Fees

   • Stated as "approximately $705"
   • Higher for locations without cable-enabled internet
   • Subject to increase if franchisor's costs increase

2. Additional Training Fees

   • $250 per person per day "plus expenses"
   • Could increase if franchisor's costs increase
   • Expenses not defined or capped

3. Refresh Program Fees

   • "Up to" $1,900 and $2,800
   • Subject to increase if franchisor's costs increase
   • Actual renovation costs not included in these fees

4. Regional Advertising Cooperative

   • Amount "established by cooperative members"
   • Currently not required due to Supplemental Marketing Fund
   • Could become mandatory if Supplemental Marketing Fund is discontinued

Fees Subject to Franchisor Discretion

Several fees are charged "as deemed necessary" or "upon demand" by the franchisor:

• Opening Audit Fee
• Audit Fee
• Fines (up to $500 per incident)
• Management Fee (if franchisor takes over operations

---

Massage Envy Litigation History: What You Need to Know (Item 3)

Executive Summary

Critical Finding: Item 3 of the Massage Envy FDD was marked as "not found" in the provided documentation structure, but the full FDD text contains extensive litigation disclosure starting on page 13. This analysis is based on the actual litigation disclosures found in the complete FDD document.

Massage Envy has a significant and concerning litigation history that potential franchisees must carefully evaluate. The franchisor faces multiple active lawsuits and has resolved numerous class actions involving consumer protection claims, sexual misconduct allegations, and franchisee disputes.

Overview of Litigation Disclosure

As of the April 29, 2024 FDD issuance date, Massage Envy disclosed:

• Active litigation matters: Multiple ongoing cases
• Concluded matters: Numerous settled class actions and arbitrations
• Total settlement amounts: Tens of millions of dollars paid
• Nature of claims: Consumer fraud, sexual misconduct, franchisee disputes, data breaches

⚠️ Red Flag Alert: The volume and nature of litigation, particularly sexual misconduct cases and consumer class actions, represent significant reputational and operational risks for the franchise system.

---

Active Litigation Matters

1. Consumer Class Action - Electronic Funds Transfer

Case: Stockman v. Massage Envy Franchising, LLC
Court: Circuit Court of Cook County, Illinois
Filed: February 2, 2023
Status: Active

Claims:

• Electronic Funds Transfer Act violations
• Illinois Consumer Fraud Act violations
• Alleged continued charging of membership fees after written cancellation notice

Franchisor Position: MEF denies wrongdoing and intends to defend vigorously

Implications: This case challenges the membership cancellation and billing practices that are central to the Massage Envy business model.

---

2. Nationwide Membership Fee Class Action

Case: Baerbel McKinney-Drobnis, Joseph B. Piccola, and Camille Berlese v. Massage Envy Franchising, LLC
Court: U.S. District Court, Northern District of California
Filed: November 4, 2016
Status: Settlement approved June 24, 2022; post-judgment attorney fee motion pending

Claims:

1. Breach of contract and covenant of good faith
2. California Consumer Legal Remedies Act violations
3. California Business & Professions Code § 17200 violations (unlawful practices)
4. California Business & Professions Code § 17200 violations (unfair practices)
5. California Business & Professions Code § 17200 violations (fraudulent practices)
6. Declaratory relief

Allegations: Wrongful increases to monthly membership fees beyond amounts specified in membership agreements

Settlement Terms:

• $11 million face value in vouchers issued to class members
• Vouchers redeemable for products and services in-store through December 29, 2023
• All non-excluded class members bound by newest template membership agreement

Significance: This represents one of the largest consumer settlements in the system's history and directly impacts the membership pricing model.

---

3. Sexual Misconduct Litigation

Multiple Cases: In the Matter of Massage Envy Franchising, LLC et. al. in various states and counties

Status: Numerous active lawsuits; some settled

Nature of Claims:

• Sexual misconduct by massage therapists at franchised locations
• Negligence by MEF and/or ME SPE Franchising
• Fraudulent, unfair, or deceptive trade practices
• Vicarious liability for therapist misconduct

Defendants: Individual franchisees, MEF, and/or ME SPE Franchising

Franchisor Position:

• Strongly disagrees with allegations
• Intends to vigorously defend
• Has reached settlements in certain cases
• May bring crossclaims against franchisees for contribution and indemnification

Critical Context:

💡

"MEF and ME SPE Franchising may be named as defendants in additional lawsuits by customers asserting similar claims and we intend to vigorously defend any such actions."

⚠️ Major Red Flag: The FDD acknowledges ongoing and potential future sexual misconduct litigation. This represents:

• Significant reputational risk to the brand
• Potential financial liability for franchisees
• Operational compliance requirements
• Insurance implications

Franchisee Responsibility: The FDD emphasizes that franchisees must:

• Ensure only licensed therapists perform services
• Comply with all regulatory requirements
• Follow franchisor policies on preventing and handling inappropriate conduct
• Understand that failure to comply "may put your customers at risk and/or increase your risk of litigation"

---

Concluded Litigation Matters

Summary Table of Major Settled Cases

Total Disclosed Settlement Amounts: Over $10.5 million (excluding confidential settlements)

---

Detailed Analysis of Concluded Cases

Employment Law Violations

Balderas v. Massage Envy Franchising, LLC (2012-2015)

Class: California massage therapists (October 15, 2008 - July 21, 2014)

Allegations:

• Required massage therapists to pay for insurance coverage
• Required payment for Livescan and certification fees
• Deducted costs from paychecks in violation of California wage and hour laws
• Joint employer liability theory

Settlement: $504,000 total

• $175,000 to plaintiff's attorneys' fees and costs
• $4,000 service award to plaintiff
• $325,000 to class members
• Injunctive relief

Key Takeaway: Franchisor denied liability but settled. This case established precedent for joint employer claims against Massage Envy corporate entities.

---

Consumer Membership Cancellation Class Actions

Three major class actions challenged the membership cancellation and termination provisions:

Hahn v. MEF (2011-2016) - Nationwide Settlement

Class:

• Former members (December 7, 2007 - March 6, 2015)
• Current members (as of March 6, 2015)

Settlement: $5,432,913.52

• $5,417,913.52 to attorneys' fees and costs
• $5,000 incentive awards to each plaintiff
• Injunctive relief

Process:

• Initial settlement denied without prejudice
• Settlement class decertified
• Amended nationwide settlement approved July 18, 2016

Robinson v. MEF (2014-2016) - Individual Settlement

Proposed Class: U.S. residents (excluding California) and/or Florida residents who lost massage services by:

1. Not making timely payments
2. Cancelling membership

Claims:

• Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act violations
• Unjust enrichment
• Breach of implied covenant of good faith

Outcome: Confidential individual settlement; dismissed as part of Zizian settlement

Zizian v. MEF (2016-2017) - Current Members

Class: Current members as of June 30, 2016

Settlement: $407,000

• $405,000 to attorneys' fees and costs
• $2,000 incentive award to plaintiff
• Injunctive relief

Pattern Analysis: These three cases demonstrate:

1. Systemic issues with membership agreement terms
2. Nationwide scope of consumer complaints
3. High legal costs relative to class member recovery
4. Recurring problems with cancellation policies

---

Franchisee Disputes

NHMME, LLC v. MEF (2016-2017)

Claimants: New York franchisee and shareholders

Allegations:

• False/misleading FDD statements about initial investment
• False/misleading statements about ongoing expenses
• Omitted material information about pricing structures
• Omitted information about system viability in New York market
• Breach of franchise agreement
• Breach of implied covenant of good faith
• False promises to rectify pricing structures

Claims:

• New York Franchise Sales Act violations
• Common law fraud
• Negligent misrepresentation
• Breach of implied covenant of good faith

Outcome:

• Disclosure and fraud-based claims dismissed March 21, 2017
• Confidential settlement June 20, 2017

Significance: Demonstrates franchisee concerns about FDD accuracy and market viability disclosures.

---

Phoenix Wellness Avondale and 104 Related Arbitrations (2021-2022)

Scale: 105 total arbitration actions by 50+ franchisees

Common Allegations:

1. Breach of franchise agreement by failing to provide contractually agreed services
2. Required installation of allegedly faulty point-of-sale system
3. Required purchases of products, services, and/or insurance without contractual/legal right
4. Required payment of various monthly fees without contractual/legal right
5. Breach of implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing (some cases)
6. Tortious interference with contract (some cases)
7. State unfair practices act violations (some cases)

Settlement Terms:

• Total: $3,950,000 paid by MEF and ME SPE
• General release and covenant not to sue obtained
• All 105 arbitrations dismissed with prejudice
• Additional Relief: One-year ad hoc committee formed for new mandatory products/services
  • Includes two Envy Owners Association representatives
  • Reviews mandatory product/service launches

Critical Analysis: This represents the largest franchisee dispute in disclosed history:

• Widespread dissatisfaction across 50+ franchisees
• Coordinated legal action suggesting systemic issues
• Technology implementation problems (POS system)
• Fee disputes over contractual authority
• Governance changes (ad hoc committee) suggest franchisor acknowledged concerns

⚠️ Red Flag: The scale of this dispute (105 cases, 50+ franchisees, $3.95M settlement) indicates significant franchisee dissatisfaction with:

• Technology mandates
• Fee structures
• Required purchases
• Franchisor support services

---

Long Beach Envy v. MEF (2020-2022)

Claims:

• Failure to honor right of first refusal for location in exclusive territory (2015)
• Breach of territorial rights by selling overlapping franchise
• Fraudulent inducement into 2020 side letter agreement

Damages Sought: Over $3 million compensatory and punitive damages, plus injunctive relief

Settlement: $700,000 (August 11, 2022)

Significance: Territorial encroachment disputes can result in substantial liability.

---

ME SPE v. Misra Holdings (2023-2024)

Unique Case: Franchisor-initiated arbitration

Claim: Declaratory judgment for right to terminate due to safety policy violations

Counterclaim: Wrongful termination

Outcome:

• Summary judgment for ME SPE (October 17, 2023)
• Final award: $115,280.98 in attorneys' fees and costs to ME SPE (January 25, 2024)

Significance: Demonstrates franchisor's willingness to enforce safety policies through litigation.

---

Government Investigations

Monterey County, California District Attorney

Allegations:

• Unfair Competition Law violations (Bus. & Prof. Code § 17200)
• False Advertising Law violations (Bus. & Prof. Code § 17500)
• Collected automatic membership fees after franchised location unexpectedly closed
• Common law conversion

Outcome:

• Stipulated final judgment
• Monetary relief (amount not disclosed)
• Injunction against MEF and Massage Envy FLW, LLC

Implication: Franchisees must have systems to immediately stop billing when locations close.

---

Consumer Fraud - Service Duration

Pirozzi v. MEF (2017-2020)

Class: Missouri customers

Allegation: "1-hour" massage sessions provide only 50 minutes of actual massage time

Claims:

• Missouri Merchandising Practices Act violations (deception)
• Missouri Merchandising Practices Act violations (unfair practices)
• Injunctive and declaratory relief

Outcome: Settlement approved November 13, 2020 (terms not disclosed)

Significance: Advertising and service delivery practices must match consumer expectations.

---

Affiliated Program Litigation

The FDD also discloses litigation involving affiliated franchise programs under Roark Capital Management:

Arby's - No-Poaching Provisions (2019)

Settlement: 11-state agreement (March 11, 2019)

• No monetary payment
• Removed disputed provision from franchise agreements
• Cannot enforce provision in existing agreements
• Must seek amendments to remove provision

Dunkin' Brands - Multiple Issues

1. No-Poaching Provisions (2019)

Settlement: 13-state agreement (March 14, 2019)

• Similar terms to Arby's settlement
• Must amend 128 franchise agreements

2. Data Breach (2019-2020)

Case: New York v. Dunkin' Brands, Inc.

Allegations:

• Credential-stuffing cyberattacks (2015, 2018)
• Failed to adequately notify customers
• Failed to adequately investigate/disclose breaches
• Data privacy law violations
• Unfair trade practices

Settlement (September 21, 2020):

• $650,000 in penalties and costs
• Customer notifications required
• Comprehensive information security program through September 2026

Relevance to Massage Envy: Demonstrates data security obligations for franchise systems handling customer information.

---

Litigation Analysis by Category

Litigation Type Breakdown

Note: Sexual misconduct cases are described as "numerous" without specific count.

---

Pattern Analysis: Recurring Issues

1. Membership Agreement Disputes (CRITICAL PATTERN)

Frequency: 5+ major class actions

Common Themes:

• Cancellation provisions
• Termination provisions
• Fee increases
• Billing after cancellation
• Service duration discrepancies

Financial Impact: Over $6 million in disclosed settlements

Root Cause: Tension between:

• Franchisor's desire for recurring revenue model
• Consumer protection

---

Massage Envy Bankruptcy History & Management Background (Item 4)

Overview

Item 4 of the Franchise Disclosure Document (FDD) provides critical information about the financial stability and legal history of the franchisor and its key management personnel. This section examines any bankruptcy proceedings that could indicate financial distress or management challenges.

Bankruptcy Disclosure Statement

According to Item 4 of the Massage Envy FDD dated April 29, 2024:

💡

"Exhibit G to this Disclosure Document includes any bankruptcies that must be disclosed with respect to our Regional Developers. Other than the bankruptcy cases disclosed in Exhibit G (if any), no additional bankruptcy information is required to be disclosed in this Item."

Key Findings

Franchisor Bankruptcy History

ME SPE Franchising, LLC (the current franchisor):

• ✅ No bankruptcy filings reported
• ✅ No reorganization proceedings
• ✅ No receivership proceedings

Parent Company Bankruptcy History

The following parent and predecessor entities show no bankruptcy history:

Management Team Bankruptcy History

The FDD discloses the following key management personnel in Item 2, with no bankruptcy history reported for any of them:

Current Leadership Team:

Regional Developer Bankruptcy History

The FDD specifically references Exhibit G for any bankruptcy disclosures related to Regional Developers:

• Regional Developers are independent entities that operate multiple Massage Envy locations
• As of December 31, 2023, there were 9 Regional Developers operating 11 Regional Developer businesses
• Any bankruptcy history for Regional Developers would be disclosed in Exhibit G
• The FDD states: "Other than the bankruptcy cases disclosed in Exhibit G (if any), no additional bankruptcy information is required to be disclosed"

Note: Prospective franchisees should carefully review Exhibit G to determine if any Regional Developers in their intended territory have bankruptcy history.

Historical Context & Corporate Restructuring

The 2019 Securitization Transaction

While not a bankruptcy, the FDD discloses a significant corporate restructuring event:

June 2019 - Securitization Transaction:

• ME SPE Franchising, LLC was formed as part of a secured financing transaction
• All existing U.S. franchise agreements were transferred from MEF to ME SPE Franchising
• Ownership and control of U.S. trademarks and intellectual property were transferred
• This was a strategic financial restructuring, not a bankruptcy or insolvency proceeding

Key Implications:

• The securitization created a special purpose entity structure
• This type of structure is common in franchise systems with significant assets
• It does not indicate financial distress but rather sophisticated financial management
• All franchise obligations were assumed by the new entity

Ownership History

2012 Acquisition by Roark Capital:

• September 27, 2012: Roark Capital Group acquired 100% ownership through RC ME Merger LLC
• This was a private equity acquisition, not a bankruptcy or distress sale
• Massage Envy became part of Roark Capital's portfolio of franchise brands

Current Ownership Structure:

ME Holding Corporation (Ultimate Parent)
    ↓
Massage Envy, LLC
    ↓
ME SPE Holdco, LLC
    ↓
ME SPE Funding, LLC
    ↓
ME SPE Franchising, LLC (Franchisor)

Management Experience & Credentials

Leadership Stability Analysis

Positive Indicators:

1. Long Tenure in Key Positions:

   • CFO Paul Malek: 5+ years with the organization
   • General Counsel Kristin Paiva: 5+ years with the organization
   • Demonstrates management continuity and stability

2. Industry Experience:

   • CEO Todd Schrader: Promoted from within (COO to CEO), indicating deep knowledge of operations
   • Multiple executives have multi-year tenure with Massage Envy specifically

3. Relevant Background:

   • Ken DeWitt (CIO): Previously served as CIO for TruGreen, bringing enterprise-level technology experience
   • Erich Melsheimer (Chief Development Officer): Experience with major brands including Planet Fitness and Gap, Inc.
   • Samantha Wallace: Franchise development experience in related wellness industries

Management Team Depth

Financial Stability Indicators

Positive Signs

✅ No Bankruptcy History: Clean record for franchisor, parent companies, and disclosed management

✅ Strong Parent Company: Roark Capital Group is a well-established private equity firm with extensive franchise experience

✅ Large System Size: 1,053 operating locations as of December 31, 2023 indicates system viability

✅ Long Operating History: Franchise system operating since 2003 (over 20 years)

✅ Management Continuity: Key executives have multi-year tenure with the organization

✅ Sophisticated Corporate Structure: The securitization transaction indicates access to capital markets

Affiliated Franchise Programs

Massage Envy is part of the Roark Capital portfolio, which includes numerous successful franchise brands:

Major Affiliated Brands (No Impact on Massage Envy Operations):

• Inspire Brands (Arby's, Buffalo Wild Wings, Sonic, Jimmy John's, Dunkin', Baskin-Robbins)
• GoTo Foods (Auntie Anne's, Carvel, Cinnabon, Jamba, McAlister's, Moe's, Schlotzsky's)
• Driven Holdings (Meineke, Maaco, CARSTAR, Take 5)
• ServiceMaster Systems (Merry Maids, ServiceMaster Clean/Restore, Two Men and a Truck)
• Others (Primrose Schools, CKE Restaurants, Nothing Bundt Cakes, Mathnasium)

Significance: This affiliation demonstrates:

• Access to sophisticated franchise management expertise
• Potential for shared best practices across brands
• Financial backing from a well-capitalized private equity firm
• No direct operational impact on individual Massage Envy franchises

Risk Assessment for Franchisees

Low-Risk Indicators

Considerations & Context

1. Regional Developer Bankruptcy Risk:

• ⚠️ Action Required: Prospective franchisees MUST review Exhibit G
• Regional Developers provide support services in certain territories
• Any Regional Developer bankruptcy could affect support quality in that territory
• This is particularly important if your intended location falls within a Regional Developer's territory

2. Corporate Restructuring (2019):

• The securitization transaction was a strategic financial move, not distress-related
• Common practice for large franchise systems
• Does not indicate financial problems
• All franchise obligations were properly assumed

3. Litigation History (Item 3):

• While bankruptcy history is clean, Item 3 discloses significant litigation
• Multiple class action lawsuits (some settled, some ongoing)
• Sexual misconduct allegations at franchised locations
• These legal matters are separate from bankruptcy but indicate operational and reputational risks

4. Management Changes:

• CEO position changed in March 2024 (Todd Schrader promoted from COO)
• This was an internal promotion, suggesting planned succession
• Other key positions show stability

Comparison to Industry Standards

Franchise Industry Bankruptcy Benchmarks

Massage Envy's Position:

Industry Context:

• Franchise systems with 20+ years of operation and no bankruptcy history are considered financially stable
• Large system size (1,000+ units) indicates proven business model
• Private equity ownership by established firms like Roark Capital generally indicates financial strength

Practical Implications for Prospective Franchisees

What This Means for Your Investment

✅ Positive Implications:

1. Financial Stability: No bankruptcy history suggests the franchisor can meet its obligations to franchisees
2. Support Continuity: Stable management team more likely to provide consistent support
3. System Longevity: Low risk of franchisor bankruptcy disrupting your business
4. Brand Stability: Clean financial history supports brand reputation
5. Access to Capital: Strong parent company suggests franchisor can invest in system improvements

⚠️ Important Considerations:

1. Regional Developer Due Diligence:

   • If your territory has a Regional Developer, verify their financial stability
   • Review Exhibit G carefully for any Regional Developer bankruptcies
   • Regional Developer financial problems could affect your support services

2. Individual Franchisee Performance:

   • Franchisor financial stability does NOT guarantee franchisee profitability
   • Review Item 19 (Financial Performance Representations) carefully
   • Contact existing and former franchisees (Item 20) about their financial experience

3. Litigation Considerations:

   • While bankruptcy history is clean, significant litigation exists (see Item 3)
   • Legal issues can affect brand reputation and system operations
   • Consider potential impact on customer perception and franchisee relations

4. Management Transition:

   • New CEO as of March 2024
   • Monitor for any strategic changes or policy shifts
   • Internal promotion suggests continuity, but watch for direction changes

Questions to Ask Current Franchisees

When contacting existing franchisees (listed in Exhibit C), consider asking:

1. Financial Stability Perception:

   • "Do you feel the franchisor is financially stable and able to support franchisees?"
   • "Have you experienced any disruptions in support services?"
   • "Are fees and royalties being used effectively to support the system?"

2. Regional Developer Experience (if applicable):

   • "How is your Regional Developer's financial stability?"
   • "Have you experienced any issues with Regional Developer support?"
   • "Is your Regional Developer investing in the territory?"

3. Management Support:

   • "How responsive is corporate management to franchisee concerns?"
   • "Have you noticed any changes with the new CEO?"
   • "Do you feel the management team understands franchisee challenges?"

4. System Investment:

   • "Is the franchisor investing in technology and system improvements?"
   • "Do you see evidence of financial strength in system initiatives?"
   • "Are marketing funds being used effectively?"

Red Flags to Watch For

While Massage Envy's bankruptcy history is clean, prospective franchisees should monitor for these warning signs:

Potential Future Concerns

❌ Would Be Concerning (Not Currently Present):

• Sudden management turnover in multiple key positions
• Delayed or reduced support services
• Deferred system-wide technology or facility upgrades
• Significant reduction in marketing fund spending
• Multiple Regional Developer bankruptcies
• Franchisor requests to defer or restructure fee payments

Current Monitoring Points

⚠️ Worth Monitoring:

• New CEO transition (March 2024) - watch for strategic changes
• Litigation costs - extensive legal matters could strain resources
• Regional Developer stability - check Exhibit G for any bankruptcies
• Franchisee closure rates - review Item 20 for system health indicators

Conclusion & Recommendations

Overall Assessment: LOW BANKRUPTCY RISK

Summary:

• ✅ Clean bankruptcy history for franchisor and disclosed management
• ✅ Strong parent company backing (Roark Capital)
• ✅ 20+ years of operating history
• ✅ Large, established system (1,000+ locations)
• ✅ Management team with relevant experience and tenure
• ⚠️ Must review Exhibit G for Regional Developer bankruptcies

Recommended Actions for Prospective Franchisees

Before Signing:

1. ✅ Review Exhibit G thoroughly for any Regional Developer bankruptcy disclosures
2. ✅ Verify your territory's Regional Developer (if applicable) and their financial stability
3. ✅ Contact multiple existing franchisees about franchisor financial stability and support
4. ✅ Review Item 19 for financial performance data (if provided)
5. ✅ Analyze Item 20 for franchisee turnover and closure rates
6. ✅ Examine Item 3 for litigation that could impact financial stability
7. ✅ Consult with a franchise attorney about the overall risk profile
8. ✅ Have your accountant review the franchisor's financial statements (Item 21)

Due Diligence Focus Areas:

Final Perspective

The absence of bankruptcy history for ME SPE Franchising, LLC, its parent companies, and disclosed management personnel is a significant positive indicator for prospective franchisees. This clean record, combined with:

• Strong private equity backing
• Long operating history (20+ years)
• Large system size (1,000+ locations)
• Experienced management team

...suggests that the franchisor has the financial stability and management capability to support franchisees over the long term.

However, this clean bankruptcy record should be considered alongside:

• The extensive litigation disclosed in Item 3
• Any Regional Developer bankruptcies in Exhibit G
• Individual franchisee financial performance
• The overall investment risk and capital requirements

The lack of bankruptcy history reduces one major risk factor but does not eliminate all investment risks associated with purchasing a Massage Envy franchise.

---

Disclaimer: This analysis is based solely on information disclosed in the Massage Envy FDD dated April 29, 2024. Prospective franchisees should conduct comprehensive due diligence, including reviewing all FDD items, consulting with legal and financial advisors

---

Massage Envy Franchise Agreement Terms & Conditions (Item 17 - Part 1)

Overview

The Massage Envy franchise agreement contains numerous provisions that significantly impact your rights as a franchisee. Understanding these terms is critical before signing, as many provisions are heavily weighted in favor of the franchisor and contain restrictions that will affect your ability to operate, transfer, or exit the business.

⚠️ Important Note: The FDD provided does not contain the complete text of Item 17. The document cuts off mid-sentence in Item 6 (Other Fees section). Therefore, this analysis is based on information available in other sections of the FDD, particularly the Franchise Agreement provisions referenced throughout Items 1-16. A complete Item 17 analysis would require the full FDD text.

Key Contract Terms Summary

Based on the available information in the FDD, here are the key franchise agreement terms:

Initial Contract Length

Information Not Available: The complete FDD text provided does not explicitly state the initial franchise term length. This is critical information that should be clearly disclosed in Item 17.

What to Look For:

• Standard franchise terms in the wellness/spa industry typically range from 5-10 years
• The initial term should be long enough to recoup your investment
• Consider whether the term aligns with your lease obligations

Renewal Options and Requirements

Renewal Process

Based on the fee structure disclosed in Item 6, Massage Envy offers franchise renewal, but specific details are limited in the available text:

Renewal Fee:

• Cost: 2/3 of the then-current initial franchise fee
• Current Calculation: Approximately $30,000 (based on current $45,000 initial fee)
• Payment Timing: Due before execution of successor franchise agreement

Key Requirements:

1. New Agreement Required: You must sign a "successor franchise agreement" to renew
2. Current Terms Apply: The new agreement will likely contain the franchisor's then-current standard terms, which may differ significantly from your original agreement
3. No Guaranteed Renewal: The franchisor likely has discretion to deny renewal under certain circumstances

Renovation and Upgrade Requirements at Renewal

The FDD references a comprehensive "Refresh Program" that appears to be required at renewal:

Refresh Program Components:

Additional Renovation Costs:

• The actual cost of implementing the Refresh Program (construction, equipment, furnishings, etc.) is not specified in the available text
• These costs could be substantial and should be budgeted for well in advance of renewal
• See Item 8 for complete Refresh Program requirements (not included in provided text)

⚠️ Red Flag: The Refresh Program fees can increase "if our costs increase," providing the franchisor with unilateral pricing power. The actual renovation costs beyond these fees are not disclosed in the available sections.

Grounds for Termination by Franchisor

While the complete termination provisions are not included in the available FDD text, several grounds for termination can be inferred from other sections:

Material Breach Provisions

Fines and Penalties Leading to Termination:

The FDD discloses a fine structure (Item 6) that indicates certain violations that could lead to termination:

1. Failure to comply with mandatory System Standards (up to $500 per incident)
2. Repeated defaults - committing the same default within 6 months after a previous default
3. Failure to operate continuously during required business hours without consent
4. Safety policy violations - referenced in the ME SPE Franchising, LLC v. Misra Holdings case (Item 3)

Immediate Termination Grounds

Based on litigation history and standard franchise provisions, likely immediate termination grounds include:

• Abandonment of the franchise
• Criminal conviction affecting the franchise
• Unauthorized transfer of ownership
• Failure to pay royalties or other fees
• Loss of required licenses (massage therapy, aesthetician licenses)
• Repeated violations after notice and opportunity to cure
• Threat to public health or safety

Management Takeover Provision

⚠️ Significant Provision: If you materially breach the Franchise Agreement, the franchisor may take over management of your business and charge:

• Management Fee: Up to 8% of Gross Sales
• Plus: All costs and expenses incurred during management

This provision allows the franchisor to operate your business at your expense if you default.

Grounds for Termination by Franchisee

Information Not Available: The provided FDD text does not include specific provisions allowing franchisees to terminate the agreement early.

Typical Limitations:

• Most franchise agreements do not provide franchisees with unilateral termination rights
• You may be locked into the full term unless the franchisor materially breaches
• Early termination typically requires franchisor consent and payment of fees

What to Investigate:

• Whether you can terminate for franchisor's material breach
• Notice requirements and cure periods
• Financial obligations upon early termination
• Non-compete obligations if you terminate early

Transfer and Resale Restrictions

Transfer Fees and Requirements

Standard Transfer:

Transfer Process Restrictions

Based on standard franchise provisions and the fee structure, expect these restrictions:

Buyer Qualifications:

• Must meet franchisor's then-current qualifications
• Financial capability requirements
• Background checks
• Training completion

Franchisor Approval:

• Franchisor has discretion to approve or deny proposed transferee
• Right of first refusal likely applies (franchisor can purchase instead)
• Cannot transfer to franchisor's competitor

Conditions Precedent:

• All fees and royalties must be current
• No existing defaults under the agreement
• Compliance with all franchise agreement terms
• Transferee must sign then-current form of franchise agreement

⚠️ Red Flag: The requirement that transferees sign the "then-current form of franchise agreement" means buyers may face different (potentially less favorable) terms than you currently have, which could reduce the marketability and value of your franchise.

Right of First Refusal

While not explicitly detailed in the available text, the Michigan Notice (Item 1) references that franchise agreements typically include a franchisor's right of first refusal, allowing the franchisor to purchase your franchise on the same terms as any bona fide third-party offer.

Non-Compete Clauses

Information Limited: The complete non-compete provisions are not included in the available FDD text. However, the "What You Need To Know About Franchising Generally" section (page 3) warns:

💡

"When your franchise ends. The franchise agreement may prohibit you from operating a similar business after your franchise ends even if you still have obligations to your landlord or other creditors."

Expected Non-Compete Terms

Based on industry standards and the warning above, expect:

During the Term:

• Prohibited from operating any competing massage/spa business
• Prohibition applies to you personally and any entity you control
• Likely extends to immediate family members

Post-Termination:

• Duration: Typically 1-3 years (not specified in available text)
• Geographic Scope: Likely includes:
  • Your former territory
  • Radius around your former location (e.g., 5-15 miles)
  • Possibly radius around other Massage Envy locations
• Activities Restricted: Operating, owning interest in, or being employed by any competing business

⚠️ Critical Issue: Post-term non-competes can severely limit your ability to earn a living in the massage/spa industry after your franchise ends, even if you've invested years building expertise and relationships in the field.

Spousal Liability for Non-Compete

⚠️ Major Concern: The FDD explicitly warns (page 4):

💡

"Spousal Liability. Your spouse must sign a document, such as a guarantee, that makes your spouse liable for your financial obligations under the franchise agreement even if your spouse does not own any part of the franchise business."

Implications:

• Your spouse is bound by the non-compete even if not an owner
• Both spouses' ability to work in the industry may be restricted
• Applies in community property states even without signature
• Could affect household income for years after franchise ends

Fee Escalation Clauses

The Franchise Agreement contains multiple provisions allowing the franchisor to increase fees:

Fees Subject to Increase

Fixed Percentage Fees

These fees are based on Gross Sales percentages and will increase as your sales increase:

• Royalty: 6% of Gross Sales (fixed percentage)
• Marketing Fund/NAF: 2% of Gross Sales (fixed percentage)
• Supplemental Marketing Fund: 2% of Gross Sales (fixed percentage)
• Management Fee (if applicable): Up to 8% of Gross Sales

Total Ongoing Fees: Minimum 10% of Gross Sales (royalty + marketing), potentially up to 18% if business is under management

Technology Fee Concerns

⚠️ Significant Concern: The P4 Technology Fees are described as "approximately $705 per month" with the following issues:

1. Not Fixed: Use of "approximately" indicates fees can vary
2. Component-Based: Fees vary based on which technology components you use
3. Infrastructure-Dependent: Costs higher without cable-enabled internet
4. No Cap: No maximum fee specified
5. Unilateral Changes: Franchisor can modify technology requirements

Additional Technology Costs:

• Centralized Tech Solutions & Support Fee: $390/month (separate from P4 fees)
• Total Monthly Technology Costs: Approximately $1,095/month minimum
• Annual Technology Costs: Approximately $13,140/year minimum

Unilateral Pricing Power

⚠️ Red Flag: The repeated phrase "could increase if our costs increase" gives the franchisor unilateral power to raise fees without franchisee consent or negotiation. This creates unlimited financial exposure for franchisees.

What Happens When the Contract Ends?

Information Limited: The complete post-termination obligations are not fully detailed in the available FDD text.

Known Post-Termination Obligations

Immediate Cessation:

• Must stop using all Massage Envy Marks immediately
• Must stop holding yourself out as a Massage Envy franchisee
• Remove all signage and branding

Non-Compete Enforcement:

• Cannot operate competing business (duration and scope not specified in available text)
• Applies to you personally and your spouse (due to Guaranty)

Potential Additional Obligations:

• Return of confidential materials and manuals
• De-identification of location
• Payment of all outstanding fees and obligations
• Customer list and data transfer requirements (likely)

⚠️ Critical Gap: The FDD does not specify what happens to:

• Your membership base and customer relationships
• Prepaid member services and gift cards
• Your lease obligations
• Equipment and inventory
• Telephone numbers and local marketing materials

Restrictive and Unusual Clauses

1. Out-of-State Dispute Resolution (Arizona)

Provision: All disputes must be resolved through mediation, arbitration, and/or litigation in Arizona.

Impact:

• Significantly increases cost of any dispute
• Home-state advantage for franchisor
• May force unfavorable settlements due to travel/cost burden
• Explicitly highlighted as a "Special Risk" in the FDD (page 4)

State Protections: Some states (like Michigan, per the notice on pages 5-6) prohibit enforcement of out-of-state dispute resolution provisions.

2. Mandatory Spousal Guaranty

Provision: Your spouse must sign a Guaranty making them personally liable for all franchise obligations.

Impact:

• Puts all marital assets at risk
• Spouse liable even with no ownership interest
• Binds spouse to non-compete restrictions
• In community property states, spouse may be liable even without signing
• Explicitly highlighted as a "Special Risk" in the FDD (page 4)

Practical Concern: This provision can destroy family finances if the franchise fails and may prevent your spouse from working in the massage/spa industry.

3. Sales Performance Requirements

Provision: Must maintain minimum sales performance levels (specific levels not disclosed in available text).

Impact:

• Failure can result in loss of territorial rights
• Can lead to termination of franchise
• Loss of entire investment
• Explicitly highlighted as a "Special Risk" in the FDD (page 4)

⚠️ Critical Issue: The specific performance thresholds are not disclosed in the available FDD sections, making it impossible to evaluate whether they are achievable.

4. Unilateral System Changes

Warning from FDD (page 3):

💡

"Business model can change. The franchise agreement may allow the franchisor to change its manuals and business model without your consent. These changes may require you to make additional investments in your franchise business or may harm your franchise business."

Impact:

• Franchisor can modify operations without your approval
• May require additional capital investments
• Could fundamentally change your business model
• No compensation for required changes

5. Mandatory vs. Suggested Standards

Provision: The FDD states (Item 1):

💡

"You must comply with all System Standards that we designate as mandatory. For any System Standards that we designate as suggested or recommended, it is your responsibility to determine, in your sole discretion, to what extent, if any, such suggested or recommended System Standards should be applied to your Business."

Concern: The franchisor has unilateral power to convert "suggested" standards to "mandatory" standards at any time, potentially requiring new investments or operational changes.

6. Supplier Restrictions

Warning from FDD (page 3):

💡

"Supplier restrictions. You may have to buy or lease items from the franchisor or a limited group of suppliers the franchisor designates. These items may be more expensive than similar items you could buy on your own."

Impact:

• Limited negotiating power on pricing
• Potential for higher costs than open market
• Franchisor may receive rebates from suppliers (disclosed in Item 8, not included in available text)

7. Indemnification Obligations

Provision (Item 6): You must indemnify the franchisor and others

---

Dispute Resolution: Massage Envy Franchise Legal Rights (Item 17 - Part 2)

Overview

CRITICAL NOTICE: The information regarding Item 17 (Dispute Resolution) is NOT AVAILABLE in the provided FDD excerpt. The document structure shows that Item 17 exists (page 55 according to the Table of Contents), but the actual content of Item 17 was not included in the pages provided for analysis.

What We Know From Other Sections

While the complete Item 17 is not available, the FDD does provide some relevant information about dispute resolution in other sections:

Out-of-State Dispute Resolution Warning

From the "Special Risks to Consider" section (Page 4), the FDD explicitly warns:

💡

"Out-of-State Dispute Resolution. The franchise agreement requires you to resolve disputes with the franchisor by mediation, arbitration and/or litigation only in Arizona. Out-of-state mediation, arbitration, or litigation may force you to accept a less favorable settlement for disputes. It may also cost more to mediate, arbitrate, or litigate with the franchisor in Arizona than in your own state."

Key Implications

This warning reveals several critical points:

1. Mandatory Arizona Venue: All disputes must be resolved in Arizona, regardless of where your franchise is located
2. Multiple Resolution Methods: The agreement includes mediation, arbitration, and/or litigation options
3. Financial Burden: Franchisees may face higher costs traveling to and litigating in Arizona
4. Settlement Pressure: Distance and cost factors may pressure franchisees into less favorable settlements

Evidence from Litigation History (Item 3)

The extensive litigation history in Item 3 provides insight into how Massage Envy handles disputes:

Arbitration Cases Documented

Several arbitration cases are listed in Item 3, including:

1. NHMME, LLC v. Massage Envy Franchising, LLC (AAA Case No. 01-16-0000-8441)

   • Filed March 11, 2016
   • New York franchisee dispute
   • Claims: Fraud, misrepresentation, breach of covenant of good faith
   • Result: Confidential settlement (June 20, 2017)

2. Phoenix Wellness Avondale, Inc. v. MEF and ME SPE (AAA Case No. 01-21-0000-2594)

   • Filed January 20, 2021
   • 104 individual arbitration actions filed by 50+ franchisees
   • Claims: Breach of contract, faulty POS system, unauthorized fees
   • Result: Settlement of $3,950,000 total (March 10, 2022)

3. Long Beach Envy, Inc. v. MEF (AAA Case No. 01-20-0005-3414)

   • Filed May 20, 2020
   • Claims: Territorial rights violations, fraudulent inducement
   • Sought $3+ million in damages
   • Result: Settlement of $700,000 (August 11, 2022)

4. ME SPE Franchising v. Misra Holdings (AAA Case No. 01-22-0005-2665)

   • Filed January 21, 2023
   • Franchisor-initiated termination case
   • Result: Arbitrator ruled in favor of ME SPE; awarded $115,280.98 in attorneys' fees

Class Action Settlements

Multiple class action lawsuits were settled, indicating patterns in dispute resolution:

What's Missing (Information Not Available)

Without access to the actual Item 17 content, we cannot provide specific details on:

• ✗ Exact mediation procedures and timelines
• ✗ Specific arbitration rules (AAA, JAMS, or other)
• ✗ Whether arbitration is binding or non-binding
• ✗ Who pays arbitration costs and fees
• ✗ Specific choice of law provisions
• ✗ Class action waiver language
• ✗ Attorney fee allocation provisions
• ✗ Statute of limitations for bringing claims
• ✗ Injunctive relief provisions
• ✗ Jury trial waiver provisions

Dispute Resolution Process (Inferred from Available Information)

Based on the litigation history and risk warnings, the likely dispute resolution process follows this pattern:

┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│                    DISPUTE ARISES                            │
└────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────┘
                         │
                         ▼
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│              STEP 1: INFORMAL NEGOTIATION                    │
│  • Direct communication with franchisor                      │
│  • Attempt to resolve without formal process                │
│  • Timeline: Not specified                                   │
└────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────┘
                         │
                         ▼
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│              STEP 2: MEDIATION (Likely)                      │
│  • Venue: Arizona                                            │
│  • Non-binding process                                       │
│  • Cost-sharing arrangement (likely)                         │
│  • Timeline: Not specified                                   │
└────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────┘
                         │
                         ▼
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│         STEP 3: ARBITRATION (Confirmed)                      │
│  • Venue: Arizona                                            │
│  • Administrator: American Arbitration Association (AAA)     │
│  • Binding decision                                          │
│  • Individual arbitrations (based on case history)           │
│  • Timeline: Varies (cases show 1-3 years)                   │
└────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────┘
                         │
                         ▼
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│         STEP 4: LITIGATION (If Applicable)                   │
│  • Venue: Arizona courts                                     │
│  • Limited circumstances (likely)                            │
│  • May be for injunctive relief only                         │
└─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘

State-Specific Modifications

Michigan Franchisees

The Michigan Franchise Investment Law (pages 5-6) provides important protections that override certain franchise agreement provisions:

Michigan Law Prohibits:

• Requiring arbitration or litigation outside Michigan (franchisees can agree to out-of-state arbitration at the time of dispute, but cannot be required to do so in advance)
• Waiving compliance with Michigan Franchise Investment Law
• Requiring franchisees to consent to liquidated damages or termination penalties

Michigan-Specific Language:

💡

"A provision which permits a franchisor to refuse to renew a franchise without fairly compensating the franchisee... A provision requiring that arbitration or litigation be conducted outside this state. This shall not preclude the franchisee from entering into an agreement, at the time of arbitration, to conduct arbitration at a location outside this state."

Other State Protections

The FDD references "State Specific Addenda" (Exhibit F) which likely contains modifications for other registration states, but this exhibit was not included in the provided pages.

Cost Considerations for Franchisees

Direct Costs of Dispute Resolution

Based on the Franchise Agreement fee schedule (Item 6):

Indirect Costs

Travel and Accommodation:

• Flights to Arizona (potentially multiple trips)
• Hotel accommodations
• Meals and incidentals
• Lost time from business operations

Expert Witnesses:

• Financial experts
• Industry experts
• Forensic accountants (for financial disputes)

Document Production:

• Copying and organizing records
• Electronic discovery costs
• Translation services (if applicable)

Real-World Cost Examples from Litigation

From the concluded cases:

1. Franchisee Group Arbitration: 50+ franchisees collectively paid attorneys to pursue claims, resulting in $3.95M settlement
2. Individual Arbitration: Long Beach franchisee received $700K settlement (likely after significant legal costs)
3. Franchisor Victory: ME SPE awarded $115,280.98 in attorneys' fees against franchisee

Estimated Total Cost Range for Arbitration: $50,000 - $250,000+ depending on complexity

Your Legal Rights as a Franchisee

Rights You Likely Have (Based on Standard Franchise Practices)

1. Right to Legal Representation: You can hire an attorney at any stage
2. Right to Present Evidence: In arbitration or litigation, you can present your case
3. Right to Discovery: Ability to request documents and information (though may be limited in arbitration)
4. Right to Appeal (Limited): Arbitration decisions are generally final with very limited appeal rights

Rights You Likely Do NOT Have

1. Choice of Venue: Must resolve disputes in Arizona
2. Jury Trial: Likely waived in favor of arbitration
3. Class Action: Likely prohibited (though not confirmed in available documents)
4. Punitive Damages: May be limited or prohibited in arbitration
5. Public Hearing: Arbitration is private, unlike court proceedings

Protections Under State Law

Depending on your state, you may have additional protections:

Franchise Relationship Laws (states like California, Washington, Wisconsin, etc.):

• Restrictions on termination
• Requirements for good cause
• Mandatory notice periods
• Restrictions on non-renewal

Consumer Protection Laws:

• May provide additional claims
• May allow for attorney fee recovery
• May permit class actions despite franchise agreement provisions

Red Flags and Concerns

🚩 Major Red Flags

1. Mandatory Arizona Venue

   • Impact: Significantly increases cost and difficulty of pursuing claims
   • Risk Level: HIGH
   • Consideration: Budget an additional $20,000-$50,000 for travel and logistics if dispute arises

2. Extensive Litigation History

   • Impact: Pattern of disputes suggests systemic issues
   • Risk Level: HIGH
   • Notable: Multiple class actions, 100+ franchisee arbitrations in 2021-2022

3. Franchisor Can Recover Attorneys' Fees

   • Impact: If you lose, you may pay both sides' legal costs
   • Risk Level: MEDIUM-HIGH
   • Example: Misra Holdings case - franchisor awarded $115,280.98

4. Broad Indemnification Obligations

   • Impact: You must defend and indemnify franchisor for claims related to your business
   • Risk Level: MEDIUM-HIGH
   • Consideration: Ensure adequate insurance coverage

⚠️ Moderate Concerns

5. Settlement Confidentiality

   • Impact: Difficult to assess typical settlement values
   • Risk Level: MEDIUM
   • Note: Most settlements include confidentiality provisions

6. Arbitration Costs

   • Impact: AAA arbitration filing fees and arbitrator costs can be substantial
   • Risk Level: MEDIUM
   • Typical Cost: $5,000-$15,000 in AAA fees alone

7. Limited Appeal Rights

   • Impact: Arbitration decisions are nearly impossible to appeal
   • Risk Level: MEDIUM
   • Consideration: First arbitration decision is likely final

Patterns from Litigation History

Common Franchisee Complaints

Based on the 100+ arbitration cases filed in 2021:

1. Technology Issues

   • Faulty point-of-sale system
   • Mandatory system installations
   • Technology fees

2. Unauthorized Fees

   • Charges without contractual basis
   • Required purchases of products/services
   • Insurance requirements

3. Territorial Violations

   • Overlapping territories
   • Right of first refusal disputes
   • New franchises in existing territories

4. Membership Agreement Issues

   • Cancellation provisions
   • Fee increases
   • Service duration claims

Franchisor's Track Record

Settlement Patterns:

• Franchisor has settled most major disputes
• Large class actions: $5.4M, $11M (vouchers), $3.95M (franchisee group)
• Individual cases: $700K settlement
• Willing to settle to avoid precedent-setting decisions

Litigation Strategy:

• Enforces arbitration provisions
• Pursues individual arbitrations rather than class actions
• Recovers attorneys' fees when successful
• Uses confidential settlements

Timeline Expectations

Based on concluded cases in Item 3:

Key Takeaway: Even "quick" arbitrations take 1+ years and cost tens of thousands of dollars.

Important Considerations for Prospective Franchisees

Before Signing the Franchise Agreement

1. Hire a Franchise Attorney

   • Essential for reviewing dispute resolution provisions
   • Preferably one licensed in Arizona and your state
   • Cost: $2,000-$5,000 for FDD review

2. Understand Your State's Protections

   • Research franchise relationship laws in your state
   • Determine if state law overrides franchise agreement provisions
   • Michigan, California, Washington, and others have strong protections

3. Budget for Potential Disputes

   • Set aside $50,000-$100,000 in reserve
   • Consider this part of your risk management
   • May never need it, but critical if you do

4. Evaluate Dispute Resolution Costs

   • Calculate travel costs to Arizona (flights, hotels, time)
   • Research AAA arbitration fees
   • Consider impact on business operations during dispute

5. Review Litigation History Carefully

   • 100+ franchisees filed arbitrations in 2021-2022
   • Multiple class actions settled
   • Pattern suggests systemic issues

Negotiation Points (If Possible)

While franchise agreements are typically non-negotiable, you might attempt to negotiate:

1. Venue: Request mediation in your home state (unlikely to succeed)
2. Cost Allocation: Request that each party bears own costs
3. Fee Cap: Request cap on attorneys' fees you could

---

Massage Envy Franchisee Success Rate & Turnover (Item 20 - Part 1)

Data Availability Notice

Important: The FDD structure provided indicates that Item 20 (Outlets and Franchisee Information) was not found in the extracted content. While the table of contents on page 7 confirms that Item 20 exists in the full FDD document (listed on page 64), the actual data tables and detailed outlet information were not included in the pages provided for analysis.

Based on the limited information available in the provided FDD excerpts, here is what can be determined:

Available System-Wide Data

Current Operating Units (As of December 31, 2023)

From Item 1 of the FDD, the following information is disclosed:

Business Model Evolution

• Pre-February 2011: Only "traditional" Massage Envy Businesses (massage therapy only)
• Post-February 2011: "Total body care" model introduced (massage + facials + stretch + skin care)
• Current Offering: Only total body care franchises are being sold
• Regional Developer Program: Ceased offering new Regional Developer franchises in September 2012

Historical Franchise Sales Data

Predecessor Company (ME Limited) Sales Record

The FDD discloses franchise sales by the predecessor company, Massage Envy Limited, LLC:

Key Observation: Of the 825 traditional businesses sold, 400 (48.5%) subsequently converted to the total body care model, indicating franchisee willingness to invest in the expanded service offering.

What's Missing from This Analysis

Due to the absence of Item 20 data tables in the provided excerpts, the following critical information cannot be analyzed:

Unable to Calculate:

• ❌ Year-by-year unit openings (past 3 years)
• ❌ Year-by-year closures (past 3 years)
• ❌ Number of transfers (past 3 years)
• ❌ Number of terminations (past 3 years)
• ❌ Number of non-renewals (past 3 years)
• ❌ Reacquired units by franchisor
• ❌ Ceased operations for other reasons
• ❌ Actual turnover rate
• ❌ Retention statistics
• ❌ State-by-state breakdown
• ❌ Net growth vs. gross openings

Corporate Ownership Changes

Significant Structural Events

September 27, 2012 - Roark Capital Acquisition:

• RC ME Merger LLC (controlled by Roark Capital Group) purchased 100% ownership
• Massage Envy became part of Roark Capital's multi-brand franchise portfolio

June 2019 - Securitization Transaction:

• Major restructuring of Massage Envy entities
• ME SPE Franchising, LLC became the new franchisor
• All existing U.S. franchise agreements transferred from MEF to ME SPE Franchising
• Ownership and control of U.S. trademarks transferred

Impact on Franchisees: These ownership changes represent significant corporate restructuring events that may have affected franchisee relationships, support systems, and operational continuity.

Litigation as an Indicator of System Health

Major Class Action Settlements (Potential Red Flags)

The FDD Item 3 discloses several significant class action lawsuits that may indicate franchisee and customer dissatisfaction:

1. Membership Fee Increase Litigation

Baerbel McKinney-Drobnis v. MEF (2016-2022)

• Claim: Wrongful increase of monthly membership fees
• Settlement: $11 million in vouchers to class members
• Status: Final approval June 24, 2022
• Implication: Suggests pricing control issues between franchisor and franchisees

2. Membership Cancellation Litigation

Multiple class actions challenging cancellation policies:

Red Flag: Multiple lawsuits over similar membership issues suggest systemic problems with membership agreement terms and practices.

3. Franchisee Arbitrations (2021-2022)

Phoenix Wellness Avondale v. MEF & ME SPE

• Number of Cases: 104 individual arbitration actions filed by 50+ franchisees
• Claims:
  • Breach of franchise agreement
  • Failure to provide contractually agreed services
  • Forced installation of allegedly faulty POS system
  • Required purchases without contractual authority
  • Unauthorized monthly fees
• Settlement: $3,950,000 total (March 2022)
• Additional Terms: Formation of ad hoc committee for new mandatory products/services

Critical Red Flag: This represents a significant franchisee uprising involving approximately 50 franchisees (roughly 5% of the system) simultaneously filing arbitration claims. This is highly unusual and suggests:

• Widespread franchisee dissatisfaction
• Possible breach of franchisor obligations
• Technology implementation problems
• Fee structure disputes

4. Sexual Misconduct Litigation

In the Matter of Massage Envy Franchising, LLC (Multiple States)

• Status: Numerous ongoing lawsuits
• Claims: Sexual misconduct by massage therapists; franchisor negligence and vicarious liability
• Franchisor Response: "Strongly disagree" and "vigorously defend"
• Settlements: Some cases settled (terms not disclosed)

Serious Concern: The FDD states: "MEF and ME SPE Franchising may be named as defendants in additional lawsuits by customers asserting similar claims." This suggests an ongoing pattern of incidents that could:

• Damage brand reputation
• Increase insurance costs
• Create liability exposure for franchisees
• Require enhanced compliance and training costs

Company-Owned Operations

Limited Company Store Experience

According to Item 1:

• Massage Envy FLW, LLC operated one company-owned location in Scottsdale, Arizona from April 2012 to June 2014
• Location was closed and territory granted to unaffiliated franchisee
• ME FLW now manages membership bases of certain closed locations

Analysis: The franchisor has minimal recent experience operating Massage Envy Businesses, which may affect:

• Understanding of current operational challenges
• Realistic assessment of profitability
• Support quality for franchisees

Regional Developer Model

Regional Developer Statistics

Regional Developer Role:

• Open and operate specified number of locations in development area
• Recruit franchisees for development area
• Provide training, opening assistance, and ongoing supervision
• Receive portion of initial franchise fees and royalties from area franchisees

Implication: The closure of the Regional Developer program in 2012 suggests:

• Possible issues with the multi-tier franchise model
• Shift to direct franchisor-franchisee relationships
• Potential conflicts between Regional Developers and franchisor

Indicators of System Stability

Positive Indicators (Based on Available Information):

✅ Large System Size: 1,053 operating units indicates established brand presence

✅ Model Evolution: 400 franchisees converted from traditional to total body care model, showing franchisee confidence in expanded services

✅ Long Operating History: Franchising since 2003 (21 years)

✅ Strong Parent Company: Roark Capital manages multiple successful franchise brands

Negative Indicators (Red Flags):

🚩 Mass Franchisee Arbitrations: 50+ franchisees (5% of system) filed claims in 2021-2022

🚩 $3.95 Million Settlement: Significant payout to resolve franchisee disputes

🚩 Multiple Class Actions: Pattern of litigation over membership practices

🚩 Sexual Misconduct Cases: Ongoing litigation with brand reputation risk

🚩 Closed Regional Developer Program: Suggests problems with original expansion model

🚩 Limited Company Operations: Minimal franchisor experience operating units

🚩 Major Corporate Restructuring: 2019 securitization transaction may have created uncertainty

What Prospective Franchisees Should Investigate

Critical Questions to Ask Current and Former Franchisees:

1. Turnover and Closures:

   • How many locations have closed in your area in the past 3 years?
   • Do you know franchisees who have sold or left the system? Why?
   • What is the typical lifespan of a Massage Envy franchise in your market?

2. The 2021-2022 Franchisee Arbitrations:

   • Were you involved in or aware of the mass arbitration filings?
   • What were the specific issues that led to those disputes?
   • Have the underlying problems been resolved?
   • Is the ad hoc committee for new products/services functioning effectively?

3. Technology and Systems:

   • What issues have you experienced with the POS system?
   • Are the technology fees ($705/month + $390/month) justified by the value received?
   • Have mandatory technology purchases been problematic?

4. Fee Structure:

   • Have you experienced unauthorized fee charges?
   • Are the total fees (royalty + marketing + technology = ~9% + $1,095/month) sustainable?
   • Have fees increased significantly since you opened?

5. Membership Pricing Control:

   • Do you have control over your membership pricing?
   • Has the franchisor forced price increases on your members?
   • How do membership cancellation policies affect your business?

6. Sexual Misconduct Policies:

   • What training and policies are in place to prevent misconduct?
   • Have you experienced incidents at your location?
   • What is your liability exposure as a franchisee?

7. Profitability and Support:

   • Is your location profitable?
   • How long did it take to reach profitability?
   • Is franchisor support adequate?
   • Would you buy another Massage Envy franchise?

Documents to Request:

1. Complete Item 20 Tables showing:

   • Year-by-year openings, closures, transfers, terminations (2021-2023)
   • State-by-state breakdown
   • Reasons for closures

2. Item 19 Financial Performance Representations (if available)

3. Settlement Agreements from franchisee arbitrations (if accessible)

4. Current Operations Manual sections on:

   • Sexual misconduct prevention
   • Membership pricing policies
   • Technology requirements

Preliminary Assessment

System Health Indicators

Without access to the complete Item 20 data, a definitive assessment cannot be made. However, based on available information:

⚠️ PROCEED WITH EXTREME CAUTION

The combination of:

• Mass franchisee arbitrations (50+ franchisees)
• $3.95 million settlement for franchisee claims
• Multiple customer class actions
• Ongoing sexual misconduct litigation
• Closed Regional Developer program
• Major corporate restructuring

...suggests a franchise system that has experienced significant operational, legal, and franchisee relations challenges in recent years.

Is This "Churning" or Healthy Growth?

Cannot determine without Item 20 data, but warning signs include:

• The need for 50+ franchisees to file arbitration suggests systemic problems
• Multiple class action settlements indicate customer satisfaction issues
• Pattern of litigation suggests operational challenges

Franchisee Satisfaction Indicators

Evidence suggests LOW to MODERATE franchisee satisfaction:

Negative Indicators:

• 50+ franchisees filed arbitration (unprecedented in most systems)
• Claims of breach of contract and unauthorized fees
• Need for settlement and oversight committee

Positive Indicators:

• 400 franchisees invested in model conversion
• System remains at 1,053 units (substantial size)
• Some franchisees purchasing multiple units (multi-unit discount offered)

Conclusion and Recommendations

What We Know:

• System has 1,053 operating units as of December 31, 2023
• Significant franchisee disputes in 2021-2022 involving 50+ franchisees
• Multiple customer class actions settled
• Ongoing sexual misconduct litigation

What We Don't Know (Critical Missing Information):

• Actual turnover rate (closures ÷ total units)
• Net growth rate (openings - closures)
• Transfer rate (indication of franchisee exit strategy success)
• Termination rate (indication of franchisee failures)
• State-by-state performance (market saturation indicators)

Recommendations for Prospective Franchisees:

1. ✅ OBTAIN COMPLETE ITEM 20 DATA - This is essential and should be in the full FDD

2. ✅ CONDUCT EXTENSIVE FRANCHISEE INTERVIEWS - Speak with at least 10-15 franchisees, including:

   • Franchisees who participated in the 2021-2022 arbitrations
   • Recently opened locations (within 2 years)
   • Long-term franchisees (5+ years)
   • Franchisees in your target market
   • Former franchisees (if you can locate them)

3. ✅ INVESTIGATE LITIGATION HISTORY - Research:

   • Details of the mass arbitration settlement
   • Sexual misconduct case outcomes
   • Impact on brand reputation in your market

4. ✅ ANALYZE COMPLETE FINANCIAL DATA - Review Item 19 (not provided) for:

   • Average unit revenues
   • Profitability metrics
   • Time to break-even

5. ✅ ASSESS TECHNOLOGY COSTS - Evaluate whether $1,095/month in technology fees is justified

6. ✅ CONSULT FRANCHISE ATTORNEY - Have an experienced franchise attorney review:

   • Franchise Agreement terms
   • Arbitration provisions
   • Liability exposure
   • Exit strategy options

7. ⚠️ CONSIDER ALTERNATIVES - Given the red flags, compare Massage Envy to:

   • Other massage franchise opportunities
   • Independent spa/massage business models
   • Different franchise concepts entirely

---

CRITICAL NOTICE: This analysis is incomplete without the actual Item 20 tables showing year-by-year unit changes, closures, transfers, and terminations. Do not make any franchise purchase decision without obtaining and analyzing the complete Item 20 data from the full FDD.

The pattern of litigation and franchisee disputes disclosed in this FDD represents significant red flags that warrant thorough investigation before investing $605,850 to $1,014,700 in a Massage Envy franchise.

---

Massage Envy Franchise Locations: Current & Former Franchisee List (Item 20 - Part 2)

Overview: The Critical Importance of Franchisee Validation

Important Notice: The FDD provided does not contain the complete Item 20 information, including the actual franchisee contact lists (Exhibits C and G). This section provides comprehensive guidance on how to conduct franchisee validation once you receive the complete FDD with franchisee contact information.

Franchisee validation is arguably the most critical step in your franchise due diligence process. While the FDD provides extensive legal and financial information, speaking directly with current and former franchisees gives you real-world insights that no document can provide.

Accessing the Franchisee Contact Lists

Where to Find Franchisee Information

According to the FDD structure, franchisee contact information is located in:

• Exhibit C: List of Current Franchisees
• Exhibit G: List of Regional Developers (who also operate franchises)

What Information You'll Receive

The franchisee lists typically include:

• Franchisee name (individual or entity)
• Business address
• City, state, and ZIP code
• Phone number
• Email address (in some cases)
• Date franchise agreement was signed
• Location opening date

Your Legal Right to This Information

Under FTC regulations, Massage Envy must provide you with:

1. A complete list of all current franchisees
2. Contact information for franchisees who left the system in the past fiscal year
3. Contact information for franchisees whose outlets were terminated, cancelled, not renewed, or otherwise voluntarily or involuntarily ceased operations

Timeline: You must receive this information at least 14 calendar days before signing any agreement or making any payment.

Recommended Number of Franchisees to Contact

Minimum Recommended Contacts

Strategic Selection Criteria

When selecting which franchisees to contact:

Geographic Diversity

• Contact franchisees in your target market area
• Include franchisees in similar demographic markets
• Include franchisees in different regions for comparison

Operational Timeline

• New franchisees (0-2 years): Understand startup challenges
• Established franchisees (3-5 years): Gauge stability and growth
• Veteran franchisees (5+ years): Long-term viability insights
• Multi-unit operators: Expansion potential and scalability

Performance Indicators (if available)

• High-performing locations
• Average-performing locations
• Struggling locations (if identifiable)

Comprehensive Franchisee Interview Questions

Questions for Current Franchisees (15 Essential Questions)

Financial Performance

1. Revenue and Profitability

   • "What were your actual Gross Sales in your first year, second year, and most recent year?"
   • "How long did it take to reach break-even, and when did you start taking a meaningful salary?"
   • "What is your current profit margin, and how does it compare to what you expected?"
   • "Have you been able to achieve the financial performance representations shown in Item 19?"

2. Initial Investment Accuracy

   • "How did your actual initial investment compare to the estimates in Item 7 of the FDD?"
   • "What unexpected costs did you encounter that weren't adequately disclosed or that you didn't anticipate?"
   • "How much working capital did you actually need beyond what was disclosed?"

3. Ongoing Costs

   • "Are the ongoing fees (royalties, marketing, technology) reasonable given the support you receive?"
   • "Have there been any unexpected fee increases or new mandatory fees since you opened?"
   • "What are your actual monthly operating costs compared to your initial projections?"

Operational Support

4. Franchisor Support Quality

   • "How would you rate the quality and responsiveness of franchisor support on a scale of 1-10?"
   • "What specific support has been most valuable, and where has support been lacking?"
   • "Has the level of support changed since you opened your location?"

5. Training Effectiveness

   • "Was the initial training adequate to prepare you to open and operate successfully?"
   • "What critical information or skills were missing from the training program?"
   • "How effective is ongoing training and support for staff development?"

6. Technology and Systems

   • "How reliable and user-friendly are the required technology systems (Meevo, P4, etc.)?"
   • "Have you experienced significant technology issues or downtime?"
   • "Are the technology fees justified by the value and functionality provided?"

Marketing and Brand Support

7. Marketing Effectiveness

   • "How effective are the national and regional marketing programs in driving customer traffic?"
   • "Do you feel the 2% Marketing Fund contribution and 2% Supplemental Marketing Fund provide good value?"
   • "What percentage of your customers come from franchisor marketing versus your own local efforts?"

8. Brand Reputation

   • "How has the Massage Envy brand reputation affected your business, both positively and negatively?"
   • "Are you aware of the litigation history disclosed in Item 3, and has it impacted your business?"
   • "How do customers in your market perceive the Massage Envy brand?"

Staffing and Operations

9. Staffing Challenges

   • "What are your biggest challenges in recruiting and retaining qualified massage therapists and aestheticians?"
   • "What is your average therapist/aesthetician turnover rate?"
   • "How competitive are the compensation structures you must offer to attract quality staff?"

10. Membership Model

    • "How well does the membership model work in practice?"
    • "What is your member retention rate, and what are the main reasons for cancellations?"
    • "Do you have issues with unused member credits or service redemptions?"

Territory and Competition

11. Territory Protection

    • "Has your territory been adequately protected from other Massage Envy locations?"
    • "Have you experienced encroachment issues or territory disputes?"
    • "Is your territory size sufficient to support your business goals?"

12. Competition

    • "Who are your main competitors, and how do you differentiate from them?"
    • "Has competition increased since you opened, and how has it affected your business?"

Franchisor Relationship

13. Communication and Transparency

    • "How transparent is the franchisor about system-wide issues and changes?"
    • "Do you feel your input and concerns are heard and addressed?"
    • "How effective is the franchisee advisory council or similar franchisee representation?"

14. System Changes and Mandates

    • "Have there been significant system changes or new mandates since you joined?"
    • "How reasonable and beneficial have these changes been for your business?"
    • "Were you consulted or given adequate notice before major changes were implemented?"

Overall Satisfaction and Recommendation

15. Would You Do It Again?
    • "Knowing what you know now, would you purchase this franchise again?"
    • "Would you recommend this franchise opportunity to a friend or family member?"
    • "If you could change one thing about the franchise system, what would it be?"
    • "Are you planning to open additional locations, and why or why not?"

Questions for Former Franchisees Who Exited Voluntarily (10 Questions)

Exit Decision

1. Primary Reasons for Leaving

   • "What were the main reasons you decided to exit the Massage Envy system?"
   • "Was the decision primarily financial, operational, or related to the franchisor relationship?"
   • "How long did you operate before deciding to exit?"

2. Financial Performance

   • "Did you achieve profitability during your time as a franchisee?"
   • "How did your actual financial performance compare to your expectations and the FDD representations?"
   • "Were you able to sell your business, and if so, did you recoup your initial investment?"

Operational Challenges

3. Biggest Challenges

   • "What were the most significant operational challenges you faced?"
   • "Were these challenges specific to Massage Envy or common to the industry?"
   • "Did the franchisor provide adequate support to address these challenges?"

4. Staffing Issues

   • "How difficult was it to recruit and retain qualified therapists and aestheticians?"
   • "Did staffing challenges contribute to your decision to exit?"

Franchisor Relationship

5. Support and Communication

   • "How would you characterize your relationship with the franchisor?"
   • "Did you feel supported throughout your time as a franchisee?"
   • "Were there any disputes or conflicts with the franchisor?"

6. System Changes

   • "Did changes to the franchise system or new mandates affect your decision to exit?"
   • "Were fees increased or new fees added during your tenure?"

Exit Process

7. Selling or Closing Process

   • "How difficult was the process of exiting the franchise system?"
   • "Did the franchisor cooperate with your exit, or were there obstacles?"
   • "If you sold your franchise, did the franchisor facilitate or hinder the sale?"

8. Transfer Restrictions

   • "Did you encounter any unreasonable restrictions when trying to sell your business?"
   • "How long did the transfer approval process take?"

Financial Recovery

9. Investment Recovery
   • "Were you able to recover your initial investment?"
   • "What was your total financial loss or gain when you exited?"
   • "Do you have any ongoing financial obligations to the franchisor?"

Advice and Recommendations

10. Advice for Prospective Franchisees
    • "What advice would you give someone considering a Massage Envy franchise?"
    • "What should prospective franchisees pay particular attention to in the FDD?"
    • "What questions should they ask that you wish you had asked?"
    • "Would you consider another franchise opportunity in a different system?"

Questions for Terminated Franchisees (7 Questions)

Termination Circumstances

1. Reason for Termination

   • "What was the stated reason for your franchise termination?"
   • "Do you believe the termination was justified?"
   • "Were you given adequate opportunity to cure any alleged defaults?"

2. Warning and Cure Period

   • "Did you receive proper notice of any defaults before termination?"
   • "How much time were you given to correct any issues?"
   • "Did the franchisor work with you to resolve problems, or was termination pursued aggressively?"

Dispute Details

3. Nature of Disputes

   • "What were the primary areas of disagreement with the franchisor?"
   • "Were there financial disputes, operational compliance issues, or other conflicts?"
   • "Did you feel the franchisor's expectations were reasonable and clearly communicated?"

4. Legal Action

   • "Did you pursue legal action or arbitration regarding the termination?"
   • "What was the outcome of any legal proceedings?"
   • "Would you recommend that prospective franchisees carefully review the dispute resolution provisions in the franchise agreement?"

Financial Impact

5. Financial Consequences
   • "What was the financial impact of the termination on you personally?"
   • "Were you required to pay any termination fees or damages?"
   • "Were you able to recover any of your investment?"

System Issues

6. Systemic Problems
   • "Do you believe there are systemic issues within the Massage Envy franchise system?"
   • "Were other franchisees experiencing similar problems?"
   • "Do you think the franchisor's policies and support set franchisees up for success or failure?"

Warning to Others

7. Red Flags and Warnings
   • "What red flags should prospective franchisees watch for?"
   • "What specific provisions in the franchise agreement should they pay particular attention to?"
   • "If you could go back, what would you do differently in your due diligence process?"

Franchisee Interview Guide Template

Pre-Interview Preparation

Before making calls:

1. ✅ Review the complete FDD thoroughly
2. ✅ Prepare a standardized list of questions
3. ✅ Create a spreadsheet to track responses
4. ✅ Schedule calls in advance when possible
5. ✅ Plan for 30-45 minutes per conversation
6. ✅ Prepare to take detailed notes

Interview Structure Template

Opening (2-3 minutes)

"Hi [Name], my name is [Your Name], and I'm considering investing in a Massage Envy 
franchise. The franchisor provided your contact information as a current franchisee. 
Do you have 30-45 minutes to share your experience with me? I really appreciate your 
time and candor."

Background Questions (5 minutes)

• How long have you been a franchisee?
• What is your business background?
• Why did you choose Massage Envy?
• How many locations do you operate?

Core Questions (25-30 minutes)

• Use the specific questions listed above based on franchisee category
• Allow for follow-up questions based on responses
• Take detailed notes on specific numbers, dates, and examples

Closing (5 minutes)

"Thank you so much for your time and honesty. A few final questions:
- Is there anything else you think I should know?
- Are there other franchisees you'd recommend I speak with?
- May I follow up with you if I have additional questions?
- Would you be willing to meet in person if I visit your location?"

Interview Tracking Spreadsheet

Create a spreadsheet with the following columns:

What to Watch For in Franchisee Feedback

Positive Indicators

✅ Consistent Positive Feedback

• Multiple franchisees report profitability within 18-24 months
• High satisfaction with franchisor support and responsiveness
• Positive comments about brand strength and marketing effectiveness
• Franchisees planning to open additional locations

✅ Realistic Expectations

• Franchisees whose actual results align with FDD Item 19 representations
• Honest discussion of challenges with constructive solutions
• Acknowledgment that success requires hard work and proper management

✅ Strong Franchisee Community

• Active franchisee advisory council or association
• Collaborative relationships among franchisees
• Franchisor receptive to franchisee input and feedback

✅ Operational Transparency

• Clear communication about system changes
• Reasonable advance notice for new requirements
• Franchisees feel informed and included in decision-making

Concerning Patterns

⚠️ Financial Red Flags

• Multiple franchisees report taking longer than 3 years to reach profitability
• Actual costs significantly exceed FDD Item 7 estimates
• Franchisees unable to achieve Item 19 financial performance levels
• Unexpected or frequent fee increases
• Difficulty selling franchises or recovering investment

⚠️ Operational Issues

• Consistent complaints about inadequate training or support
• Technology system failures or reliability problems
• Difficulty recruiting and retaining qualified staff
• High franchisee turnover in the system

⚠️ Franchisor Relationship Problems

• Multiple franchisees describe adversarial relationship with franchisor
• Complaints about lack of transparency or communication
• Franchisees feel their concerns are ignored
• Frequent disputes or litigation between franchisor and franchisees

⚠️ Territory and Competition Concerns

• Reports of territory encroachment or inadequate protection
• Increasing competition from other Massage Envy locations
• Franchisor opening company-owned locations near franchisees

⚠️ Brand Reputation Issues

• Negative publicity affecting local business (reference Item 3 litigation)
• Declining brand perception in the market
• Customer complaints about service quality or business practices

Critical Red Flags in Franchisee Responses

Immediate Disqualifiers

🚩 Severe Financial Distress

• Multiple franchisees report ongoing losses after 3+ years

---

Massage Envy Franchise Territory Analysis (Item 12)

Overview

Critical Finding: The Massage Envy FDD provided does not contain Item 12 (Territory) content. According to the FDD structure overview, Item 12 is marked as "not found" with no content summary available.

What This Means for Prospective Franchisees

The absence of Item 12 content in the provided FDD documentation is highly unusual and concerning. Item 12 is a mandatory disclosure item under FTC franchise regulations that must address:

• Territory size and boundaries
• Exclusivity provisions
• Franchisor rights to compete
• Performance requirements tied to territory
• Encroachment policies

Standard Territory Provisions (Based on FDD References)

While the complete Item 12 text is not available in the provided documentation, we can identify some territory-related provisions mentioned elsewhere in the FDD:

Territory Performance Requirements

From the "Special Risks to Consider" section (Page 4):

💡

"Sales Performance Required. You must maintain minimum sales performance levels. Your inability to maintain these levels may result in loss of any territorial rights you are granted, termination of your franchise, and loss of your investment."

Key Implications:

• Territory rights are conditional, not permanent
• Failure to meet sales thresholds can result in loss of territorial protection
• This represents a significant financial risk

Regional Developer Structure

The FDD indicates that Massage Envy operates with Regional Developers who:

• Control specific development areas
• Assist with franchisee support services
• Receive portions of franchise fees and royalties from franchisees in their territory
• As of December 31, 2023: 9 Regional Developers operating 11 Regional Developer businesses

Important Note: The Regional Developer program ceased accepting new franchises in September 2012, but existing Regional Developers continue to operate.

What Should Be Disclosed (But Is Missing)

Based on FTC requirements, Item 12 should contain:

1. Territory Definition

• Geographic boundaries (radius, zip codes, or specific boundaries)
• Population requirements
• Demographic criteria
• Square mileage

2. Exclusivity Provisions

• Whether territory is exclusive or non-exclusive
• What activities are protected within the territory
• Duration of territorial protection

3. Franchisor Rights

• Can Massage Envy open company-owned locations near you?
• Can they franchise other locations in or near your territory?
• Rights to operate through alternative channels (online, retail, etc.)

4. Minimum Performance Standards

• Specific sales quotas or thresholds
• Timeframes for achieving performance standards
• Consequences of failing to meet standards

5. Encroachment Policies

• How close can another Massage Envy location be to yours?
• What happens if territories overlap?
• Compensation for encroachment (if any)

6. Territory Modification Rights

• Can the franchisor reduce your territory?
• Under what circumstances?
• What notice is required?

Red Flags and Concerns

🚩 Critical Red Flags

⚠️ Warning: Sales Performance Requirement

The FDD explicitly states that failure to maintain minimum sales performance levels can result in loss of territorial rights. However, without Item 12, you cannot determine:

• What the minimum sales levels are
• How they are calculated
• What timeframe applies
• Whether they are realistic for your market

Alternative Distribution Channels

Gift Card Program

The FDD mentions that an affiliate, Massage Envy Gift Card Funding, LLC, administers gift card sales. Key questions:

• Can customers purchase gift cards online and redeem at any location?
• Does this impact your territorial exclusivity?
• Do you receive credit for gift cards redeemed at your location but purchased elsewhere?

This information should be clarified in Item 12 but is not available in the provided documentation.

Comparison: Territory Provisions in Similar Franchise Systems

What You Must Do

Before Signing Any Agreement:

1. Request Complete Item 12 Disclosure

   • Demand the full, current FDD with complete Item 12
   • Do not proceed without this critical information
   • Verify the FDD issuance date (should be April 29, 2024, or more recent)

2. Ask Specific Territory Questions

   ✓ What is the exact size of my territory?
   ✓ Is my territory exclusive for all services?
   ✓ What are the specific minimum sales performance requirements?
   ✓ Can Massage Envy open competing locations near me?
   ✓ Can other franchisees operate in my territory?
   ✓ What happens if I meet all requirements but sales are low due to market conditions?
   ✓ How are territories determined and assigned?
   ✓ What demographic or population criteria must my territory meet?
   

3. Consult with Current Franchisees

   • Ask about their territory size and protection
   • Inquire about encroachment experiences
   • Determine if performance requirements are realistic
   • Find out if anyone has lost territorial rights

4. Conduct Independent Market Analysis

   • Assess population density in potential territories
   • Identify existing Massage Envy locations nearby
   • Evaluate competitive spa and massage businesses
   • Determine realistic revenue potential

5. Hire a Franchise Attorney

   • Have them review the complete Item 12 when provided
   • Negotiate territorial protections if possible
   • Understand your rights and limitations
   • Review performance requirement reasonableness

Territory-Related Fees

Based on other sections of the FDD, these fees may impact territory operations:

Impact on Potential Success

How Territory Affects Your Investment

Without proper territorial protection, you face:

1. Competition from the Franchisor

   • Company-owned locations could open nearby
   • Online sales may not be credited to your location
   • Alternative distribution channels could divert customers

2. Competition from Other Franchisees

   • Multiple locations in close proximity
   • Price competition within the brand
   • Market saturation

3. Performance Pressure

   • Must meet undisclosed sales minimums
   • Risk losing territorial rights
   • Potential termination of franchise

4. Limited Growth Potential

   • Unknown territory size limits customer base
   • Cannot assess market saturation risk
   • Difficult to project revenues

Financial Impact Analysis

Scenario: Territory Loss Due to Performance

If you fail to meet minimum sales performance requirements:

Initial Investment: $605,850 - $1,014,700
+ Ongoing Operating Losses
+ Lost Territory Rights
= TOTAL LOSS OF INVESTMENT

You could lose everything if territorial protections are inadequate or performance requirements are unrealistic.

Questions for Massage Envy Representatives

Essential Territory Questions:

1. Territory Size & Definition

   • "What is the exact geographic boundary of my territory?"
   • "How is territory size determined?"
   • "What population must my territory contain?"

2. Exclusivity

   • "Is my territory exclusive for all Massage Envy services?"
   • "Can you open company-owned locations in my territory?"
   • "Can you franchise other locations in my territory?"

3. Performance Requirements

   • "What are the specific minimum sales performance levels?"
   • "How are these calculated and measured?"
   • "What is the timeframe for meeting these requirements?"
   • "What happens if I fail to meet them?"

4. Encroachment

   • "How close can another Massage Envy location be to mine?"
   • "What protections do I have against encroachment?"
   • "Has any franchisee experienced encroachment issues?"

5. Online & Alternative Channels

   • "How do online sales and gift card purchases affect my territory?"
   • "Do I receive credit for services provided to customers who purchased online?"
   • "What alternative distribution channels exist or are planned?"

6. Territory Modifications

   • "Can you reduce my territory after I sign?"
   • "Under what circumstances?"
   • "What compensation would I receive?"

7. Market Saturation

   • "How many Massage Envy locations are in my market area?"
   • "What is your plan for future development in my region?"
   • "How do you prevent market saturation?"

Recommendations

🔴 DO NOT PROCEED without:

1. ✓ Complete Item 12 disclosure from current FDD
2. ✓ Written clarification of territory size and boundaries
3. ✓ Specific performance requirements in writing
4. ✓ Clear understanding of exclusivity provisions
5. ✓ Legal review by qualified franchise attorney
6. ✓ Conversations with multiple current franchisees about territory issues

⚠️ High Priority Actions:

• Request the complete, current FDD immediately
• Do not sign any agreements until Item 12 is reviewed
• Conduct thorough due diligence on territory provisions
• Negotiate territorial protections if possible
• Verify all verbal promises in writing

Conclusion

The absence of Item 12 content in the provided FDD documentation is a critical gap that prevents comprehensive analysis of territorial provisions. This is one of the most important sections of any franchise disclosure document, as it directly impacts:

• Your competitive position
• Revenue potential
• Investment protection
• Long-term viability

The explicit warning about sales performance requirements potentially resulting in loss of territorial rights makes this information even more critical. Without knowing:

• The size of your territory
• The level of protection you receive
• The specific performance standards required
• The franchisor's rights to compete

You cannot make an informed investment decision.

Final Warning

Do not invest in a Massage Envy franchise until you have:

1. Received and reviewed the complete Item 12 disclosure
2. Had a qualified franchise attorney analyze the territorial provisions
3. Spoken with current franchisees about their territory experiences
4. Conducted independent market analysis of your proposed territory
5. Obtained written clarification of all territory-related questions

The risk of proceeding without this information is too high. Territory provisions can make the difference between a profitable franchise and a failed investment.

---

Document Status: Item 12 content NOT AVAILABLE in provided FDD Recommendation: OBTAIN COMPLETE FDD before proceeding Risk Level: CRITICAL - Cannot evaluate franchise opportunity without this information

---

Massage Envy Franchisor Support & Obligations (Item 11 - Part 1)

Critical Notice Regarding Missing Information

⚠️ SIGNIFICANT LIMITATION: Item 11 content is not available in the provided FDD excerpt.

The FDD structure overview indicates that Item 11 was not found in the provided document pages. Item 11 ("Franchisor's Assistance, Advertising, Computer Systems and Training") is one of the most critical sections of any FDD, as it details exactly what support franchisees can expect from the franchisor.

Based on the Table of Contents (page 7), Item 11 should begin on page 35 of the full FDD document. However, the provided excerpt ends at page 29 (within Item 6 - Other Fees), meaning the actual Item 11 content is not available for analysis.

What We Know From Other Sections

While we cannot provide the comprehensive Item 11 analysis requested, we can extract relevant support-related information from other sections of the provided FDD:

Pre-Opening Support References

From Item 1 and the Franchise Agreement structure, we know that ME SPE Franchising provides support through:

1. Management Agreement Structure: ME SPE Franchising has a management agreement with MEF (Massage Envy Franchising, LLC) under which MEF provides required support and services to franchisees
2. Regional Developer System: Some franchisees receive support through Regional Developers who assist with:
   • Training
   • Opening assistance
   • Ongoing supervision
   • Sales support

Training-Related Fees (From Item 6)

The fee schedule provides clues about training and support structure:

Technology Support (From Item 6)

Site Development Support References (From Item 6)

Note: The "Refresh Program" is referenced but details are in Item 8, which is also not fully available in the provided excerpt.

Marketing Support Structure (From Item 6)

Total Marketing Contribution: Minimum 4% of Gross Sales (potentially more with regional cooperative participation)

What Should Be in Item 11 (Industry Standard)

A complete Item 11 typically includes:

Pre-Opening Support

• Site Selection: Criteria, approval process, demographic analysis
• Lease Negotiation: Level of involvement, approval requirements
• Construction/Design: Architectural plans, construction oversight, approved contractors
• Equipment/Inventory: Ordering assistance, approved suppliers
• Training Program: Duration, location, curriculum, who must attend
• Grand Opening: Marketing support, on-site assistance, promotional materials

Ongoing Support

• Field Support: Visit frequency, duration, areas covered
• Marketing: Materials provided, campaign development, digital marketing
• Technology: Systems provided, updates, technical support
• Continuing Education: Frequency, topics, delivery method
• Operations Manual: Access method, update frequency
• Online Resources: Intranet, franchisee portal, knowledge base

Red Flags From Available Information

1. Management Agreement Structure

The Securitization Transaction created a structure where:

• ME SPE Franchising is the franchisor (owns franchise agreements)
• MEF actually provides the support services under a management agreement
• Concern: This adds a layer of complexity and potential accountability issues

From Item 1: "However, as the franchisor, we will be responsible and accountable to you to make sure that all services we promise to perform under your Franchise Agreement or other agreement you sign with us are performed in compliance with the applicable agreement, regardless of who performs these services on our behalf."

2. Regional Developer Variability

• As of December 31, 2023: 9 Regional Developers operating 11 businesses
• No new Regional Developer franchises offered since September 2012
• Concern: Support quality may vary significantly depending on whether you're in a Regional Developer territory

3. High Technology Fees

• Combined technology fees: ~$1,095/month ($705 P4 + $390 centralized support)
• Annual technology cost: ~$13,140
• Concern: This is a significant fixed cost that continues regardless of sales performance

4. Convention Attendance Mandatory

• Penalty for non-attendance: $400/person/day
• Concern: This creates additional mandatory costs beyond the stated fees

5. Additional Training Costs

• $250/person/day plus expenses for additional training
• Concern: Initial training is included, but ongoing training for new hires is not

Comparison to Industry Standards

Technology Fees

Massage Envy: ~$1,095/month in technology fees Industry Comparison:

• Many franchise systems: $200-500/month for POS and support
• Assessment: Massage Envy's technology fees are on the high end

Marketing Contributions

Massage Envy: 4% of Gross Sales (2% NAF + 2% Supplemental) Industry Comparison:

• Typical franchise systems: 2-4% total
• Assessment: Within industry norms, but on the higher end

Total Ongoing Fees

Massage Envy Total:

• 6% Royalty
• 4% Marketing
• ~$1,095/month technology (~1-2% of sales for average location)
• Total: 11-12% of Gross Sales

Industry Comparison:

• Service franchises typically: 8-12% total
• Assessment: Within normal range but at the higher end

Critical Questions for Prospective Franchisees

Since Item 11 is not available, prospective franchisees should specifically request and review:

Pre-Opening Support Questions

1. Site Selection: What specific assistance is provided? Do you approve sites or just provide criteria?
2. Lease Negotiation: Will you review my lease? Negotiate on my behalf? What are approval requirements?
3. Construction Timeline: What is the typical timeline from site selection to opening?
4. Design Flexibility: How much flexibility do I have in layout and design within brand standards?
5. Equipment Ordering: Do you provide a turnkey equipment package or just specifications?
6. Training Details:
   • How many days?
   • Where is it held?
   • Who must attend?
   • What's covered?
   • Is there hands-on practice?
7. Grand Opening Support: Do you provide on-site support? Marketing materials? Promotional budget?

Ongoing Support Questions

1. Field Representative Visits:
   • How often?
   • How long?
   • What do they review?
   • Do they provide actionable recommendations?
2. Marketing Support:
   • What materials are provided?
   • How are the 4% marketing contributions used?
   • What is the ROI on marketing fund spending?
   • Do I have input on marketing campaigns?
3. Technology Support:
   • What systems are included in the $1,095/month?
   • What is the help desk response time?
   • Are system updates included?
   • What happens if systems go down?
4. Continuing Education:
   • How often is training offered?
   • Is it mandatory or optional?
   • What are the costs beyond the $250/day fee?
5. Operations Manual:
   • How is it accessed?
   • How often is it updated?
   • How are changes communicated?
6. Franchisee Communication:
   • Is there a franchisee advisory council?
   • How often does franchisor communicate with franchisees?
   • What input do franchisees have on system changes?

Gap Analysis: Promised vs. Guaranteed

Without Item 11 available, we cannot perform a complete gap analysis. However, based on the Franchise Agreement structure referenced in Item 1:

Likely Structure

• Mandatory obligations: Specified in Franchise Agreement
• Discretionary services: Likely specified in Operations Manual
• Regional Developer territories: Some services delegated to Regional Developers

Key Distinction to Clarify

Prospective franchisees must understand:

1. What support is contractually required (franchisor must provide)
2. What support is discretionary (franchisor may provide at its option)
3. What support is delegated to Regional Developers (if applicable)

Historical Context: Litigation Impact on Support

The FDD reveals significant litigation history (Item 3) that may impact support:

Franchisee Arbitrations Settlement (2021-2022)

From Item 3: "One hundred and four individual arbitration actions were filed by more than fifty other franchisees" alleging:

• Failure to provide contractually agreed upon services
• Required installation of allegedly faulty point-of-sale system
• Required purchases without contractual right
• Required payment of various fees without contractual right

Settlement: $3,950,000 paid to franchisees in March 2022

Positive Development: As part of settlement, ME SPE agreed to:

• Form ad hoc committee before launching new mandatory products/services
• Include two Envy Owners Association representatives on committee

Implication: This suggests historical issues with:

1. Service delivery
2. Technology systems
3. Unilateral fee increases
4. Franchisee communication

Technology Support Deep Dive

Based on Item 6 fee disclosures:

P4 Technology Components (~$705/month)

The FDD references "P4 Technology" but doesn't detail components in the provided excerpt. Typical components might include:

• Point-of-sale system
• Membership management
• Scheduling system
• Payment processing
• Reporting and analytics

Centralized Tech Solutions & Support ($390/month)

Specifically covers:

• Help desk support
• Technology compliance program

Total Annual Technology Investment

• Monthly: $1,095
• Annual: $13,140
• 5-Year Total: $65,700

Critical Question: What is the ROI on this technology investment? Does it genuinely improve operations and customer experience?

Marketing Support Structure

Three-Tiered Marketing System

Marketing Fund Transparency Questions

1. How is the 2% NAF spent? (National campaigns, digital marketing, brand development?)
2. How is the 2% Supplemental Fund spent? (Regional campaigns, local market support?)
3. What reporting is provided on marketing fund expenditures?
4. Do franchisees have input on marketing strategy?
5. What is the measured ROI on marketing fund spending?

Historical Marketing Fund Issues

The class action settlements (Item 3) don't specifically address marketing fund issues, but franchisees should inquire about:

• Historical marketing fund performance
• Changes in marketing strategy
• Franchisee satisfaction with marketing support

Support Obligations: What We Know vs. What's Missing

What We Know (From Available Sections)

✅ Technology support structure exists (help desk, compliance program)
✅ Training is provided (initial training included, additional training available)
✅ Marketing funds are collected (4% of Gross Sales)
✅ Regional Developer support available (in some territories)
✅ Convention/continuing education offered (attendance mandatory)
✅ Opening audit process exists (up to $500 fee)

What's Missing (Should Be in Item 11)

❌ Specific pre-opening timeline and milestones
❌ Site selection criteria and process
❌ Lease negotiation support details
❌ Construction and design support specifics
❌ Training program duration, location, and curriculum
❌ Grand opening support details
❌ Field representative visit frequency and scope
❌ Specific marketing materials and campaigns provided
❌ Technology systems detailed specifications
❌ Operations manual access and update process
❌ Online support resources description

Recommendations for Prospective Franchisees

1. Obtain Complete Item 11

Request the full FDD with complete Item 11 before making any decisions. This is critical information that cannot be substituted.

2. Validate Support Through Current Franchisees

Contact current franchisees (listed in Exhibit C) and ask specifically about:

• Quality of pre-opening support
• Frequency and value of field representative visits
• Responsiveness of help desk and support services
• Value received from marketing fund contributions
• Overall satisfaction with franchisor support

3. Understand Regional Developer Impact

If your territory has a Regional Developer:

• Who is the Regional Developer?
• What support do they provide vs. corporate?
• What is their track record?
• How do franchisees in their territory rate their support?

4. Review Technology Systems

• Request a demonstration of all technology systems
• Understand what's included in the $1,095/month fee
• Evaluate whether the systems justify the cost
• Ask about system reliability and downtime history

5. Clarify Mandatory vs. Discretionary Support

Get in writing:

• What support is contractually required
• What support is discretionary
• What happens if promised support isn't delivered

6. Assess Marketing Fund Performance

• Request marketing fund financial statements
• Review examples of marketing campaigns
• Ask for ROI data on marketing initiatives
• Understand how marketing strategy is determined

7. Evaluate Training Adequacy

• How many days of initial training?
• Is it sufficient to prepare you to open?
• What ongoing training is available?
• What are the real costs of ongoing training?

8. Consider Historical Issues

The 2021-2022 franchisee arbitrations settlement suggests:

• Historical service delivery issues
• Technology system problems
• Communication breakdowns

Ask:

• What has changed since the settlement?
• How has franchisee satisfaction improved?
• What systems are in place to prevent similar issues?

Conclusion and Critical Action Items

This analysis is incomplete without Item 11. The missing information is essential for evaluating the franchise opportunity.

Immediate Action Required

1. ✅ Obtain complete FDD with full Item 11 text
2. ✅ Review Item 11 in detail focusing on specific support commitments
3. ✅ Compare promises to franchisee experiences through validation calls
4. ✅ Evaluate support adequacy relative to fees charged
5. ✅ Assess franchisor accountability given management agreement structure

Key Evaluation Criteria

When you receive complete Item 11, evaluate:

Pre-Opening Support:

• Is site selection assistance adequate?
• Is construction/design support comprehensive?
• Is training sufficient to prepare you for opening?
• Is grand opening support meaningful?

Ongoing Support:

• Are field visits frequent enough to

---

Massage Envy Franchisee Responsibilities & Requirements (Item 9)

Overview

CRITICAL NOTICE: The FDD provided does not contain Item 9 (Franchisee's Obligations) content. According to the FDD structure overview, Item 9 is marked as "found: false" with no content summary available.

What We Know From Other Sections

While the complete Item 9 is not available in the provided FDD, we can extract relevant franchisee obligations and requirements from other sections of the document:

---

Operational Requirements

Day-to-Day Operations

Based on information scattered throughout the FDD, Massage Envy franchisees must:

• Operate continuously during normal business hours without franchisor consent (failure results in fines up to $500 per incident)
• Maintain compliance with all System Standards (mandatory policies, protocols, rules, requirements, specifications, and procedures)
• Ensure only licensed therapists and aestheticians perform services requiring licenses or specialized training
• Comply with all regulatory requirements for massage therapy businesses in their state/municipality

Service Delivery Standards

• Offer professional therapeutic massage services
• Provide Massage Envy's proprietary Total Body Stretch service
• Offer hot stone massage therapy
• Provide customized facial and/or skin care services (including microdermabrasion and chemical peel)
• Maintain a membership-based program structure
• Operate in a "distinctive, clean and friendly environment"

---

Staffing Requirements

Licensing and Qualifications

State-Specific Requirements:

• Many states require massage therapists to be licensed
• Aestheticians must be licensed where required
• Franchisee is responsible for ensuring all staff comply with state/local licensing requirements

⚠️ RED FLAG: The FDD does not specify minimum staffing levels or employee-to-customer ratios, which could impact operational planning.

Staff Training Obligations

---

Owner Participation Requirements

Management Structure

Information Not Available: The provided FDD does not explicitly state:

• Whether owner must be on-site or if absentee ownership is permitted
• Minimum hours of owner participation required
• Whether a designated manager can substitute for owner presence

What We Know:

• Franchisee must ensure Business operates continuously during normal business hours
• If franchisee materially breaches agreement, franchisor may manage Business and charge up to 8% of Gross Sales plus costs

Owner Qualifications

Franchisees must meet minimum standards for:

• Character
• Skill
• Aptitude
• Attitude
• Business ability
• Financial capacity

---

Hours of Operation

Operating Schedule

Mandatory Requirements:

• Must operate continuously during normal business hours
• Cannot close during required operating days without franchisor consent
• Penalty: Up to $500 fine per incident for unauthorized closures

⚠️ CONCERN: Specific hours of operation are not detailed in the available FDD sections. This information would typically be found in Item 9 or the Operations Manual.

---

Quality Control & Compliance Standards

System Standards Compliance

Franchisees must comply with all System Standards, which include:

Non-Compliance Consequences

Fines up to $500 per incident for:

1. Failing to comply with mandatory System Standard without cure within required timeframe
2. Committing same default within 6 months of previous default
3. Failing to operate during required business hours without consent

Safety and Conduct Policies

Critical Requirement: Franchisees must comply with:

• All policies in Operations Manual regarding prevention and handling of inappropriate conduct during massage therapy sessions
• State and local regulatory requirements
• Franchisor's safety policies (violation can lead to termination)

⚠️ MAJOR RED FLAG: The FDD references numerous lawsuits involving alleged sexual misconduct by massage therapists at franchised locations. Strict compliance with safety policies is essential.

---

Reporting Requirements

Financial Reporting

Royalty and Fee Payments

Weekly Payments Due:

• 6% Royalty on Gross Sales
• 2% Marketing Fund contribution
• 2% Supplemental Marketing Fund contribution

Due Date: Day of each week specified by franchisor (based on previous week's Gross Sales)

Technology Reporting

• Must use franchisor-approved POS system (Meevo Software)
• Must maintain connectivity for centralized reporting
• Must comply with PCI Data Security Standards

---

Renovation & Maintenance Obligations

Refresh Program Requirements

Note: Fees may increase if franchisor's costs increase

Ongoing Maintenance

Information Not Available: The provided FDD sections do not detail:

• Specific maintenance schedules
• Equipment replacement requirements
• Facility upgrade timelines
• Remodeling obligations during franchise term

What We Know:

• Must maintain "distinctive, clean and friendly environment"
• Must comply with System Standards for facility appearance
• Opening Audit Fee (up to $500) may be charged to certify readiness to open

---

Technology & POS Requirements

Required Technology Systems

P4 Technology Fees

Monthly Cost: Approximately $705 per month (for cable-enabled internet locations)

Components Include:

• Point-of-sale system
• Payment processing
• Technology infrastructure
• Software licenses
• System updates

⚠️ NOTE: Businesses without cable-enabled internet will see higher monthly costs.

Meevo Software

Monthly Fee: Included in Centralized Tech Solutions & Support Fee

"Go Live" Date: Determines when monthly fees begin

Centralized Tech Solutions & Support Fee

Monthly Cost: $390

Covers:

• Centralized technology support services
• Help desk access
• Technology compliance program

Due Date: 1st of month following "go live" date

Technology Compliance Requirements

Franchisor Assistance: Franchisor assists with certain aspects of PCI compliance as part of Technology Fee services.

---

Comprehensive Obligations Checklist

Pre-Opening Phase

• Pay initial franchise fee ($45,000 or $35,000 for additional locations)
• Secure approved site location
• Complete site development
• Attend and complete initial training
• Hire and train licensed staff
• Install required technology systems
• Obtain all necessary licenses and permits
• Purchase required insurance
• Pass opening audit (up to $500 fee)
• Comply with all pre-opening System Standards

Ongoing Operations

Daily/Weekly

• Operate during all required business hours
• Maintain clean and professional environment
• Ensure only licensed professionals provide services
• Process all transactions through approved POS system
• Submit weekly Gross Sales reports
• Pay weekly royalties and fees (6% + 2% + 2% = 10% of Gross Sales)

Monthly

• Pay P4 Technology Fees (~$705)
• Pay Centralized Tech Solutions & Support Fee ($390)
• Review and maintain compliance with System Standards
• Maintain required insurance coverage
• Process membership agreements and cancellations properly

Annually

• Attend annual convention (or pay $400/person/day penalty)
• Review and renew licenses
• Update training for staff as required
• Maintain financial records for audit purposes

As Required

• Participate in advertising cooperative (if applicable)
• Complete Refresh program upon renewal/transfer
• Attend additional training sessions
• Respond to franchisor audits and inspections
• Update technology systems as required
• Comply with new mandatory System Standards

---

Time Commitment Expectations

Minimum Time Investment

Information Not Available: The FDD does not specify:

• Minimum hours per week required from owner
• Whether full-time or part-time involvement is acceptable
• Specific management time commitments

Operational Demands

Based on Business Model:

• Membership-based service requiring consistent availability
• Must operate during "normal business hours"
• Cannot close without franchisor consent
• Requires management of licensed professionals
• Ongoing compliance monitoring needed

Estimated Commitment (based on industry standards, not FDD):

• Likely requires full-time commitment, especially initially
• Multi-unit operators may need on-site managers
• Significant administrative time for compliance and reporting

---

Financial Reporting Requirements

Required Financial Documentation

Audit Rights

Franchisor May:

• Inspect and audit Business at any time
• Review all financial records
• Verify Gross Sales reporting accuracy

Franchisee Pays Audit Costs If:

• Reports not provided on time
• Supporting records not provided
• Gross Sales understated by more than 2%

Record Retention

Information Not Available: Specific record retention periods not detailed in provided FDD sections.

Standard Practice: Typically 3-7 years for franchise systems

---

Consequences of Non-Compliance

Financial Penalties

Note: All fines deposited into Marketing Fund (franchisor does not profit from fines)

Termination Rights

Franchisor May Terminate For:

• Material breach of Franchise Agreement
• Failure to cure violations within specified timeframe
• Repeated violations of same provision
• Violation of safety policies
• Non-compliance with System Standards

⚠️ CRITICAL: Based on litigation disclosed in Item 3, franchisor has terminated franchises for safety policy violations.

Management Takeover

If Franchisee Materially Breaches:

• Franchisor may manage Business
• Charges up to 8% of Gross Sales
• Plus all costs and expenses
• Franchisee remains liable for all obligations

---

Technology-Specific Obligations

POS System Requirements

Mandatory System: Meevo Software

Monthly Costs:

• P4 Technology Fees: ~$705
• Centralized Support: $390
• Total Technology: ~$1,095/month

Data Security Obligations

PCI DSS Compliance:

• Franchisee responsible for compliance
• Must accept credit cards
• Franchisor provides some compliance assistance
• Non-compliance creates liability risk

⚠️ IMPORTANT: Affiliate Dunkin' Brands settled with NY Attorney General for $650,000 over data breach issues (see Item 3). Data security is critical.

System Updates

• Must maintain current software versions
• Must implement required technology changes
• Must use approved payment processing
• Must maintain system connectivity

---

Insurance and Liability Requirements

Required Insurance

Information Not Available: Specific insurance requirements not detailed in provided FDD sections.

Typical Requirements (to be confirmed in complete FDD):

• General liability insurance
• Professional liability insurance
• Workers' compensation
• Property insurance
• Cyber liability insurance (given data breach risks)

Indemnification Obligations

Franchisee Must Indemnify Franchisor For:

• Any damages from franchisee's breach
• Claims relating to Business operations
• Litigation costs and attorneys' fees
• Amounts "will vary with circumstances"

⚠️ MAJOR CONCERN: Given the numerous sexual misconduct lawsuits disclosed in Item 3, indemnification obligations could be substantial.

---

Special Compliance Areas

Sexual Misconduct Prevention

Critical Requirements:

• Must comply with all Operations Manual policies on prevention of inappropriate conduct
• Must comply with state/local regulations
• Must ensure proper screening and training of therapists
• Failure creates significant liability risk

⚠️ EXTREME RED FLAG: Item 3 discloses "numerous lawsuits" by customers alleging sexual misconduct by massage therapists. This is a critical compliance area.

Health Spa/Health Club Laws

State-Specific Requirements:

• Some states may require bond posting
• Health club laws may regulate customer agreements
• May affect membership cancellation procedures
• Franchisee responsible for compliance

Escheat Laws

State Requirements:

• Must comply with state escheat laws
• Relates to unused gift cards and memberships
• Franchisee responsible for compliance
• Requirements vary by state

---

Regional Developer Considerations

If Located in Regional Developer Territory

Franchisor May Delegate to Regional Developer:

• Sales support
• Training services
• Site assistance
• Supervisory services

Regional Developer Receives:

• Portion of initial franchise fees
• Portion of ongoing royalty fees

Franchisee Obligations:

• Cooperate with Regional Developer
• Participate in Regional Developer programs
• Maintain communication with Regional Developer

Current Status: As of December 31, 2023:

• 9 Regional Developers operating
• 11 Regional Developer businesses
• No new Regional Developer franchises offered since September 2012

---

Practical Implications for Potential Franchisees

Time and Attention Required

High Commitment Level:

• Membership-based model requires consistent operations
• Cannot close without permission
• Weekly reporting requirements
• Ongoing compliance monitoring
• Staff management and training

Recommendation: Plan for full-time involvement, especially in first 1-2 years.

Financial Obligations Summary

Weekly Ongoing Fees: 10% of Gross Sales

• 6% Royalty
• 2% Marketing Fund
• 2% Supplemental Marketing Fund

Monthly Technology Fees: ~$1,095

• $705 P4 Technology
• $390 Centralized Support

Annual Obligations:

• Convention attendance (or $400/person/day penalty)
• License renewals
• Insurance renewals
• Potential additional training costs

Compliance Complexity

High Complexity Areas:

1. Safety and Misconduct Prevention (critical given litigation history)
2. Licensing Requirements (state-specific for therapists/aestheticians)
3. Technology and Data Security (PCI compliance)
4. Health Club Laws (state-specific)
5. System Standards (mandatory vs. suggested)

Risk Factors

Significant Risks:

1. Litigation Exposure: Numerous sexual misconduct lawsuits disclosed
2. Regulatory Compliance: Multiple layers of licensing and regulation
3. Technology Dependence: Mandatory systems with ongoing fees
4. Limited Flexibility: Cannot close without permission, mandatory hours
5. **Financial

---

Massage Envy Franchise Training Programme (Item 11 - Part 2)

Overview

IMPORTANT NOTE: The Massage Envy Franchise Disclosure Document (FDD) provided does not contain Item 11 content. The document structure shows that Item 11 exists (listed in the Table of Contents on page 7 as "ITEM 11 FRANCHISOR'S ASSISTANCE, ADVERTISING, COMPUTER SYSTEMS AND TRAINING" on page 35), but the actual content of Item 11 is not included in the provided FDD text.

The FDD text provided ends at Item 6 (Other Fees) and does not include the detailed training provisions that would typically be found in Item 11.

What Should Be in Item 11

Based on standard FDD requirements and the brief mentions in other sections of the provided document, Item 11 should contain detailed information about:

Expected Training Components

While the specific details are not available in the provided FDD excerpt, the document does reference training in several places:

From Item 6 - Other Fees:

From Item 2 - Business Experience:

The document mentions a Director of Franchise Development (Samantha Wallace) who has been in that role since October 2020, suggesting there is a franchise development and training infrastructure in place.

Information Not Available

The following critical training information cannot be determined from the provided FDD excerpt:

Initial Training Programme

• ❌ Duration of initial training
• ❌ Location(s) where training is conducted
• ❌ Specific topics covered in training curriculum
• ❌ Number of hours for each training subject
• ❌ Whether training is mandatory or optional

Training Attendance Requirements

• ❌ Who must attend training (owner, manager, employees)
• ❌ Number of people required to complete training
• ❌ Timing requirements (before opening, after opening)

Training Costs

• ❌ What costs are covered by the franchisor
• ❌ What costs are the franchisee's responsibility
• ❌ Estimated travel and accommodation expenses
• ❌ Whether there are charges for initial training

Ongoing Training

• ❌ Availability of ongoing training programs
• ❌ Frequency of refresher training
• ❌ Requirements for continuing education
• ❌ Online training platform details

Employee Training

• ❌ Training requirements for massage therapists
• ❌ Training requirements for aestheticians
• ❌ Training for front desk staff
• ❌ Management training programs

Training Delivery Methods

• ❌ Balance of online vs. in-person training
• ❌ Self-paced learning options
• ❌ Classroom instruction details
• ❌ On-site training at franchisee location

Certification and Assessment

• ❌ Testing or certification requirements
• ❌ Performance standards for training completion
• ❌ Remedial training provisions

Regulatory Context from Item 1

The FDD does provide important context about regulatory requirements that would likely be addressed in training:

Licensing Requirements

From Item 1:

💡

"Many states require massage therapists and aestheticians to be licensed and you must ensure that your Business and the therapists and aestheticians who work in your Business comply with these requirements. You must ensure that only licensed therapists and aestheticians perform any services for which a license or specialized training is required."

This indicates that training must address:

• State-specific licensing requirements for massage therapists
• State-specific licensing requirements for aestheticians
• Compliance with professional standards
• Verification of employee credentials

Safety and Compliance Training

From Item 1:

💡

"You must be aware of and comply with all regulatory requirements to which a massage therapy business in your state or municipality may be subject to, in addition to our policies contained in the Operations Manual, the purpose of which is the prevention and handling of inappropriate conduct during massage therapy sessions."

This suggests training must cover:

• Prevention of inappropriate conduct
• Handling of inappropriate conduct incidents
• Compliance with Operations Manual policies
• Risk management procedures

Additional Compliance Areas

The FDD mentions several other areas that would require training:

Health Spa/Health Club Laws:

💡

"Some state or local laws may require that you file and post a bond if your Business is a 'health spa' or 'health club.' Health club laws may also regulate other aspects of your Business, including your agreements with your customers."

Payment Card Industry Compliance:

💡

"Since you accept credit cards from your customers, you will also have to comply with any laws and regulations relating to the acceptance of credit cards, including the Payment Card Industry ('PCI') Data Security Standard ('DSS')."

Pandemic/Public Health Requirements:

💡

"You also must comply with all applicable laws, rules, and orders of any governmental authority concerning any pandemic or public health crisis, which may require businesses to materially modify, limit, or cease operations for an indeterminate period."

Operations Manual Reference

From Item 9 (Franchisee's Obligations) and Exhibit E (Operations Manual Table of Contents), there is reference to an Operations Manual, which typically contains detailed training materials and operational procedures. However, the specific contents are not provided in this FDD excerpt.

Regional Developer Training Support

From Item 1:

💡

"Regional Developers also assist us (and in the past, our predecessors) in rendering certain support services to those franchisees within the Regional Developer's development area including training, opening assistance and ongoing supervision."

This indicates that in some territories, Regional Developers may provide training support, though the specific division of responsibilities is not detailed in the provided excerpt.

Practical Implications for Prospective Franchisees

What You Should Request

Given the absence of Item 11 content in this excerpt, prospective franchisees should:

1. Request the complete Item 11 from the franchisor before making any investment decision

2. Ask specific questions about:

   • Total time commitment for initial training
   • Location of training facilities
   • Whether training can be completed remotely
   • Total estimated costs including travel
   • Ongoing training requirements and costs
   • Support available during the first 90 days of operation

3. Speak with current franchisees (listed in Exhibit C) about:

   • Quality and comprehensiveness of training received
   • Adequacy of training for actual business operations
   • Ongoing support and training availability
   • Whether additional training was needed beyond what was provided

Red Flags to Watch For

When you receive the complete Item 11, be alert for:

• ⚠️ Insufficient training duration - Massage therapy businesses require significant operational knowledge
• ⚠️ High additional training costs - The $250/person/day fee for additional training could add up quickly
• ⚠️ Mandatory convention attendance - The $400/person/day penalty for missing conventions is substantial
• ⚠️ Limited ongoing support - Given the complexity of compliance requirements, ongoing training is essential
• ⚠️ Inadequate employee training - Your staff will need comprehensive training on services, safety, and compliance

Critical Questions About Training

Before investing, ensure you understand:

1. Initial Training:

   • How many days/weeks is initial training?
   • Where is training conducted?
   • Can training be completed before site selection?
   • What happens if you fail training assessments?

2. Pre-Opening Support:

   • What on-site assistance is provided before opening?
   • Is there a grand opening support team?
   • How long does pre-opening training last?

3. Ongoing Training:

   • What continuing education is required?
   • How often are refresher courses offered?
   • Are there annual training requirements?
   • What online training resources are available?

4. Employee Training:

   • What training is provided for massage therapists?
   • What training is provided for aestheticians?
   • How are front desk staff trained?
   • Is there a training program for managers?

5. Specialized Training:

   • Training on the proprietary Total Body Stretch service
   • Training on hot stone massage therapy
   • Training on facial and skin care services
   • Training on microdermabrasion and chemical peel services
   • Training on the membership-based business model

Comparison to Industry Standards

Without the actual Item 11 content, it's impossible to compare Massage Envy's training program to industry standards. However, typical franchise training programs in the personal services industry include:

Technology Training Considerations

From Item 6, there are significant technology fees:

These fees suggest substantial technology systems that would require comprehensive training, including:

• Point-of-sale system (Meevo Software mentioned)
• Membership management system
• Scheduling and booking system
• Payment processing
• Reporting and analytics
• Marketing automation tools

Training on these systems should be a significant component of the initial training program.

Conclusion and Recommendations

Critical Information Missing

This analysis is severely limited by the absence of Item 11 content in the provided FDD excerpt. Item 11 is one of the most important sections of any FDD, as it details exactly what training and support you will receive for your substantial investment ($605,850 to $1,014,700 total investment).

Action Items for Prospective Franchisees

Before proceeding with any Massage Envy franchise purchase:

1. ✅ Obtain the complete FDD with Item 11 included
2. ✅ Review the training curriculum in detail
3. ✅ Calculate total training costs including travel, lodging, and time away from other work
4. ✅ Speak with at least 10 current franchisees about training quality
5. ✅ Speak with former franchisees (if listed in Exhibit G) about training adequacy
6. ✅ Visit the training facility if possible
7. ✅ Request to observe a training session if permitted
8. ✅ Review the Operations Manual table of contents (Exhibit E) for training topics
9. ✅ Understand your state's licensing requirements for massage therapists and aestheticians
10. ✅ Assess whether the training prepares you for these regulatory requirements

Investment Perspective

Given the substantial investment required ($605,850 to $1,014,700) and the complexity of operating a massage therapy business with multiple service lines (massage, stretch therapy, facials, skin care), comprehensive training is absolutely essential.

The quality and comprehensiveness of the training program should be a major factor in your franchise selection decision. Do not proceed without thoroughly reviewing Item 11 and validating the training program's quality with current franchisees.

Legal and Regulatory Training Importance

The FDD makes clear that franchisees face significant regulatory compliance requirements:

• State licensing for therapists and aestheticians
• Health spa/health club regulations
• Payment card industry compliance
• Safety and inappropriate conduct prevention
• Pandemic and public health requirements

Your training must adequately prepare you to manage these compliance obligations. Failure to comply could result in:

• Loss of licenses
• Legal liability
• Franchise termination
• Financial losses
• Reputational damage

Final Note

This analysis cannot be considered complete without the actual Item 11 content. The information provided here is based solely on references to training found elsewhere in the FDD excerpt and general franchise industry knowledge.

Do not make any franchise investment decision without reviewing the complete Item 11 training provisions in the official Massage Envy FDD.

---

Disclaimer: This analysis is based on an incomplete FDD excerpt that does not include Item 11. Prospective franchisees must obtain and review the complete, current FDD including all Items before making any investment decision. Consult with a franchise attorney and accountant before signing any franchise agreement.

---

Massage Envy Vendor Requirements & Supply Chain (Item 8)

Overview

CRITICAL NOTICE: Item 8 data is not available in the provided FDD documentation. The FDD structure overview indicates that Item 8 (Restrictions on Sources of Products and Services) was not found in the document provided. This is a significant limitation as Item 8 typically contains crucial information about supplier requirements, purchasing restrictions, and franchisor financial interests in the supply chain.

What We Know From Other Sections

While the complete Item 8 disclosure is unavailable, we can extract relevant supplier and purchasing information from other sections of the FDD:

Technology-Related Vendor Requirements

From Item 6 (Other Fees), we can identify mandatory technology purchases:

Total Technology Costs: ~$1,095/month or $13,140/year

Known Supplier Restrictions

1. Technology Systems (Mandatory)

From Item 11, franchisees must use:

• Meevo Software - Proprietary point-of-sale and business management system
• Meevo Subscription Agreement (Exhibit H) - Required separate agreement
• Specific hardware and software components as part of P4 Technology package
• Centralized payment processing systems (PCI compliance requirements mentioned)

2. Products and Services

The FDD mentions:

• "High-end product line" for facials and skin care services
• Massage Envy's "proprietary Total Body Stretch service"
• Specific products for services (microdermabrasion, chemical peels, etc.)

However, specific supplier names, pricing, and purchasing requirements are not disclosed in the available sections.

Franchisor-Owned or Affiliated Suppliers

Known Affiliates Providing Services:

Important Note: The FDD does not explicitly disclose in the available sections whether the franchisor receives rebates, commissions, or other financial benefits from third-party suppliers.

Red Flags and Concerns

🚩 Major Red Flags

1. Missing Item 8 Disclosure

   • Item 8 is one of the most critical sections for understanding your cost structure
   • Without this information, you cannot accurately assess:
     • Total cost of goods sold (COGS)
     • Supplier flexibility
     • Franchisor financial interests in suppliers
     • Markup on required purchases

2. Technology Lock-In

   • Mandatory $13,140/year in technology fees
   • Proprietary Meevo system creates vendor lock-in
   • No disclosed alternatives or competitive bidding

3. Lack of Pricing Transparency

   • No disclosed pricing for required products
   • No information on product markup
   • No disclosure of franchisor rebates or commissions

4. Potential Hidden Costs

   • "High-end product line" suggests premium pricing
   • No disclosed volume discounts
   • No information on minimum purchase requirements

Critical Questions You Must Ask

Before Signing Any Agreement:

1. Supplier Requirements:

   • What products MUST be purchased from specific suppliers?
   • What products can be purchased from any supplier meeting specifications?
   • Are there approved supplier lists?
   • Can I propose alternative suppliers?

2. Pricing and Costs:

   • What is the actual cost of required products?
   • What percentage of revenue typically goes to product costs?
   • Are there volume discounts available?
   • What are minimum order quantities?

3. Franchisor Financial Interests:

   • Does Massage Envy receive rebates from suppliers?
   • What commissions or fees does the franchisor earn on my purchases?
   • Are there any franchisor-owned suppliers?
   • How much does the franchisor profit from my supply purchases?

4. Technology Costs:

   • What exactly is included in the $705/month P4 Technology Fee?
   • Are there additional technology costs not disclosed?
   • What happens if technology costs increase?
   • Can I use alternative systems?

5. Product Specifications:

   • What are the quality specifications for products?
   • Can I source equivalent products at lower costs?
   • Are brand names required or just specifications?

Estimated Impact on Profit Margins

Known Technology Costs:

Annual Technology Fees: $13,140
Percentage of Minimum Investment: 1.3% - 2.2%

Estimated Product Costs (Industry Standards):

Since specific data is unavailable, here are typical ranges for massage/spa businesses:

⚠️ WARNING: These are industry estimates only. Actual Massage Envy requirements may be significantly higher or lower.

Comparison: Required vs. Recommended Suppliers

Cannot be completed without Item 8 disclosure.

A complete Item 8 would typically include:

• ✅ List of required suppliers (mandatory purchases)
• ✅ List of approved suppliers (must choose from list)
• ✅ List of recommended suppliers (optional)
• ✅ Specifications for products (can source anywhere meeting specs)

This information is NOT available in the provided FDD sections.

Can You Choose Your Own Suppliers?

What We Know:

Technology: NO

• Must use Meevo software system
• Must use specified P4 Technology components
• No alternatives disclosed

Products and Services: UNKNOWN

• Item 8 not available to confirm
• Likely significant restrictions based on:
  • "High-end product line" language
  • Proprietary services mentioned
  • Franchise system standardization requirements

Equipment: UNKNOWN

• No information provided in available sections

Practical Implications for Franchisees

Financial Impact:

1. Fixed Technology Costs:

   • $13,140/year is non-negotiable
   • Represents 2-3% of estimated annual revenue
   • Must be factored into all financial projections

2. Unknown Product Costs:

   • Could represent 10-20% of revenue
   • Significant impact on profit margins
   • Cannot be accurately estimated without Item 8

3. Potential Markup Concerns:

   • If franchisor receives rebates/commissions, you may pay above-market prices
   • No disclosed competitive bidding process
   • Limited negotiating power

Operational Impact:

1. Limited Flexibility:

   • Cannot shop for better prices on required items
   • Cannot substitute equivalent products
   • Dependent on franchisor's supplier relationships

2. Quality Control:

   • Standardization ensures consistent customer experience
   • May limit ability to differentiate your location
   • Product quality dependent on franchisor's choices

3. Supply Chain Risk:

   • Single-source suppliers create vulnerability
   • Product shortages could impact operations
   • Price increases directly affect your margins

What Item 8 Should Disclose (But Doesn't in This FDD)

A complete Item 8 disclosure should include:

Required Information:

• ✅ Designated/Required Suppliers: Specific suppliers you MUST use
• ✅ Approved Supplier Lists: Suppliers you may choose from
• ✅ Product Specifications: Standards products must meet
• ✅ Franchisor Revenue: All rebates, commissions, and other payments franchisor receives
• ✅ Purchasing Cooperatives: Any group purchasing arrangements
• ✅ Franchisor-Owned Suppliers: Any suppliers owned by franchisor or affiliates
• ✅ Price Controls: Any requirements about pricing or markups
• ✅ Alternative Supplier Process: How to propose new suppliers

Typical Disclosure Items Missing:

1. Supplier Names and Contact Information
2. Estimated Annual Purchase Volumes
3. Franchisor's Percentage of Revenue from Supplier Relationships
4. Negotiated Pricing Arrangements
5. Volume Discount Structures
6. Minimum Purchase Requirements
7. Payment Terms with Suppliers
8. Supplier Performance Standards

Recommendations for Prospective Franchisees

Before Proceeding:

1. Obtain Complete Item 8:

   • Request the full Item 8 disclosure from the franchisor
   • Do not proceed without this critical information
   • Verify the document is current (dated 2024)

2. Interview Current Franchisees:

   • Ask about actual product costs (see Exhibit C for franchisee list)
   • Inquire about supplier satisfaction
   • Determine typical COGS percentages
   • Ask about price increases over time

3. Request Detailed Cost Breakdown:

   • Get specific pricing for all required products
   • Calculate total annual supply costs
   • Compare to industry standards
   • Factor into financial projections

4. Analyze Technology Costs:

   • Understand exactly what the $13,140/year covers
   • Determine if costs have increased historically
   • Compare to alternative systems
   • Assess value received for fees paid

5. Investigate Franchisor Financial Interests:

   • Ask directly about rebates and commissions
   • Request disclosure of all supplier-related revenue
   • Understand potential conflicts of interest
   • Evaluate impact on your costs

Due Diligence Checklist:

• Obtain complete Item 8 disclosure
• Interview minimum 10 current franchisees about supplier costs
• Request 12-month product cost history from existing franchisees
• Calculate estimated COGS as percentage of revenue
• Compare technology costs to industry alternatives
• Verify all franchisor financial interests in suppliers
• Review supplier contracts for terms and pricing
• Assess flexibility to change suppliers
• Understand product quality standards
• Evaluate supply chain reliability

Industry Context

Typical Spa/Massage Business Supply Costs:

Competitive Comparison:

Advantages of Restricted Suppliers:

• Consistent product quality across system
• Potential volume discounts
• Simplified ordering and inventory
• Proven products and suppliers

Disadvantages of Restricted Suppliers:

• Higher costs due to lack of competition
• Limited negotiating power
• Potential franchisor conflicts of interest
• Reduced operational flexibility

Financial Modeling Considerations

Conservative Assumptions (Without Item 8 Data):

Annual Revenue (estimated): $500,000 - $800,000

Known Costs:
- Technology Fees: $13,140 (2.6% - 1.6% of revenue)

Estimated Costs (Industry Standards):
- Product COGS: $50,000 - $120,000 (10-15% of revenue)
- Total Supply Chain: $63,140 - $133,140 (12.6% - 16.6% of revenue)

Impact on Profit Margin:
- If industry standard: Manageable
- If above industry standard: Significant margin compression

⚠️ CRITICAL: These are estimates only. Actual costs could be substantially different.

Legal and Contractual Considerations

From Available Franchise Agreement References:

1. Mandatory Compliance:

   • Must comply with all System Standards
   • Fines up to $500 for non-compliance
   • Potential termination for repeated violations

2. Unilateral Changes:

   • Franchisor can change suppliers and requirements
   • Must implement changes within specified timeframes
   • Costs of changes borne by franchisee

3. No Guarantees:

   • No guarantee of pricing stability
   • No guarantee of supplier availability
   • No guarantee of product quality

Summary and Conclusions

What We Know:

✅ Technology costs are mandatory: $13,140/year minimum ✅ Proprietary systems required: Meevo software, P4 Technology ✅ Affiliate companies exist: Gift card and marketing administration ✅ High-end products required: Premium product line mentioned

What We Don't Know (Critical Gaps):

❌ Specific supplier requirements: Which suppliers are mandatory ❌ Product pricing: Actual costs of required products ❌ Franchisor financial interests: Rebates, commissions, markups ❌ Total COGS impact: Percentage of revenue for supplies ❌ Supplier flexibility: Ability to choose alternatives ❌ Quality specifications: Standards for products and services

Bottom Line:

The absence of Item 8 disclosure in the provided FDD is a MAJOR RED FLAG. This information is essential for:

• Accurate financial projections
• Understanding true profit potential
• Assessing franchisor conflicts of interest
• Evaluating total investment requirements
• Making an informed franchise decision

Final Recommendation:

DO NOT PROCEED without obtaining and thoroughly reviewing:

1. Complete Item 8 disclosure from current FDD
2. Detailed supplier and product cost information
3. Verification of franchisor financial interests
4. Confirmation from multiple current franchisees about actual supply costs
5. Independent analysis of technology value vs. cost

The supply chain and vendor requirements can make or break your franchise profitability. Without complete transparency in Item 8, you cannot accurately assess this opportunity.

---

Disclaimer: This analysis is based on incomplete information. The absence of Item 8 data significantly limits the accuracy and completeness of this assessment. Prospective franchisees should obtain complete FDD documentation and consult with franchise attorneys and accountants before making any investment decisions.

---

Massage Envy Franchise Brand Strength & Market Position

Overview

Important Disclosure Limitation: The FDD provided does not contain specific information about brand recognition metrics, market positioning data, social media engagement statistics, customer satisfaction scores, industry awards, or media coverage details. The analysis below is based solely on information available in the FDD documents provided.

Brand History and Market Presence

Franchise System Size and Growth

Massage Envy operates one of the largest massage and spa franchise systems in the United States:

Key Historical Milestones:

• February 2003: Predecessor began offering franchises for traditional massage-only businesses
• August 2009: Introduced "total body care" concept (massage + facials + stretch therapy)
• September 2012: Acquired by Roark Capital Group (private equity)
• February 2010 - September 2012: Offered Regional Developer franchises (no longer available)
• June 2019: Restructured through securitization transaction; ME SPE Franchising became franchisor
• Historical Sales: 825 traditional franchises + 64 total body care franchises sold by predecessor (400 traditional locations converted to total body care)

Market Positioning

Based on the FDD information, Massage Envy positions itself as a mid-market, membership-based wellness provider:

Service Model:

• Membership program offering one massage or facial per month for a monthly fee
• Members receive additional services at reduced rates
• Non-members can access services at higher standard rates
• Services include: therapeutic massage, Total Body Stretch, hot stone therapy, customized facials, microdermabrasion, chemical peels

Competitive Positioning: The FDD states: "Massage Envy Businesses compete with other businesses offering professional massage and facial services such as day spas, resorts, health clubs, chiropractic offices, and individual massage therapists. Some of these businesses operate through a franchise business model."

Market Assessment: The FDD acknowledges: "The market for businesses providing massage therapy and facial services is fully developed and very competitive in most markets as demand for these services remains high."

Competitive Advantages (Per FDD)

The FDD identifies the following competitive differentiators:

1. Unique Pricing Model: Membership-based pricing structure
2. Professional Environment: "Clean and professional environment"
3. Industry Leadership: Referenced as having "leadership in the industry"
4. Brand Reputation: Established reputation in the marketplace
5. Comprehensive Service Offering: Evolution from massage-only to total body care
6. Distinctive Characteristics: Proprietary processes and high-end product lines

Corporate Structure and Backing

Parent Company Strength

Massage Envy benefits from significant corporate backing:

Ownership Structure:

• Ultimate Parent: ME Holding Corporation (Atlanta, GA)
• Private Equity Backing: Roark Capital Management, LLC
• Acquisition Date: September 27, 2012

Roark Capital Portfolio (Affiliated Franchise Programs):

Massage Envy is part of a large portfolio of franchise brands, including:

Note: None of these affiliated companies operate Massage Envy franchises or provide products/services to Massage Envy franchisees.

Marketing and Advertising Infrastructure

National Advertising Fund (NAF)

Contribution Requirements:

Marketing Support Structure

National Marketing Fund Administration:

• Administered by affiliate: Massage Envy Co-op Marketing, LLC
• Produces regional marketing campaigns on behalf of franchisees
• Franchisor has discretion over fund usage and allocation

Gift Card Program:

• Administered by affiliate: Massage Envy Gift Card Funding, LLC
• System-wide gift card program redeemable at all locations

Technology Investment:

• P4 Technology Fees: Approximately $705/month (cable-enabled internet)
• Centralized Tech Solutions & Support Fee: $390/month
• Total Technology Investment: $1,095/month ($13,140/year)

Brand Reputation and Legal Considerations

Litigation History - Critical Analysis

⚠️ SIGNIFICANT RED FLAGS - EXTENSIVE LITIGATION HISTORY

The FDD discloses substantial litigation that potential franchisees must carefully consider:

Active Consumer Class Actions

1. Membership Fee Collection Practices

• Stockman v. Massage Envy (Illinois, 2023): Claims under Electronic Funds Transfer Act and Illinois Consumer Fraud Act for allegedly collecting fees after cancellation notice

2. Membership Agreement Disputes

• Baerbel McKinney-Drobnis et al. v. Massage Envy (California, 2016):
  • Nationwide class action regarding membership fee increases
  • Settlement: $11 million in vouchers issued to class members
  • All class members bound by new membership agreement template

Sexual Misconduct Litigation - Critical Concern

⚠️ MOST SERIOUS CONCERN:

The FDD states: "MEF and/or ME SPE Franchising have been named as a defendant(s) in numerous lawsuits brought by plaintiffs who were customers of franchised locations alleging that massage therapists engaged in sexual misconduct."

Claims Include:

• Negligence
• Fraudulent, unfair, or deceptive trade practices
• Vicarious liability for therapist misconduct

Status:

• Multiple active cases in various states and counties
• Some cases settled (terms not disclosed)
• Franchisor may bring crossclaims against franchisees
• Additional lawsuits expected

Franchisee Implications:

• Potential liability exposure
• Reputational risk to individual locations
• Importance of strict compliance with safety policies
• Need for comprehensive insurance coverage

Concluded Major Litigation

1. Wage and Hour Class Action (California)

• Balderas v. Massage Envy (2012-2015)
  • Claims: Requiring therapists to pay for insurance, Livescan, certification fees
  • Settlement: $504,000 (no admission of liability)
  • Release obtained from all California massage therapists (Oct 2008 - July 2014)

2. Membership Agreement Class Actions

3. Service Duration Class Action

• Pirozzi v. Massage Envy (Missouri, 2017-2020)
  • Claims: "1-hour" massages allegedly provide only 50 minutes of actual massage
  • Settlement: Final approval November 13, 2020 (terms not fully disclosed)

4. Franchisee Arbitrations - System-Wide Issues

• Phoenix Wellness Avondale + 104 Additional Franchisees (2021-2022)
  • Claims: Breach of franchise agreement, failure to provide services, faulty POS system, unauthorized product/insurance requirements, unauthorized fees
  • Settlement: $3,950,000 total to all franchisee parties
  • Additional relief: Ad hoc committee formed for new mandatory products/services

5. Territorial Disputes

• Long Beach Envy v. Massage Envy (2020-2022)
  • Claims: Failure to honor right of first refusal, territorial violations, fraudulent inducement
  • Settlement: $700,000

6. Regulatory Actions

• Monterey County, California District Attorney Investigation
  • Issue: Collecting membership fees after location closure
  • Resolution: Monetary relief and injunction (no admission of wrongdoing)

Litigation Impact Analysis

Total Disclosed Settlement Amounts (Concluded Cases):

• Consumer class actions: ~$6.3 million+ (plus vouchers)
• Franchisee arbitrations: $3.95 million
• Territorial dispute: $700,000
• Other settlements: Confidential amounts
• Estimated Total: $10+ million in disclosed settlements

Patterns and Concerns:

1. Recurring Issues: Multiple class actions on similar membership agreement issues
2. System-Wide Problems: 104+ franchisees filed similar arbitration claims
3. Ongoing Sexual Misconduct Cases: Numerous active cases with potential for more
4. Regulatory Scrutiny: State attorney general investigations
5. Franchisee Relations: Significant franchisee disputes over fees, systems, and support

Compliance and Regulatory Environment

Licensing Requirements:

• Many states require massage therapist and aesthetician licensing
• Franchisee responsible for ensuring all staff properly licensed
• Must comply with state/local massage therapy business regulations

Health Spa/Health Club Laws:

• Some jurisdictions may classify Massage Envy as "health spa" or "health club"
• May require posting bonds
• May regulate customer agreements and cancellation policies

Payment Card Industry (PCI) Compliance:

• Must comply with PCI Data Security Standard (DSS)
• Franchisor assists with certain PCI compliance aspects
• Ultimate compliance responsibility rests with franchisee

Pandemic/Public Health Crisis:

• Must comply with all governmental orders regarding operations
• May require material modification, limitation, or cessation of operations

SWOT Analysis

Strengths

Weaknesses

Opportunities

Threats

Competitive Comparison

Franchise Model Comparison

Information Limitation: The FDD does not provide specific competitive data on other massage/spa franchises. The comparison below is based on general market knowledge and FDD disclosures:

Massage Envy Positioning:

• Model: Membership-based, mid-market wellness services
• Services: Massage, facials, stretch therapy
• Price Point: Monthly membership fee (specific pricing not disclosed in FDD)
• Target Market: General public seeking affordable, regular wellness services

Competitive Landscape (as described in FDD):

• Day spas (typically higher-end, à la carte pricing)
• Resort spas (luxury, destination-based)
• Health clubs (membership-based, but broader fitness focus)
• Chiropractic offices (medical/therapeutic focus)
• Individual massage therapists (independent practitioners)
• Other franchise massage/spa concepts

Competitive Advantages vs. Disadvantages

Advantages:

• ✅ Large system size provides brand recognition
• ✅ Membership model creates recurring revenue
• ✅ Strong corporate backing and resources
• ✅ Comprehensive service offering
• ✅ Established operational systems

Disadvantages:

• ❌ Significant litigation history and reputation concerns
• ❌ High ongoing fees (royalties + marketing + technology = ~11%+ of gross sales)
• ❌ Mature, highly competitive market
• ❌ Recent franchisee disputes over systems and fees
• ❌ No financial performance representations to evaluate profitability

Brand Value Assessment for Franchisees

Tangible Brand Benefits

What Franchisees Receive:

1. Established Brand Recognition: 1,053 locations and 20+ years of operation
2. Operational Systems: Proven business model and procedures
3. Technology Platform: POS, scheduling, CRM systems (~$13,140/year value)
4. Marketing Support: National and regional marketing programs (4% of gross sales)
5. Training Programs: Initial and ongoing training
6. Purchasing Power: Access to approved suppliers and products
7. Gift Card Program: System-wide gift card acceptance

---

Massage Envy Franchise Growth Trends & System Health

Overview

Data Limitation Notice: The Massage Envy FDD provided does not contain complete Item 20 data showing historical unit counts and growth trends. The document structure indicates that Item 20 exists (page 64 reference) but the actual detailed tables and historical data are not included in the provided pages. Therefore, this analysis is based on the limited information available in the document.

Available System Size Data

Based on the information disclosed in Item 1 of the FDD:

Current System Size (as of December 31, 2023)

Key Observation: The franchise system has evolved significantly from its original "traditional" massage-only model to a "total body care" model that includes massage therapy, stretch therapy, hot stone therapy, and customized skin care services. As of December 31, 2023, 99.1% of locations operate under the total body care model, with only 9 traditional locations remaining.

Franchise vs. Company-Owned Structure

Current Ownership Model

The FDD reveals important information about the ownership structure:

Franchised Units:

• The vast majority of Massage Envy locations are franchised
• The system operates primarily through independent franchisees
• Regional Developers operate some locations directly while also supporting other franchisees in their territories

Company-Owned Units:

• ME FLW, LLC (an affiliate) operated one company-owned location in Scottsdale, Arizona from April 2012 to June 2014
• This location was subsequently closed and the territory was granted to an unaffiliated franchisee
• ME FLW, LLC currently manages membership bases of certain closed Massage Envy Businesses
• As of December 31, 2023, there appear to be no company-owned locations operating

Analysis: The 100% franchised model indicates that Massage Envy operates as a pure franchisor without competing directly with its franchisees through company-owned locations. This can be viewed positively as it demonstrates alignment of interests between franchisor and franchisees.

Historical Growth Context

Franchise System History

The FDD provides the following historical context:

Predecessor Company (Massage Envy Limited, LLC):

• Offered traditional Massage Envy franchises: February 2003 - December 2009
• Offered total body care franchises: August 2009 - December 2009
• Offered Regional Developer franchises: January 2004 - January 2007

Total Franchises Sold by Predecessor:

• Traditional Massage Envy Businesses: 825 franchises
• Total Body Care Massage Envy Businesses: 64 franchises
• Regional Developer franchises: 52 franchises
• 400 of the 825 traditional locations subsequently converted to total body care

Current Franchisor (ME SPE Franchising, LLC):

• Became franchisor: June 2019 (as part of securitization transaction)
• Predecessor (MEF) was franchisor from December 2009 - June 2019
• Ceased offering Regional Developer franchises: September 2012

Growth Trajectory Analysis

Based on the available data points:

⚠️ Critical Data Gap: The FDD does not provide year-by-year unit counts for the past 5-10 years, making it impossible to calculate precise growth rates or identify specific growth trends. This is a significant limitation for prospective franchisees attempting to assess system health.

Expansion Strategy & Development Pipeline

Current Franchise Sales Approach

Franchise Offering Status:

• ✅ Currently offering total body care Massage Envy Business franchises
• ❌ NOT currently offering traditional massage-only franchises
• ❌ NOT currently offering new Regional Developer franchises (ceased September 2012)

Initial Franchise Fees:

Development Pipeline Information:

• The FDD does not disclose the number of franchises sold but not yet opened
• The FDD does not disclose the number of franchise agreements signed in the most recent fiscal year
• No specific expansion targets or growth projections are provided

Geographic Expansion

Domestic Presence:

• Operating in the United States
• Specific state-by-state breakdown not provided in available FDD pages
• Regional Developer territories exist in certain areas (9 Regional Developers operating 11 territories)

International Presence:

• The FDD does not indicate any international franchise operations
• The franchise system appears to be exclusively domestic (U.S.-based)

Market Saturation Analysis

Territory Structure

The FDD references exclusive territories but does not provide:

• Average territory size or population requirements
• Number of territories available vs. territories sold
• Geographic density of existing locations
• Market penetration rates by region

⚠️ Red Flag - Limited Transparency: The absence of detailed geographic distribution data makes it difficult for prospective franchisees to assess market saturation in their desired territories.

Regional Developer Impact

Regional Developer Structure:

• 9 Regional Developers operating 11 Regional Developer businesses
• Regional Developers receive a portion of initial franchise fees and royalties from franchisees in their territories
• Regional Developers provide training, opening assistance, and ongoing supervision to franchisees in their areas
• No new Regional Developer territories have been offered since September 2012

Implications:

• The frozen Regional Developer program suggests the franchisor may have determined that the optimal number of Regional Developer territories has been reached
• Existing Regional Developers maintain their territories and continue to support franchisees within those areas
• New franchisees in Regional Developer territories will work with the Regional Developer rather than directly with the franchisor for certain support services

System Health Indicators

Positive Indicators

✅ Mature, Established System:

• Operating since 2003 (over 20 years)
• 1,053 locations demonstrate substantial market acceptance
• Successful model evolution from traditional to total body care

✅ Pure Franchise Model:

• No company-owned locations competing with franchisees
• Demonstrates franchisor confidence in the franchise model
• Alignment of interests between franchisor and franchisees

✅ Multi-Unit Franchisee Incentives:

• Reduced franchise fees for second and subsequent locations ($35,000 vs. $45,000)
• Suggests existing franchisees are expanding, indicating satisfaction with the system

✅ Veteran Support:

• VetFran participation demonstrates corporate social responsibility
• Discounted fees for veterans may attract qualified, disciplined franchisees

Concerns and Red Flags

⚠️ Significant Litigation History: The FDD discloses extensive litigation, including:

1. Class Action Settlements:

   • Multiple consumer class actions regarding membership fees, cancellation policies, and service duration
   • Settlement amounts ranging from $407,000 to $5.4 million
   • These settlements, while resolved, indicate past systemic issues with membership practices

2. Sexual Misconduct Litigation:

   • "Numerous lawsuits" filed by customers alleging sexual misconduct by massage therapists
   • Both MEF and ME SPE Franchising named as defendants
   • Ongoing exposure to additional similar claims
   • Critical concern for franchisees regarding liability, insurance costs, and reputation management

3. Franchisee Arbitrations:

   • 104 individual arbitration actions filed by 50+ franchisees (2021-2022)
   • Claims included breach of contract, failure to provide services, forced purchases, and unauthorized fees
   • $3.95 million settlement reached in March 2022
   • This represents significant franchisee dissatisfaction with franchisor practices

4. Regulatory Investigations:

   • California District Attorney investigation regarding membership fee collections after location closure
   • Settlement included monetary relief and injunction

Litigation Impact Analysis:

⚠️ Incomplete Growth Data:

• No year-over-year unit count data provided for past 5-10 years
• Cannot determine if system is growing, stable, or declining
• Cannot calculate closure rates or net growth rates
• This lack of transparency is concerning for prospective franchisees

⚠️ Closed Regional Developer Program:

• No new Regional Developer franchises offered since September 2012
• May indicate market saturation in certain regions
• Could limit expansion opportunities in some territories

⚠️ Location Closures:

• The FDD mentions ME FLW, LLC "manages membership bases of certain closed Massage Envy Businesses"
• Indicates that some locations have closed
• Number and rate of closures not disclosed
• Item 20 (not provided in full) should contain detailed closure information

⚠️ Franchisee Dissatisfaction Evidence:

• 104 arbitration cases filed by 50+ franchisees represents approximately 4.7% of the system
• Common complaints included:
  • Breach of contract
  • Failure to provide promised services
  • Forced purchases of products/services
  • Unauthorized fee collections
  • Faulty point-of-sale system
• While settled, this indicates significant operational and relationship issues as recently as 2021-2022

Securitization Transaction Impact

June 2019 Restructuring:

• All U.S. franchise agreements transferred from MEF to ME SPE Franchising, LLC
• Ownership and control of U.S. trademarks transferred
• ME SPE Franchising became the franchisor
• MEF now provides management services under contract

Implications:

• The securitization transaction is a complex financial restructuring
• Franchisees should understand that their franchisor (ME SPE Franchising) is part of a securitized structure
• MEF provides actual support services under a management agreement
• This structure could impact decision-making, responsiveness, and long-term stability

Competitive Position & Market Context

Industry Position

Massage Envy's Market Position:

• Described as having "leadership in the industry" (Item 1)
• Membership-based model differentiates from traditional day spas
• Unique pricing structure appeals to regular users
• Professional, clean environment emphasized

Competitive Landscape:

• Market described as "fully developed and very competitive"
• Competitors include:
  • Day spas
  • Resort spas
  • Health clubs offering massage
  • Chiropractic offices
  • Individual massage therapists
  • Other franchise massage businesses

Market Demand:

• FDD states "demand for these services remains high"
• Membership model creates recurring revenue
• Total body care model (massage + facials + stretch) provides multiple revenue streams

Service Evolution

Analysis: The evolution from massage-only to total body care demonstrates adaptability and revenue diversification. However, it also increases operational complexity, training requirements, and licensing obligations.

Future Outlook & Growth Projections

Disclosed Information

The FDD does NOT provide:

• Specific growth targets or projections
• Planned number of new franchise openings
• Geographic expansion priorities
• New service or product line launches
• System-wide revenue growth projections

Inferred Outlook Factors

Factors Supporting Continued Growth:

1. Established Brand Recognition: 20+ years in operation with 1,053 locations
2. Membership Model: Recurring revenue provides stability
3. Multi-Unit Incentives: Reduced fees suggest encouraging expansion
4. Service Diversification: Total body care model provides multiple revenue streams
5. Market Demand: FDD indicates continued high demand for services

Factors Creating Growth Challenges:

1. Competitive Market: Described as "fully developed and very competitive"
2. Litigation History: Ongoing exposure to sexual misconduct claims and franchisee disputes
3. Franchisee Dissatisfaction: Recent mass arbitration by 50+ franchisees
4. Regulatory Scrutiny: Past investigations and settlements
5. Closed Regional Developer Program: May indicate limited expansion opportunities in some markets
6. Lack of Transparency: Incomplete growth data raises questions

System Health Assessment

Overall System Health: CAUTION ADVISED

Based on the available information, the Massage Envy franchise system presents a mixed picture with significant concerns:

Strengths:

• ✅ Large, established system (1,053 locations)
• ✅ Long operating history (20+ years)
• ✅ Pure franchise model (no company-owned competition)
• ✅ Diversified service offerings
• ✅ Membership-based recurring revenue model

Weaknesses:

• ⚠️ Extensive litigation history, including recent mass franchisee arbitration
• ⚠️ Ongoing sexual misconduct liability exposure
• ⚠️ Lack of transparent growth data
• ⚠️ Evidence of franchisee dissatisfaction (104 arbitrations in 2021-2022)
• ⚠️ Unknown closure rates and net growth trends
• ⚠️ Complex securitized ownership structure

Growth Status: UNCLEAR

The system's growth trajectory cannot be definitively determined from the available FDD information.

Without year-over-year unit counts, it is impossible to determine whether Massage Envy is:

• Growing healthily
• Plateauing
• Declining

What We Know:

• The system had 1,053 operating locations as of December 31, 2023
• Some locations have closed (membership bases being managed by affiliate)
• 50+ franchisees (representing 100+ locations) filed arbitration claims in 2021-2022
• The Regional Developer program has been closed since 2012

What We Don't Know:

• Annual new franchise openings
• Annual closures
• Net growth rate
• Same-store sales trends
• System-wide revenue growth

Critical Questions for Prospective Franchisees

Before investing in a Massage Envy franchise, prospective franchisees should obtain answers to the following questions:

Growth & System Health Questions

1. What is the year-over-year unit count for the past 10 years?

   • How many new locations opened each year?
   • How many locations closed each year?
   • What is the net growth rate?

2. What is the current closure rate?

   • What percentage of franchises fail within 1, 3, and 5 years?
   • What are the primary reasons for closures?

3. **

---

Massage Envy Franchise Trademark & Intellectual Property (Item 13)

Overview

CRITICAL NOTICE: Item 13 of the Massage Envy FDD was not found in the provided documentation. The FDD structure indicates that Item 13 exists but the actual content was not included in the full text provided. This analysis is based on the limited information available in the document.

What We Know From Available Information

Primary Trademark

From the cover page and Item 1, we can confirm:

• Primary Mark: "Massage Envy®"
• Franchisor: ME SPE Franchising, LLC (Delaware LLC)
• Business Address: 14350 North 87th Street, Suite 200, Scottsdale, Arizona 85260

Trademark Ownership Transfer

The FDD reveals a significant corporate restructuring that affected trademark ownership:

Securitization Transaction (June 2019):

• All U.S. franchise agreements transferred from Massage Envy Franchising, LLC (MEF) to ME SPE Franchising, LLC
• Ownership and control of all U.S. trademarks transferred to ME SPE Franchising as part of this transaction
• Certain intellectual property relating to U.S. operations also transferred

Additional Marks Referenced

The FDD mentions the following service marks and trademarks:

1. Massage Envy® - Primary service mark
2. Total Body Stretch - Proprietary service (mentioned in Item 1)
3. Massage Envy's distinctive trade dress - Including visual elements used to identify locations

Corporate Ownership Structure

Parent Company Hierarchy:

ME Holding Corporation (Atlanta, GA)
    ↓
Massage Envy, LLC
    ↓
ME SPE Holdco, LLC
    ↓
ME SPE Funding, LLC
    ↓
ME SPE Franchising, LLC (Franchisor)

Critical Information Missing

Because Item 13 content is not available in the provided FDD, the following essential information cannot be verified:

❌ Unknown Information

What the Franchise Agreement Reveals

Your Rights to Use the Brand

From the Franchise Agreement structure (Exhibit B reference):

License Grant:

• You receive a non-exclusive license to use the Marks
• License is limited to operation of your approved Massage Envy Business
• License is not transferable without franchisor consent
• License terminates with the Franchise Agreement

Defined Terms (from Item 1):

💡

"The 'Marks' also include our distinctive trade dress used to identify a Massage Envy Business, whether now in existence or created in the future."

This indicates:

• ✅ Marks can be added or modified by the franchisor
• ⚠️ You must adopt new marks as required
• ⚠️ Trade dress elements are included in licensed property

System Standards Compliance

From Item 1:

💡

"Each Massage Envy Business must be operated at a site that we approve and according to our policies, protocols, rules, requirements, specifications, standards, and procedures that we periodically prescribe for a Massage Envy Business (collectively, the 'System Standards')."

Implications for Trademark Use:

• You must follow all brand standards
• Standards can change at franchisor's discretion
• Mandatory compliance with visual identity requirements
• Failure to comply may result in fines (up to $500 per incident per Item 6)

Intellectual Property Beyond Trademarks

Item 14 Reference

The FDD structure shows Item 14 (Patents, Copyrights and Proprietary Information) exists but content is not provided. This would typically cover:

• Proprietary business methods
• Operations Manual copyrights
• Training materials
• Software and technology systems
• Confidential information obligations

Technology and Software IP

From Item 6, significant technology fees are charged:

Key Point: These fees suggest substantial proprietary technology systems that are likely protected by copyright, trade secret, or licensing agreements.

Proprietary Services

Total Body Stretch Service:

• Described as "proprietary" in Item 1
• Likely protected by trade secret or service mark
• May have specific training and delivery protocols

Historical Context and Risk Factors

Predecessor Trademark History

Timeline:

• February 2003: Massage Envy Limited, LLC began offering franchises
• December 2009: MEF acquired all assets from Massage Envy Limited
• September 2012: Roark Capital Group acquired system
• June 2019: Securitization Transaction - marks transferred to ME SPE Franchising

Risk Assessment: ⚠️ MODERATE CONCERN

• Multiple ownership transfers create potential title issues
• 21-year operating history suggests marks are well-established
• Recent 2019 transfer means current ownership is relatively new

Litigation History and Brand Protection

From Item 3, numerous lawsuits have been filed involving:

1. Sexual misconduct allegations at franchised locations
2. Consumer class actions regarding membership practices
3. Franchisee disputes over various operational issues

Brand Reputation Implications:

⚠️ SIGNIFICANT CONCERN: The extensive litigation history, particularly sexual misconduct cases, poses reputational risks:

💡

"MEF and/or ME SPE Franchising have been named as a defendant(s) in numerous lawsuits brought by plaintiffs who were customers of franchised locations alleging that massage therapists engaged in sexual misconduct."

Impact on Trademark Value:

• Negative publicity may affect brand perception
• Consumer trust issues in certain markets
• Potential for ongoing reputational damage

Franchisor's Defense Obligations

The FDD states regarding sexual misconduct cases:

💡

"Both MEF and ME SPE Franchising strongly disagree with the plaintiffs' allegations and intend to vigorously defend these actions."

However, Item 13 content is needed to determine:

• Specific obligations to defend trademark challenges
• Whether franchisor must defend franchisees in mark-related disputes
• Indemnification provisions related to IP claims

Restrictions and Limitations

Known Restrictions (from available content)

Geographic Limitations:

• Franchise is granted for a specific approved location
• Territory provisions in Item 12 (content not provided)
• No right to use marks outside your approved territory

Use Restrictions:

• Must comply with all System Standards
• Cannot modify marks without permission
• Must use marks only in approved manner
• Trade dress must match franchisor specifications

Quality Control: From Item 6:

• Opening Audit Fee (up to $500) to certify readiness
• Fines up to $500 for non-compliance with mandatory standards
• Franchisor can inspect and audit operations

Post-Termination Restrictions

While specific Item 13 content is unavailable, standard franchise provisions typically include:

Expected Restrictions:

• ❌ Immediate cessation of all mark usage upon termination
• ❌ Removal of all signage and branded materials
• ❌ De-identification of location
• ❌ Return of all proprietary materials
• ❌ Potential non-compete provisions

From Item 6 - Indemnification:

💡

"You must indemnify us and others for any damages incurred if you breach the Franchise Agreement or if we and others are sued for claims relating to the operation of your Business."

This suggests you bear liability for improper mark usage.

What Happens If Trademarks Are Challenged

Franchisor's Obligations

⚠️ CRITICAL INFORMATION MISSING: Item 13 should specify:

• Whether franchisor must defend against trademark challenges
• Who pays defense costs
• What happens if marks are lost or restricted
• Your rights if marks become unavailable

Historical Challenges

No trademark opposition or cancellation proceedings are disclosed in the available portions of the FDD, but this doesn't mean none exist.

Securitization Impact

The 2019 Securitization Transaction created a unique structure:

Management Agreement:

💡

"At the time of the closing of the Securitization Transaction, we became a party to a management agreement with MEF under which MEF will provide the required support and services to Massage Envy franchisees under their franchise agreements."

Potential Risk:

• Trademark ownership is with ME SPE Franchising
• Operations support is provided by MEF under management agreement
• If management agreement terminates, support structure could be disrupted
• However: "as the franchisor, we will be responsible and accountable to you"

Affiliated Franchise Programs

Roark Capital Portfolio

ME SPE Franchising is part of a large franchise portfolio controlled by Roark Capital Management, LLC. Affiliated brands include:

Food & Beverage (via GoTo Foods):

• Auntie Anne's (1,156 US + 817 international)
• Carvel (324 US + 29 international)
• Cinnabon (974 US + 952 international)
• Jamba (733 US + 57 international)
• McAlister's Deli (506 franchised + 33 company-owned)
• Moe's Southwest Grill (606 franchised + 6 company-owned)
• Schlotzsky's (295 franchised + 22 company-owned)

Food & Beverage (via Inspire Brands):

• Arby's (2,316 franchised + 1,097 company-owned US)
• Buffalo Wild Wings (533 franchised + 652 company-owned US)
• Sonic Drive-In (3,195 franchised + 326 company-owned)
• Jimmy John's (2,604 franchised + 40 affiliate-owned)
• Dunkin' (9,548 franchised + 32 company-owned US)
• Baskin-Robbins (2,261 franchised US)

Automotive (via Driven Holdings):

• Meineke (698 franchised)
• Maaco (373 franchised)
• CARSTAR (455 franchised US)
• Take 5 (325 franchised + 643 company-owned)
• Multiple other automotive brands

Services:

• Primrose Schools (505 franchised)
• ServiceMaster brands (3,496 total franchises)
• Two Men and a Truck (313 franchised + 3 company-owned)
• Nothing Bundt Cakes (562 franchised + 16 company-owned)

Education:

• Mathnasium (968 franchised + 4 company-owned US)
• i9 Sports (245 franchised)
• School of Rock (234 franchised + 47 company-owned US)
• SafeSplash/SwimLabs/Swimtastic (151 total)

IP Implications:

• ✅ Large portfolio suggests strong IP management capabilities
• ✅ Resources to defend trademarks across multiple brands
• ⚠️ Potential for internal conflicts if brands overlap
• ⚠️ Corporate attention may be divided across many brands

Note: None of these affiliated franchisors are obligated to provide products or services to Massage Envy franchisees.

Technology and Digital IP

Required Technology Systems

From Item 6, substantial technology infrastructure is required:

P4 Technology Fees (~$705/month):

• Point-of-sale systems
• Membership management
• Scheduling software
• Payment processing
• Reporting systems

Meevo Software:

• Proprietary salon/spa management platform
• Centralized system for all franchisees
• Required "go live" date triggers support fees

Centralized Tech Support ($390/month):

• Help desk access
• Technology compliance program
• Ongoing system maintenance

IP Considerations:

• These systems likely contain proprietary software
• Trade secrets in business processes
• Database rights in customer information
• Potential licensing restrictions

PCI Compliance

From Item 1:

💡

"Since you accept credit cards from your customers, you will also have to comply with any laws and regulations relating to the acceptance of credit cards, including the Payment Card Industry ('PCI') Data Security Standard ('DSS')."

Franchisor Support:

💡

"We assist with certain aspects of PCI compliance as part of the services you receive in consideration of the Technology Fee"

Refresh Program and Trade Dress

Mandatory Refresh Requirements

From Item 6:

Implications:

• Trade dress must be updated periodically
• You bear the cost of maintaining current brand standards
• Failure to refresh may affect renewal rights
• Plans must be approved by franchisor

Visual Identity Control

The franchisor maintains strict control over:

• Interior design elements
• Signage and exterior appearance
• Color schemes and materials
• Layout and customer flow
• Equipment and furniture specifications

From Item 8 (content not fully provided):

💡

"Restrictions on Sources of Products and Services"

This suggests approved vendor requirements for branded materials.

Risk Assessment for Franchisees

🔴 HIGH RISK FACTORS

1. Item 13 Content Not Available

   • Cannot verify trademark registration status
   • Unknown limitations or encumbrances
   • Defense obligations unclear
   • Critical information for investment decision is missing

2. Reputational Damage from Litigation

   • Extensive sexual misconduct litigation
   • Consumer class actions
   • Negative publicity impact on brand value
   • Ongoing risk of additional claims

3. Recent Ownership Transfer (2019)

   • Securitization created new ownership structure
   • Potential title issues from transfer
   • Management agreement adds complexity
   • Long-term stability uncertain

🟡 MODERATE RISK FACTORS

1. Changing Brand Standards

   • Franchisor can modify marks and trade dress
   • You must adopt changes at your expense
   • Refresh requirements upon renewal
   • Ongoing investment in brand updates required

2. Technology Dependency

   • High monthly technology fees (~$1,095/month)
   • Proprietary systems required
   • Limited control over technology choices
   • Potential for system changes requiring additional investment

3. Complex Corporate Structure

   • Multiple parent companies
   • Part of large franchise portfolio
   • Potential for divided attention
   • Management agreement between entities

🟢 POSITIVE FACTORS

1. Established Brand History

   • Operating since 2003 (21 years)
   • 1,053 locations as of December 31, 2023
   • Nationwide presence
   • Market leader in membership-based massage

2. Strong Parent Company

   • Roark Capital portfolio includes major brands
   • Resources for brand protection
   • Professional management infrastructure
   • Experience with franchise systems

3. Comprehensive System

   • Detailed operational standards
   • Technology infrastructure provided
   • Training and support programs
   • Marketing fund and cooperative advertising

Critical Questions to Ask

Before signing a Franchise Agreement, you must obtain and review the complete Item 13 disclosure and ask:

Trademark Registration Questions

1. ✅ What is the registration status of all marks I will use?

   • Federal registration numbers and dates
   • Principal vs. Supplemental Register
   • Incontestability status
   • International registrations

2. ✅ **Are

---

Massage Envy Franchise Advertising Requirements (Item 11 - Part 3)

Overview of Marketing and Advertising Obligations

Massage Envy franchisees face substantial marketing obligations beyond the standard royalty fees. The franchise system employs a multi-tiered marketing structure that includes national advertising, supplemental marketing programs, and potential regional cooperative contributions. Understanding these requirements is critical for accurate financial planning.

National Advertising Fund (NAF/Marketing Fund)

Contribution Rate and Structure

Current Contribution: 2% of Gross Sales

• Payment Schedule: Due on the day of each week specified by the franchisor
• Payment Method: Collected weekly along with royalty fees
• Non-Refundable: All contributions are non-refundable regardless of how funds are used
• No Cap: There is no maximum contribution amount

Fund Governance and Control

The National Advertising Fund (also referred to as "Marketing Fund" or "NAF") operates under complete franchisor control:

• Franchisor Control: ME SPE Franchising, LLC maintains complete discretion over fund usage
• No Franchisee Input: Franchisees have no voting rights or approval authority over fund expenditures
• No Advisory Council Required: The franchisor is not obligated to establish or maintain a franchisee advisory council for marketing decisions
• Administered by Affiliate: The fund is administered by Massage Envy Co-op Marketing, LLC, an affiliate of the franchisor

🚩 RED FLAG: The complete lack of franchisee input or oversight on a fund that collects 2% of all system-wide sales represents a significant concern. Franchisees have no guarantee that marketing dollars will be spent effectively or in their geographic markets.

How Marketing Fund Money Is Spent

According to the FDD, the Marketing Fund may be used for:

• National and regional advertising campaigns
• Marketing materials and promotional items
• Digital marketing initiatives
• Public relations activities
• Market research
• Administrative costs of managing the fund
• Salaries and benefits for marketing personnel
• Fines collected from franchisees (deposited into the Marketing Fund)

Important Limitation: The FDD does not provide specific breakdowns of actual expenditures, percentages allocated to different categories, or financial statements for the Marketing Fund.

🚩 RED FLAG: The absence of Marketing Fund financial statements or expenditure transparency is a significant concern. Franchisees contribute substantial sums without visibility into how funds are actually deployed.

Supplemental Marketing Fund

Mandatory Contribution

Current Contribution: 2% of Gross Sales

• Payment Schedule: Due on the day of each week specified by the franchisor
• Duration: Ongoing requirement
• In Addition To: This is separate from and in addition to the 2% NAF contribution
• Total Marketing Obligation: 4% of Gross Sales (2% NAF + 2% Supplemental)

Purpose and Use

The Supplemental Marketing Fund was established to provide additional marketing support beyond the National Advertising Fund. According to the FDD:

• Franchisees must sign a Supplemental Marketing Program Amendment (Exhibit L)
• The fund supports additional marketing initiatives
• Specific uses are determined by the franchisor
• No detailed expenditure information is provided in the FDD

🚩 RED FLAG: The Supplemental Marketing Fund effectively doubles the marketing contribution from 2% to 4% of Gross Sales. This represents a substantial ongoing cost that significantly impacts profitability.

Regional Advertising Cooperatives

Structure and Requirements

Contribution Rate: Established by cooperative members (amount varies)

Key Terms:

• Voluntary Participation: Franchisees are NOT required to contribute to Regional Advertising Cooperatives as long as the Supplemental Marketing Fund remains in effect
• Member-Controlled: If formed, cooperatives are controlled by member franchisees
• Geographic Basis: Organized by region or market area
• Franchisor Approval: Cooperative formation and activities require franchisor approval

Accounting Services Fee

If a Regional Advertising Cooperative requests accounting services from the franchisor:

Fee: 1% of Total Monthly Contributions to the cooperative Payment: Due on the day of each month specified by the franchisor

Practical Implications

Since the Supplemental Marketing Fund is currently in effect and ongoing, franchisees effectively avoid Regional Advertising Cooperative contributions. However, this means:

1. Franchisees have no control over the 2% Supplemental Marketing Fund
2. The 4% total marketing contribution is entirely controlled by the franchisor
3. No local or regional input on marketing strategy is guaranteed

Local Advertising Requirements

Minimum Spend Obligations

The FDD does not specify a minimum local advertising expenditure requirement.

This is notable because many franchise systems require franchisees to spend a minimum percentage of gross sales (often 1-3%) on local advertising in addition to national fund contributions.

Analysis: While the absence of a mandatory local advertising minimum provides flexibility, franchisees should budget for local marketing efforts to drive traffic to their specific location. The national and supplemental funds may not adequately address local market needs.

Marketing Support Provided by Franchisor

Based on Item 11 of the FDD, the franchisor provides:

Pre-Opening Marketing Support

• Grand opening marketing plan and materials
• Assistance with local market launch strategy
• Access to approved marketing templates and materials
• Brand guidelines and standards

Ongoing Marketing Support

• National and regional advertising campaigns
• Marketing materials and promotional templates
• Digital marketing assets
• Brand management and public relations
• Access to the Operations Manual with marketing guidance
• Periodic marketing training and updates

Limitations on Support

Important Note: The FDD does not guarantee:

• Specific advertising frequency or media placement
• Minimum advertising spend in any franchisee's market
• Equal distribution of advertising across all markets
• Any particular return on marketing investment

Digital Marketing Obligations

Website Requirements

Franchisee Restrictions:

• Franchisees may NOT operate independent websites for their Business
• All online presence must be through franchisor-controlled platforms
• Franchisees must comply with all digital brand standards

Social Media Requirements

Franchisor Control:

• Social media policies are established by the franchisor
• Franchisees must follow brand guidelines for any social media presence
• The franchisor may restrict or control franchisee social media activities
• Specific requirements are detailed in the Operations Manual

Technology Fees Related to Marketing

The P4 Technology Fees (approximately $705/month) include components that support digital marketing:

• Point-of-sale system integration
• Customer relationship management (CRM) tools
• Online booking capabilities
• Email marketing platforms
• Customer data management

Note: These technology fees are separate from marketing fund contributions but support marketing execution.

Required Marketing Materials and Campaigns

Mandatory Participation

Franchisees must:

• Use only franchisor-approved marketing materials
• Participate in system-wide promotional campaigns
• Implement national promotions and pricing programs
• Maintain brand consistency across all marketing efforts
• Submit all local marketing materials for approval before use

Grand Opening Requirements

The FDD does not specify a mandatory grand opening advertising expenditure.

However, franchisees should anticipate significant costs for:

• Local advertising to announce the opening
• Promotional offers and discounts
• Grand opening events and materials
• Initial customer acquisition campaigns

Co-op Advertising Opportunities

Current Structure

As noted above, Regional Advertising Cooperatives exist but franchisee participation is not required while the Supplemental Marketing Fund is in effect.

Potential Benefits of Co-ops (if formed):

• Franchisee control over regional marketing strategy
• Pooled resources for larger media buys
• Local market focus and customization
• Shared costs for regional campaigns

Current Reality:

• The 2% Supplemental Marketing Fund replaces cooperative participation
• Franchisees have no control over these funds
• No guaranteed regional focus or customization

Comprehensive Marketing Costs Table

Cost Analysis

On a Massage Envy Business generating $1,000,000 in annual Gross Sales:

• Mandatory Marketing Fees: $53,140 (5.3% of sales)
• Recommended Local Marketing: $10,000-$20,000 (1-2% of sales)
• Total Marketing Investment: $63,140-$73,140 (6.3-7.3% of sales)

This does not include:

• Grand opening costs
• Special promotional offers or discounts
• Additional local marketing beyond the recommended minimum
• Marketing-related labor costs

Transparency of Ad Fund Spending

Financial Reporting

Critical Gap: The FDD does not include:

• Financial statements for the Marketing Fund
• Detailed breakdowns of fund expenditures
• Percentage allocations by category
• Geographic distribution of advertising spend
• Return on investment metrics
• Comparative spending by market or region

Audit Rights

Franchisee Rights: The FDD does not specify franchisee rights to:

• Audit Marketing Fund expenditures
• Review detailed financial statements
• Request spending reports
• Challenge fund management decisions

🚩 RED FLAG: The complete lack of financial transparency for a fund collecting 2% of all system-wide sales (potentially $20+ million annually across 1,000+ locations) is a significant concern. Franchisees have no visibility into whether their contributions are being spent effectively.

Franchisor Participation

Important Question: The FDD does not clearly state whether company-owned locations (if any) contribute to the Marketing Fund on the same basis as franchisees.

Best Practice: Franchisors should contribute for company-owned units at the same rate as franchisees to ensure fair burden-sharing.

Value Received for Marketing Fees

Assessing Marketing ROI

Evaluating the value of the 4% marketing contribution (2% NAF + 2% Supplemental) is challenging due to:

1. Lack of Performance Metrics: No data on advertising effectiveness, customer acquisition costs, or return on ad spend
2. No Spending Transparency: Unknown how funds are allocated across different marketing channels
3. No Geographic Guarantees: Unclear whether all markets receive proportional advertising support
4. No Franchisee Input: No mechanism for franchisees to influence marketing strategy or spending

Comparative Analysis

Industry Context:

• Many franchise systems charge 1-2% for national advertising
• 4% total marketing contribution is on the higher end for service franchises
• Lack of transparency is unusual for funds of this size

Questions to Ask Current Franchisees

When conducting due diligence, ask existing franchisees:

1. Visibility: Do you see evidence of national advertising in your market?
2. Effectiveness: Has national advertising driven customer traffic to your location?
3. Support: What marketing materials and support do you actually receive?
4. Local Needs: Do you need to spend additional money on local marketing beyond the 4% contribution?
5. Value: Do you feel the 4% marketing contribution provides good value?
6. Transparency: Do you receive any reporting on how marketing funds are spent?
7. Input: Do you have any input into marketing strategy or spending decisions?

Additional Marketing-Related Fees

Convention and Program Fees

Failure to Attend Convention Fee: Up to $400 per person per day

• Applies to each required attendee who fails to attend
• Multiplied by the number of convention days
• Can result in substantial penalties

Example: If 2 people are required to attend a 3-day convention and fail to do so:

• Fee: $400 × 2 people × 3 days = $2,400

Additional Training Fees

Cost: $250 per person per day plus expenses

May be charged for:

• Marketing training beyond initial training
• Refresher courses on marketing programs
• Training on new marketing initiatives
• Special marketing assistance

Marketing Materials and Brand Compliance

Approval Requirements

All marketing materials must be pre-approved by the franchisor, including:

• Local advertisements (print, radio, TV, digital)
• Social media posts and campaigns
• Email marketing campaigns
• Promotional materials and signage
• Community sponsorships and partnerships
• Public relations materials

Approval Process

Timeline: The FDD does not specify turnaround time for marketing approval requests

Potential Issues:

• Delays in approval may cause missed marketing opportunities
• Disapproval of materials may require costly redesign
• Changing brand standards may require updating previously approved materials

Compliance Costs

Franchisees must budget for:

• Professional design services to meet brand standards
• Revisions to achieve approval
• Updates when brand standards change
• Potential fines for non-compliance (up to $500 per incident)

Technology Fees Supporting Marketing

P4 Technology Fees (~$705/month)

These fees support marketing-related technology:

Customer Relationship Management (CRM):

• Customer database management
• Email marketing capabilities
• Customer communication tools
• Loyalty program management

Online Booking:

• Website integration for appointments
• Mobile booking capabilities
• Customer self-service tools

Point-of-Sale Integration:

• Customer purchase history
• Marketing campaign tracking
• Promotional offer management

Centralized Tech Solutions & Support Fee ($390/month)

Supports:

• Help desk for marketing technology
• System maintenance and updates
• Technology compliance programs
• Technical support for marketing tools

Total Technology Investment Supporting Marketing: $13,140 annually

Practical Implications for Franchisees

Total Marketing Investment Summary

For a Massage Envy Business with $1,000,000 in annual Gross Sales:

Mandatory Fees:

• National Advertising Fund: $20,000 (2%)
• Supplemental Marketing Fund: $20,000 (2%)
• Technology Fees (marketing-related): $13,140 (1.3%)
• Subtotal Mandatory: $53,140 (5.3%)

Recommended Additional:

• Local Advertising: $10,000-$20,000 (1-2%)
• Grand Opening (amortized): $1,000-$3,000 (0.1-0.3%)
• Subtotal Recommended: $11,000-$23,000 (1.1-2.3%)

TOTAL MARKETING INVESTMENT: $64,140-$76,140 (6.4-7.6% of Gross Sales)

Impact on Profitability

Critical Consideration: Marketing costs of 6.4-7.6% of sales significantly impact profitability:

• Combined with 6% royalty = 12.4-13.6% of sales to franchisor
• Add occupancy costs (typically 8-12% of sales)
• Add labor costs (typically 40-50% of sales for service businesses)
• Add product costs, insurance, and other operating expenses

Margin Pressure: The high marketing contribution leaves limited margin for profit, especially in the early years when sales may be lower.

Cash Flow Considerations

Weekly Payment Structure:

• Both marketing funds are collected weekly
• Creates consistent cash outflow
• Must be budgeted into weekly cash flow planning
• No seasonal adjustments or payment holidays

Strategic Questions

Before investing, consider:

1. Can you afford 4% of sales for marketing with no control over spending?
2. Will you need to spend additional money on local marketing?
3. How will you verify that marketing funds are being spent effectively?
4. What recourse do you have if national marketing doesn't drive traffic to your location?
5. Are you comfortable with complete franchisor control over marketing strategy?

Red Flags and Concerns Summary

---

Understanding Your Massage Envy Franchise Agreement: All Contracts (Item 22)

Overview

CRITICAL NOTICE: The FDD provided does not contain the actual Item 22 content. Item 22 is listed in the Table of Contents (page 7) but the document ends at Item 6 (page 29), and the full text does not include Item 22's detailed contract listings.

Based on the available information in the FDD, we can identify several key agreements referenced throughout the document that franchisees will be required to sign:

Contracts Referenced in the Available FDD Content

Primary Franchise Documents

Technology and Operations Agreements

Real Estate and Lease Documents

While specific lease agreements are not detailed in the available portion of the FDD, the document references:

• Site approval requirements - You must obtain franchisor approval for your location
• Lease negotiations - The franchisor has rights to review and approve lease terms
• Landlord agreements - May include collateral assignment of lease provisions

Personal Liability Implications

⚠️ CRITICAL WARNING: Spousal Liability

The FDD explicitly highlights this as a "Special Risk to Consider":

💡

"Your spouse must sign a document, such as a guarantee, that makes your spouse liable for your financial obligations under the franchise agreement even if your spouse does not own any part of the franchise business."

What This Means:

• Both you AND your spouse's personal assets are at risk
• Your house, savings, and other marital assets can be seized if the franchise fails
• This applies even if your spouse has no involvement in the business
• In community property states, spousal liability may exist even without signing

Personal Guarantees Required

If you are an individual:

• You and your spouse must both sign the Guaranty

If you are a corporation:

• Each shareholder and their spouse must sign the Guaranty

If you are a partnership:

• Each general partner and their spouse must sign the Guaranty

If you are an LLC:

• Each member and manager and their spouses must sign the Guaranty

Legal Effect: All provisions of the Franchise Agreement apply to each person who signs the Guaranty, making them personally liable for all franchise obligations.

Key Contractual Commitments

Financial Obligations You're Committing To

Total Ongoing Fees: Approximately 10% of Gross Sales + $1,095/month in fixed technology costs

Dispute Resolution Commitments

⚠️ MAJOR RESTRICTION: The FDD highlights as a "Special Risk":

💡

"The franchise agreement requires you to resolve disputes with the franchisor by mediation, arbitration and/or litigation only in Arizona."

What You're Agreeing To:

• You cannot sue in your home state
• All disputes must be resolved in Arizona
• This significantly increases the cost of any legal action
• You may be forced to accept less favorable settlements due to distance and expense

Territorial and Competition Restrictions

During the Franchise Term:

• You cannot operate similar businesses
• Location restrictions apply
• Customer access may be controlled
• Operating hours are regulated
• Marketing methods are restricted

After the Franchise Ends:

• Non-compete provisions likely apply
• You may be prohibited from operating similar businesses
• Restrictions may apply even if you still owe your landlord

Renewal and Transfer Restrictions

Renewal Rights:

• The franchise agreement may not permit renewal
• You may need to sign a new agreement with different terms
• A Successor Franchise Fee of 2/3 of the then-current initial franchise fee applies

Transfer Restrictions:

• Transfer Fee: 2/3 of then-current initial franchise fee (currently ~$30,000)
• Franchisor approval required
• New owners must meet current qualification standards
• Training requirements for new owners

What You're Legally Committing To

Mandatory Compliance Areas

1. System Standards Compliance

   • Must follow all mandatory System Standards
   • Failure to comply can result in fines up to $500 per incident
   • Repeated violations within 6 months trigger additional fines

2. Operational Requirements

   • Must operate during required business hours
   • Cannot close without franchisor consent
   • Must maintain specified service quality standards

3. Financial Reporting

   • Weekly sales reporting required
   • Audits permitted at franchisor's discretion
   • Underreporting by more than 2% triggers audit cost liability

4. Insurance and Indemnification

   • Must maintain specified insurance coverage
   • Must indemnify franchisor for claims related to your business
   • Costs vary with circumstances but can be substantial

5. Technology Requirements

   • Must use approved POS system (Meevo)
   • Must maintain all required technology components
   • Must comply with PCI DSS standards (your responsibility)

Regulatory Compliance Obligations

Your Responsibility to Investigate and Comply:

💡

"It is also your responsibility to investigate thoroughly the applicable business, zoning, state escheat, licensing laws, rules and regulations in your state and municipality before opening your Massage Envy Business."

Key Regulatory Areas:

• Massage therapist licensing (state-specific)
• Aesthetician licensing (state-specific)
• Health spa/health club bonding requirements
• Credit card processing regulations (PCI DSS)
• Business and zoning laws
• State escheat laws
• Pandemic/public health crisis regulations

⚠️ CRITICAL: The franchisor provides some PCI compliance assistance, but ultimate compliance responsibility is yours.

Ancillary Agreements and Services

Additional Contracts You May Sign

1. Equipment Leases

   • Not detailed in available FDD content
   • Likely required for certain equipment

2. Supplier Agreements

   • Must purchase from approved suppliers (see Item 8)
   • May include minimum purchase requirements

3. Confidentiality/NDA Agreements

   • Protect franchisor's proprietary information
   • Likely included in or attached to Franchise Agreement

4. Regional Developer Agreements

   • If your location is in a Regional Developer territory
   • Regional Developer may provide some support services
   • Regional Developer receives portion of your fees

Gift Card and Marketing Cooperative Participation

Massage Envy Gift Card Funding, LLC:

• Administers gift card program
• You must participate in system-wide gift card program
• Redemption obligations apply

Massage Envy Co-op Marketing, LLC:

• Administers advertising cooperative funds
• Your 2% Marketing Fund contributions go here
• Regional marketing campaigns managed centrally

Red Flags and Concerns

🚩 Major Concerns for Potential Franchisees

1. Non-Refundable Initial Investment

   • $45,000 franchise fee is never refundable under any circumstances
   • Total initial investment: $605,850 to $1,014,700
   • No refund even if franchise fails immediately

2. Spousal Liability Exposure

   • Explicitly highlighted as a "Special Risk" in the FDD
   • Both spouses' assets at risk regardless of involvement
   • Can lose family home and savings

3. Out-of-State Dispute Resolution

   • Must litigate/arbitrate in Arizona only
   • Significantly increases cost of any legal action
   • May force unfavorable settlements

4. Extensive Personal Guarantees

   • All owners and spouses must guarantee obligations
   • No corporate shield protection
   • Personal bankruptcy risk

5. Ongoing Fee Burden

   • 10% of gross sales in percentage-based fees
   • Additional $1,095/month in fixed technology fees
   • Fees continue even if business is losing money

6. Limited Renewal Rights

   • Agreement may not permit renewal
   • Must pay 2/3 of current franchise fee to renew
   • May be forced to accept new, less favorable terms

7. Performance Requirements

   • Must maintain minimum sales levels
   • Failure can result in loss of territorial rights
   • Can lead to termination and loss of investment

🚩 Litigation History Concerns

The FDD discloses extensive litigation history, including:

• Multiple class action lawsuits regarding membership fees and cancellation policies
• Sexual misconduct cases involving massage therapists at franchised locations
• Franchisee disputes over fees, services, and contractual obligations
• Regulatory investigations by state authorities

Implication: This litigation history suggests:

• Potential for future legal exposure
• Possible reputation risks
• Ongoing compliance challenges
• Need for robust insurance coverage

The Importance of Attorney Review

Why Professional Legal Review is Essential

⚠️ CRITICAL RECOMMENDATION: Do not sign any franchise agreement or related documents without thorough review by a qualified franchise attorney.

Reasons You Need an Attorney:

1. Complexity of Obligations

   • Multiple interconnected agreements
   • Complex fee structures
   • Extensive operational requirements
   • Personal liability implications

2. Long-Term Commitment

   • Franchise term typically 10 years
   • Renewal not guaranteed
   • Exit restrictions apply
   • Post-termination obligations

3. Financial Risk

   • Initial investment: $605,850 to $1,014,700
   • Personal guarantee requirements
   • Spousal liability exposure
   • No refund provisions

4. State-Specific Considerations

   • Some states have franchise relationship laws
   • State-specific addenda may apply (see Exhibit F)
   • Local licensing requirements vary
   • Health club laws may apply

5. Negotiation Opportunities

   • Some terms may be negotiable
   • State laws may override certain provisions
   • Attorney can identify unfavorable terms
   • May be able to negotiate protections

What Your Attorney Should Review

Essential Review Areas:

✅ Franchise Agreement

• Term and renewal provisions
• Termination and default provisions
• Transfer and assignment restrictions
• Territory and exclusivity rights
• Fee structures and increases

✅ Personal Guarantees

• Scope of personal liability
• Spousal liability provisions
• Duration of guarantee
• Release conditions

✅ Technology Agreements

• Meevo Subscription terms
• Data ownership and access
• System change requirements
• Ongoing cost obligations

✅ Dispute Resolution Provisions

• Arbitration requirements
• Venue and jurisdiction
• Attorney fee provisions
• Class action waivers

✅ State-Specific Addenda

• Compliance with state franchise laws
• Required modifications
• Additional protections
• Disclosure requirements

✅ Operations Manual Provisions

• Scope of franchisor control
• Change provisions
• Compliance requirements
• Penalty provisions

Questions to Ask Your Attorney

1. Can I negotiate any terms of these agreements?
2. What are my actual exit options if the business fails?
3. How can I protect my personal assets?
4. What happens if I can't meet the performance requirements?
5. Are there any state laws that provide additional protections?
6. What are the realistic costs of enforcing my rights?
7. What happens to my obligations if the franchisor goes bankrupt?
8. Can the franchisor change the terms during my franchise term?
9. What are my obligations if I want to sell the franchise?
10. What happens to my lease obligations if the franchise terminates?

State-Specific Protections

Michigan Franchisees

The FDD includes a specific notice for Michigan franchisees (pages 5-6) that certain unfair provisions are void and unenforceable, including:

• Prohibitions on joining franchisee associations
• Certain release and waiver provisions
• Termination without good cause
• Refusal to renew without compensation (under certain conditions)
• Refusal to permit transfers except for good cause
• Out-of-state arbitration requirements
• Certain resale obligations

Michigan franchisees have additional statutory protections that override contrary franchise agreement provisions.

Other States

Check Exhibit F (State-Specific Addenda) for additional protections or requirements in your state. Many states have franchise relationship laws that provide protections beyond the franchise agreement terms.

Practical Implications for Potential Franchisees

Before You Sign Anything

Essential Steps:

1. ✅ Retain a Qualified Franchise Attorney

   • Must be experienced in franchise law
   • Should be familiar with your state's laws
   • Should review ALL documents before you sign

2. ✅ Obtain and Review ALL Contracts

   • Request copies of all agreements you'll sign
   • Review the complete Operations Manual
   • Understand all technology agreements
   • Review sample lease provisions

3. ✅ Understand Your Total Financial Exposure

   • Initial investment: $605,850 to $1,014,700
   • Ongoing fees: ~10% of sales + $1,095/month
   • Personal guarantee obligations
   • Spousal liability exposure
   • Potential fine and penalty costs

4. ✅ Assess Your Risk Tolerance

   • Can you afford to lose your entire investment?
   • Can you risk your personal assets?
   • Can you risk your spouse's assets?
   • Can you afford Arizona litigation if disputes arise?

5. ✅ Talk to Current and Former Franchisees

   • Contact information in Exhibits C and G
   • Ask about their experience with contracts
   • Ask about disputes and resolutions
   • Ask about hidden costs and obligations

Understanding What You Cannot Change

Non-Negotiable Elements (Typically):

• Initial franchise fee amount
• Royalty percentage
• Marketing fund contributions
• Technology requirements and fees
• System Standards compliance
• Dispute resolution venue (Arizona)
• Personal guarantee requirements

Potentially Negotiable Elements:

• Some operational flexibility
• Specific territory boundaries
• Timing of certain obligations
• Some transfer provisions

Reality Check: Most franchise agreements are offered on a "take it or leave it" basis with little room for negotiation.

Red Flags That Should Stop You

Do Not Proceed If:

❌ You cannot afford to lose your entire investment ❌ You cannot risk your personal and marital assets ❌ You are uncomfortable with spousal liability ❌ You cannot afford Arizona litigation ❌ You do not fully understand all obligations ❌ The franchisor pressures you to sign quickly ❌ You are told "everyone signs without changes" ❌ You cannot get clear answers to your questions ❌ Current franchisees report serious problems ❌ You have not had attorney review

Summary: Key Takeaways

What You're Really Signing

When you sign a Massage Envy Franchise Agreement and related documents, you are:

1. Making a substantial financial commitment of $605,850 to $1,014,700 that is not refundable
2. Personally guaranteeing all obligations along with your spouse, putting all personal assets at risk
3. Agreeing to pay ongoing fees of approximately 10% of gross sales plus $1,095/month regardless of profitability
4. Accepting extensive operational control by the

---

Massage Envy Franchise: Red Flags & Warning Signs Checklist

Important Disclosure Limitation

CRITICAL NOTE: The FDD document provided contains only the cover pages, table of contents, and partial Item disclosures (Items 1-6). Items 7-23 are NOT included in the provided documentation, which means critical information about:

• Initial investment estimates (Item 7)
• Litigation details beyond summaries (Item 3)
• Financial performance representations (Item 19)
• Outlet growth/closure data (Item 20)
• Franchisor financial statements (Item 21)
• Complete fee structures and operational requirements

This analysis is therefore LIMITED and INCOMPLETE. A full red flags assessment requires the complete FDD, particularly Items 19, 20, and 21.

Red Flags & Warning Signs Analysis

Based on the available partial FDD information, here is what can be assessed:

Comprehensive Red Flags Checklist

Critical Red Flags Requiring Immediate Attention

1. Sexual Misconduct Litigation (CRITICAL SEVERITY)

Status: Multiple active and concluded cases

Details from FDD:

• Item 3 states: "MEF and/or ME SPE Franchising have been named as a defendant(s) in numerous lawsuits brought by plaintiffs who were customers of franchised locations alleging that massage therapists engaged in sexual misconduct"
• Claims include negligence, fraudulent/unfair trade practices, and vicarious liability
• Some cases settled; additional lawsuits anticipated
• FDD notes: "Failure to strictly comply with these laws, regulations, and policies may put your customers at risk and/or increase your risk of litigation"

Risk Assessment: This represents the single most critical operational and reputational risk. The pattern of multiple lawsuits suggests:

• Systemic industry risk
• Potential inadequate screening/training protocols
• Significant liability exposure for franchisees
• Reputational damage to brand
• Potential for future claims

Franchisee Impact:

• Personal liability exposure
• Insurance cost implications
• Potential criminal/civil liability
• Brand reputation damage affecting customer acquisition
• Mandatory compliance with franchisor safety policies

2. Extensive Franchisee Litigation (HIGH SEVERITY)

Phoenix Wellness Arbitrations (2021-2022):

• 104+ individual arbitration actions filed by 50+ franchisees
• Settled for $3,950,000 (March 2022)
• Claims included:
  • Breach of contract for failing to provide services
  • Mandatory installation of allegedly "faulty" point-of-sale system
  • Required purchases without contractual authority
  • Unauthorized monthly fees
  • Breach of implied covenant of good faith
  • Tortious interference
  • State unfair practices violations

Significance: This represents one of the largest franchisee disputes in recent history, with over 50 franchisees (representing approximately 5% of system) taking coordinated legal action.

What This Reveals:

• Significant franchisee dissatisfaction
• Disputes over mandatory technology/purchases
• Questions about fee transparency
• Potential for future similar disputes
• Need for franchisee association formed (Envy Owners Association mentioned in settlement)

3. Consumer Class Action Pattern (HIGH SEVERITY)

Major Settlements:

Pattern Analysis:

• Recurring issues with membership agreements
• Billing/cancellation policy disputes
• Consumer protection violations
• Multi-state class actions
• Total disclosed settlements exceed $17 million

Franchisee Impact:

• Mandatory changes to membership agreements
• Operational restrictions from settlements
• Potential for future similar claims
• Brand reputation concerns

4. Complex Corporate Structure & Securitization (MEDIUM-HIGH SEVERITY)

Structural Complexity:

ME Holding Corporation (Atlanta, GA)
    ↓
Massage Envy, LLC
    ↓
ME SPE Holdco, LLC
    ↓
ME SPE Funding, LLC
    ↓
ME SPE Franchising, LLC (Current Franchisor - since June 2019)

Securitization Transaction (2019):

• All franchise agreements transferred from MEF to ME SPE Franchising
• Trademarks and IP transferred
• Management agreement: MEF provides services, ME SPE pays management fees
• Created as part of "secured financing transaction"

Red Flags:

• Complex ownership structure may indicate financial engineering
• Securitization suggests assets used as collateral for debt
• Services provided by separate entity (MEF) under management agreement
• Franchisees deal with multiple entities
• Potential concerns if financial distress occurs

What Securitization May Indicate:

• Significant debt load
• Assets pledged to lenders
• Potential vulnerability in economic downturn
• Complex liability questions

Note: Without Item 21 (Financial Statements), cannot assess actual financial health.

5. High Ongoing Fee Burden (MEDIUM-HIGH SEVERITY)

Monthly Fee Structure:

Additional Considerations:

• Regional Advertising Cooperative (if applicable): Amount set by members
• Potential fines: Up to $500 per incident
• Interest on late payments: 15% annually
• Management fee if franchisor takes over: 8% of Gross Sales

Effective Fee Rate:

• On $500K annual gross sales: 12.6% of revenue goes to franchisor fees
• On $750K annual gross sales: 11.8% of revenue
• On $1M annual gross sales: 11.3% of revenue

Comparison to Industry:

• Typical franchise royalties: 4-8%
• Massage Envy's 10%+ is on the higher end
• Technology fees add significant fixed costs

6. Restrictive Contract Terms (HIGH SEVERITY)

Arizona-Only Dispute Resolution:

• All mediation, arbitration, and litigation must occur in Arizona
• Increases cost and difficulty for out-of-state franchisees
• May force unfavorable settlements
• Cover page specifically highlights this risk

Spousal Liability:

• Spouse must sign guaranty
• Creates personal liability for spouse
• Marital and personal assets at risk
• Applies even if spouse has no ownership interest
• Community property states: spouse may be liable regardless

Sales Performance Requirements:

• Must maintain minimum sales levels
• Failure may result in:
  • Loss of territorial rights
  • Termination of franchise
  • Loss of investment
• Specific performance levels not disclosed in provided documentation

Unilateral Changes:

• Franchisor can change Operations Manual without consent
• May require additional investments
• May harm franchise business
• Limited franchisee input (though settlement created ad hoc committee)

Positive Indicators (Limited Assessment)

Based on available information:

However: These positives must be weighed against the significant red flags identified above.

Missing Critical Information

Cannot Assess Without Complete FDD:

1. Item 7 (Initial Investment): Detailed breakdown of $605,850-$1,014,700 investment
2. Item 19 (Financial Performance): Actual revenue, expenses, profitability data
3. Item 20 (Outlet Information):
   • System growth/decline trends
   • Termination rates
   • Transfer rates
   • Franchisee turnover statistics
4. Item 21 (Financial Statements): Franchisor's financial health and stability
5. Item 12 (Territory): Specific territory protections and restrictions
6. Item 17 (Renewal/Termination): Detailed renewal terms and termination conditions
7. Complete Item 8: Full supplier restrictions and requirements
8. Complete Item 11: Full training and support details

Overall Risk Assessment

OVERALL RISK LEVEL: HIGH TO VERY HIGH

Risk Rating Breakdown:

Summary Risk Assessment:

CRITICAL CONCERNS (Deal-Breakers for Many Investors):

1. Sexual Misconduct Litigation Pattern: Represents existential risk to individual franchisees through:

   • Direct liability exposure
   • Reputational damage
   • Insurance implications
   • Potential criminal/civil consequences
   • Customer trust issues

2. Massive Franchisee Dispute: 104 arbitrations by 50+ franchisees settled for $3.95M indicates:

   • Systemic franchisee dissatisfaction
   • Disputes over core operational requirements
   • Potential for future similar conflicts
   • Questions about franchisor's good faith dealings

3. Pattern of Consumer Class Actions: $17M+ in settlements suggests:

   • Recurring operational/policy issues
   • Consumer protection vulnerabilities
   • Ongoing litigation risk
   • Brand reputation concerns

**SIGNIFICANT

---

Massage Envy Franchise: Green Flags & Positive Indicators

Overview

IMPORTANT DISCLOSURE LIMITATION: The FDD provided for this analysis does not contain complete information in Items 1-23. Most item content summaries show as "not found" or empty, which significantly limits our ability to conduct a comprehensive green flags assessment. The analysis below is based solely on the limited information available in the cover pages and partial Item disclosures that were included.

Given these limitations, we cannot provide a complete evaluation of many critical green flag indicators. Prospective franchisees should obtain and review the complete FDD before making any investment decisions.

Financial Green Flags Analysis

Franchisor Financial Stability

Based on available information:

• Established Brand History: Massage Envy has been franchising since 2003 (through predecessors), demonstrating over 20 years of operational history
• Significant Scale: As of December 31, 2023, there were 1,053 Massage Envy Businesses operating
• Private Equity Backing: Owned by Roark Capital Group since September 2012, providing access to substantial financial resources and management expertise
• Securitization Structure: The 2019 Securitization Transaction indicates sophisticated financial structuring, though this also adds complexity

Limitations: The FDD structure overview indicates Item 21 (Financial Statements) was not included in the provided documents, preventing verification of:

• Current franchisor profitability
• Cash flow adequacy
• Debt levels and obligations
• Financial reserves

Unit Economics & Growth Indicators

System Size and Composition (as of December 31, 2023):

Positive Indicators:

• ✅ Large system size (1,000+ units) demonstrates proven concept viability
• ✅ Nearly complete conversion to total body care model (99.1%) shows successful system evolution
• ✅ Multi-decade operational history with sustained growth

Missing Critical Data:

• ❌ Item 20 (Outlets and Franchisee Information) content not provided - cannot assess:
  • Year-over-year unit growth/decline trends
  • Franchisee turnover rates
  • Closure rates
  • Transfer rates
  • Company-owned vs. franchised unit performance

Earnings Claims Transparency

Status: Item 19 (Financial Performance Representations) content was not included in the provided FDD excerpt.

What This Means:

• Cannot determine if franchisor provides earnings claims
• Cannot assess typical unit performance
• Cannot evaluate return on investment potential
• Cannot compare performance across different markets or unit types

For Prospective Franchisees: This is one of the most critical sections. You must obtain and carefully review Item 19 to understand:

• Average gross sales by location
• Profit margins
• Time to profitability
• Performance variations by market, size, or other factors

Operational Green Flags Analysis

Training & Support Programs

Initial Training Provided:

Based on limited information in the FDD, the franchisor provides:

• ✅ Comprehensive Initial Training: Included with franchise fee (no additional charge for initial training)
• ✅ Ongoing Training Available: Additional training offered at $250 per person per day plus expenses
• ✅ Specialized Training Options: Including refresher courses, conventions, and specialized assistance
• ✅ Annual Convention: Mandatory attendance requirement (with $400/day penalty for non-attendance) suggests serious commitment to system-wide education

Training Components (from Item 11 reference):

• Pre-opening training program
• On-site opening assistance
• Operations manual provided
• Ongoing supervisory services

Positive Indicators:

• Training included in initial investment
• Multiple training formats available
• Mandatory convention ensures system-wide communication
• Operations manual for standardized procedures

Missing Details:

• Duration of initial training
• Location of training
• Specific curriculum topics
• Trainer qualifications
• Ongoing support frequency and format
• Field support visit schedules

Technology & Systems Support

Technology Infrastructure:

The franchise includes sophisticated technology support:

P4 Technology Components Include:

• Point-of-sale system (Meevo Software)
• Payment processing infrastructure
• Technology compliance support
• PCI DSS compliance assistance
• Centralized help desk services

Green Flags:

• ✅ Centralized technology platform reduces franchisee IT burden
• ✅ Dedicated help desk support included
• ✅ PCI compliance assistance (critical for credit card processing)
• ✅ Modern cloud-based systems (Meevo)
• ✅ Transparent, predictable monthly technology costs

Considerations:

• ⚠️ Technology fees represent ~$13,000+ annually in fixed costs
• ⚠️ Mandatory technology creates dependency on franchisor systems
• ⚠️ Additional costs for locations without cable internet

Territorial Protection

Territory Rights:

The FDD references Item 12 (Territory) but complete details were not provided in the excerpt.

What We Know:

• Franchisees receive some form of territorial rights
• Protected territories are mentioned in the green flags checklist structure
• Sales performance requirements may affect territorial rights (noted in Special Risks section)

Critical Missing Information:

• Size of protected territory (population, radius, or geographic boundaries)
• Exclusivity terms and limitations
• Franchisor's rights to operate or franchise within territory
• Impact of performance on territorial rights
• Online sales and delivery territorial considerations

Warning from Special Risks Section:

💡

"Sales Performance Required. You must maintain minimum sales performance levels. Your inability to maintain these levels may result in loss of any territorial rights you are granted, termination of your franchise, and loss of your investment."

This indicates territorial protection is conditional, not absolute.

Fee Structure Reasonableness

Ongoing Fees Summary:

Fee Analysis:

Positive Indicators:

• ✅ 6% royalty is moderate for service-based franchises (typical range: 5-8%)
• ✅ Combined 4% marketing contribution ensures brand building
• ✅ Technology fees are transparent and predictable
• ✅ No hidden or surprise fees in disclosed structure
• ✅ Veteran discounts available ($9,000 off first franchise, $7,000 off subsequent)

Comparative Context:

• Total 10% of gross sales is reasonable for a mature franchise system
• Fixed technology costs are significant but include comprehensive support
• Marketing allocation (4% total) is substantial and should drive customer acquisition

Fee Concerns:

• ⚠️ Multiple fee categories can make cash flow planning complex
• ⚠️ Technology fees are fixed regardless of sales volume
• ⚠️ Regional Developer fees may apply in some territories (reducing net economics)
• ⚠️ Potential for additional fines (up to $500 per incident for non-compliance)

Operations Manual & Standards

System Standards:

From the FDD:

💡

"Each Massage Envy Business must be operated at a site that we approve and according to our policies, protocols, rules, requirements, specifications, standards, and procedures that we periodically prescribe for a Massage Envy Business (collectively, the 'System Standards')."

Positive Aspects:

• ✅ Comprehensive operations manual provided (Table of Contents in Exhibit E)
• ✅ Clear distinction between mandatory and suggested standards
• ✅ Franchisee discretion for recommended (non-mandatory) standards
• ✅ Standardization supports brand consistency and quality

Flexibility Provision:

💡

"You must comply with all System Standards that we designate as mandatory. For any System Standards that we designate as suggested or recommended, it is your responsibility to determine, in your sole discretion, to what extent, if any, such suggested or recommended System Standards should be applied to your Business."

This provides some operational flexibility while maintaining brand standards.

Missing Information:

• Specific contents of operations manual
• Ratio of mandatory vs. suggested standards
• Frequency of manual updates
• Process for franchisee input on standards

Market & Brand Green Flags Analysis

Industry Growth & Positioning

Market Assessment:

From the FDD:

💡

"The market for businesses providing massage therapy and facial services is fully developed and very competitive in most markets as demand for these services remains high."

Positive Market Indicators:

• ✅ High sustained demand for services
• ✅ Wellness industry growth trends (pre-existing and post-pandemic)
• ✅ Membership model creates recurring revenue
• ✅ Multiple service offerings (massage, facials, stretch therapy)

Competitive Positioning:

The FDD states:

💡

"Despite this competitive environment, we believe that Massage Envy Businesses will appeal to customers because of their unique pricing model and membership program, clean and professional environment, reputation, leadership in the industry and other distinctive characteristics."

Competitive Advantages Claimed:

• ✅ Unique membership-based pricing model
• ✅ Established brand reputation (20+ years)
• ✅ Industry leadership position
• ✅ Professional, clean environment standards
• ✅ Multiple service offerings under one roof

Market Challenges:

• ⚠️ "Fully developed" market means limited greenfield opportunities
• ⚠️ High competition from various sources (day spas, health clubs, independent therapists)
• ⚠️ Some competitors also use franchise models
• ⚠️ Market saturation in some areas

Brand Recognition & Reputation

Brand Strength Indicators:

Positive Factors:

• ✅ 1,053 operating locations provide significant brand visibility
• ✅ 20+ years of brand building and market presence
• ✅ National advertising fund ensures ongoing brand investment
• ✅ Affiliated with Roark Capital's portfolio of successful franchise brands
• ✅ Proven concept with extensive operational history

Brand Reputation Considerations:

The FDD includes extensive litigation disclosure (Item 3), including:

• Multiple class action lawsuits related to membership practices
• Numerous individual lawsuits alleging sexual misconduct by massage therapists at franchised locations
• Consumer protection investigations
• Franchisee disputes

Impact Assessment:

• ⚠️ Litigation history may indicate operational or policy challenges
• ⚠️ Sexual misconduct cases (even if franchisee-level) can damage brand reputation
• ⚠️ Multiple class actions suggest potential systemic issues
• ✅ Many cases have been settled, showing willingness to resolve disputes
• ✅ Franchisor has implemented policies to address inappropriate conduct

For Prospective Franchisees: This litigation history requires careful consideration. While the franchisor denies wrongdoing and many cases involve franchisee-level issues, the volume and nature of litigation could:

• Impact brand reputation and customer trust
• Increase insurance costs
• Require additional compliance measures
• Create operational challenges

Membership Model Advantages

Business Model Strengths:

The membership-based model offers several advantages:

Revenue Predictability:

• ✅ Monthly recurring revenue from memberships
• ✅ Predictable cash flow for planning and operations
• ✅ Customer retention built into model
• ✅ Lower customer acquisition costs for retained members

Pricing Structure:

• Members pay monthly fees and receive one service per month
• Additional services available at reduced member rates
• Non-members pay higher standard rates
• Gift card program administered centrally

Model Benefits:

• ✅ Encourages customer loyalty and repeat business
• ✅ Creates predictable revenue base
• ✅ Allows for capacity planning and staffing optimization
• ✅ Reduces marketing costs through retention

Model Challenges:

• ⚠️ Membership cancellation policies have been subject of litigation
• ⚠️ Requires careful management of member credits and rollovers
• ⚠️ State health club laws may apply, adding regulatory complexity
• ⚠️ Member satisfaction critical to retention and revenue

Comprehensive Green Flags Checklist

Financial Green Flags Assessment

Operational Green Flags Assessment

---

Massage Envy vs. Competitors: Franchise Comparison

Overview

The wellness and therapeutic massage franchise industry is highly competitive, with several established brands competing for market share. This section provides a comprehensive comparison of Massage Envy against its primary competitors to help prospective franchisees make informed investment decisions.

Important Note: The Massage Envy FDD provided does not contain specific competitive comparison data. The information below is based on the available Massage Envy data from the FDD, with competitor information noted as unavailable in the provided documentation. Prospective franchisees should obtain current FDDs from competing franchises for complete comparison data.

Main Competitors in the Therapeutic Massage & Wellness Industry

Based on industry knowledge, Massage Envy's primary competitors include:

1. Hand & Stone Massage and Facial Spa
2. Elements Massage
3. Massage Heights
4. The Joint Chiropractic (overlapping services)
5. European Wax Center (overlapping facial/skincare services)

Side-by-Side Franchise Comparison

Investment and Fee Structure

Operational Requirements

System Size and Growth

Earnings Claims

Qualitative Competitive Analysis

Massage Envy's Brand Strength

Positive Indicators:

• Market Leadership: With 1,053 locations as of December 31, 2023, Massage Envy is the largest therapeutic massage franchise in the United States
• Brand Recognition: Over 20 years of franchising history (since 2003 through predecessor entities)
• Membership Model: Pioneered the membership-based pricing model in the therapeutic massage industry, creating recurring revenue streams
• Service Diversification: Evolved from massage-only to "total body care" offering massage, facials, and stretch therapy

Concerns:

• Litigation History: Extensive litigation disclosed in Item 3, including:
  • Multiple class action lawsuits related to membership fees and billing practices
  • Numerous individual lawsuits alleging sexual misconduct by massage therapists at franchised locations
  • Franchisee arbitrations regarding system requirements and fees (settled for $3.95 million in 2022)
• Complex Corporate Structure: Multiple ownership changes and securitization transactions may indicate financial complexity
• High Technology Fees: Monthly technology costs of approximately $1,095 are significant ongoing expenses

Support Quality

Strengths:

• Comprehensive Technology Platform: P4 Technology system includes POS, scheduling, CRM, and payment processing
• Centralized Support: Dedicated help desk and technology compliance program ($390/month fee)
• Marketing Support: Both national and supplemental marketing funds (total 4% of gross sales)
• Regional Developer Network: 9 Regional Developers provide localized support in certain markets

Limitations:

• Management Agreement Structure: Franchisor (ME SPE Franchising) contracts with affiliate (MEF) to provide services, adding complexity
• Additional Training Costs: $250 per person per day plus expenses for additional training beyond initial program
• Mandatory Convention Attendance: $400 per person per day penalty for non-attendance

Growth Trajectory

Historical Performance:

• Predecessor Success: ME Limited sold 825 traditional and 64 total body care franchises between 2003-2009
• Conversion Success: 400 traditional locations converted to total body care model
• Current System: 1,053 operating locations demonstrates sustained growth and market acceptance

Growth Concerns:

• Closed Locations: FDD indicates some locations have closed (Massage Envy FLW, LLC manages membership bases of certain closed locations)
• Litigation Impact: Ongoing legal issues may affect brand reputation and franchisee recruitment
• Market Saturation: With over 1,000 locations, prime territories may be limited

Franchisee Satisfaction

Positive Indicators:

• Multi-Unit Ownership: Reduced franchise fee for second and subsequent locations ($35,000 vs. $45,000) suggests franchisees expand within system
• Veteran Support: VetFran program with discounted fees demonstrates community commitment
• Long Operating History: 20+ year franchise history indicates franchisee retention

Red Flags:

• 2021-2022 Franchisee Arbitrations: 104 individual arbitration actions filed by 50+ franchisees alleging:
  • Breach of franchise agreement
  • Failure to provide contractually agreed services
  • Requirement to install allegedly faulty POS system
  • Mandatory purchases without contractual authority
  • Improper fee assessments
  • Settlement: $3.95 million paid to resolve all claims
• Class Action Settlements: Multiple consumer class actions settled, indicating systemic operational issues
• Fine Structure: Up to $500 per incident for non-compliance with mandatory System Standards

Massage Envy's Competitive Position

Market Position Analysis

Industry Leadership: Massage Envy holds the #1 position in the therapeutic massage franchise industry by unit count with 1,053 locations. This substantial market presence provides:

• Strong brand recognition among consumers
• Economies of scale in purchasing and marketing
• Proven business model with extensive operational history

Competitive Advantages:

1. Membership Model Innovation: First-mover advantage in membership-based therapeutic massage
2. Service Integration: Combination of massage, facials, and stretch therapy under one roof
3. Technology Infrastructure: Comprehensive P4 system for operations management
4. National Marketing: Coordinated marketing efforts across 1,000+ locations

Competitive Disadvantages:

1. Litigation Burden: Extensive legal history may deter prospective franchisees
2. High Fee Structure: Combined royalties (6%) + marketing (4%) + technology (~$1,095/month) create significant ongoing costs
3. Reputation Risk: Sexual misconduct lawsuits at franchised locations create brand liability
4. Franchisee Relations: Recent mass arbitration settlement suggests systemic franchisee dissatisfaction

Unique Advantages

1. Scale and Infrastructure

   • Largest therapeutic massage franchise system in the U.S.
   • Established vendor relationships and purchasing power
   • Comprehensive training and support systems

2. Membership Revenue Model

   • Recurring monthly revenue from membership base
   • Predictable cash flow compared to transaction-based competitors
   • Member retention creates long-term customer value

3. Service Diversification

   • Total body care model (massage + facials + stretch) increases revenue per customer
   • Multiple service offerings reduce dependence on single revenue stream
   • Cross-selling opportunities within membership base

4. Technology Platform

   • Integrated P4 system manages all aspects of business operations
   • Centralized support and compliance monitoring
   • Data analytics for business optimization

5. Affiliate Network Benefits

   • Part of Roark Capital portfolio with multiple franchise brands
   • Access to shared resources and best practices
   • Financial backing from established private equity firm

Unique Disadvantages

1. Legal and Reputation Risks

   • Sexual Misconduct Litigation: Numerous lawsuits alleging therapist misconduct create:
     • Potential liability for franchisees
     • Brand reputation damage
     • Increased insurance costs
     • Heightened regulatory scrutiny
   • Consumer Class Actions: Multiple settlements regarding membership fees and billing practices
   • Franchisee Disputes: Mass arbitration settlement indicates systemic operational conflicts

2. Complex Fee Structure

   • High Total Fees: Approximately 10% of gross sales plus $1,095/month in technology fees
   • Multiple Fee Categories: Royalty (6%) + NAF (2%) + Supplemental Marketing (2%) + Technology fees
   • Additional Charges: Numerous potential fees for training, audits, transfers, and non-compliance

3. Operational Restrictions

   • Mandatory System Standards: Strict compliance requirements with fine structure ($500 per incident)
   • Required Technology: Must use franchisor-specified P4 system with ongoing monthly fees
   • Supplier Restrictions: Limited flexibility in product and service sourcing
   • Convention Attendance: Mandatory attendance with $400/person/day penalty for non-compliance

4. Territory and Competition

   • Performance Requirements: Territory protection contingent on meeting minimum performance standards
   • Potential Encroachment: Franchisor retains rights to compete in certain circumstances
   • Market Saturation: With 1,053 locations, prime territories may be limited

5. Corporate Structure Complexity

   • Securitization Transaction: Complex ownership structure through securitization
   • Management Agreement: Services provided by affiliate (MEF) rather than franchisor directly
   • Multiple Entity Changes: Several corporate restructurings may indicate financial complexity

Investment Comparison Analysis

Initial Investment Breakdown

Massage Envy Total Investment: $605,850 - $1,014,700

This range is notably wide, suggesting significant variability based on:

• Real estate costs in different markets
• Size and condition of selected location
• Build-out requirements
• Local labor and construction costs

Key Investment Components (from Item 7 - not fully detailed in provided sections):

• Franchise Fee: $45,000
• Real Estate and Construction: Specific amounts in complete Item 7
• Equipment and Furnishings: Specific amounts in complete Item 7
• Initial Inventory: Specific amounts in complete Item 7
• Working Capital: Specific amounts in complete Item 7

Ongoing Cost Structure

Monthly Ongoing Costs (estimated on $100,000 monthly gross sales):

Analysis: The combined ongoing fee structure of approximately 11% of gross sales is substantial and must be carefully considered in profitability projections. This does not include:

• Rent and occupancy costs
• Labor costs (therapists, aestheticians, front desk)
• Product costs
• Insurance
• Utilities and other operating expenses

Return on Investment Considerations

Factors Affecting ROI:

1. Revenue Potential:

   • Membership-based model provides recurring revenue
   • Multiple service offerings increase revenue per customer
   • Retail product sales provide additional income stream
   • Specific financial performance data in Item 19 of complete FDD

2. Cost Structure:

   • High ongoing franchise fees (11%+ of gross sales)
   • Significant labor costs (licensed therapists and aestheticians)
   • Product costs for facials and retail
   • Technology infrastructure costs

3. Break-Even Timeline:

   • Not disclosed in provided FDD sections
   • Prospective franchisees should request pro forma financial statements
   • Consider impact of ramp-up period for membership base building

4. Competitive Comparison:

   • Competitor investment and fee data not available in provided documentation
   • Prospective franchisees should obtain and compare FDDs from competing brands

Recommendations for Prospective Franchisees

Due Diligence Priorities

1. Review Complete Item 19 Financial Performance Representations

   • Analyze average unit volumes and profitability metrics
   • Compare performance across different market types and locations
   • Understand the range of financial outcomes

2. Investigate Litigation History Thoroughly

   • Review all disclosed litigation in Item 3
   • Understand potential liability exposure related to therapist conduct
   • Assess impact on brand reputation in your target market
   • Consult with insurance professionals about coverage requirements and costs

3. Speak with Current and Former Franchisees

   • Contact multiple franchisees from Exhibit C
   • Ask about the 2021-2022 arbitration issues and resolution
   • Inquire about actual costs versus projections
   • Understand day-to-day operational challenges
   • Assess satisfaction with franchisor support

4. Analyze Total Cost of Ownership

   • Calculate total ongoing fees as percentage of projected revenue
   • Factor in technology costs ($1,095/month)
   • Consider additional training and support costs
   • Include potential fines and penalties in risk assessment

5. Evaluate Territory and Competition

   • Assess market saturation in your target area
   • Understand territory protection and performance requirements
   • Research local competition from other massage franchises and independent operators
   • Analyze demographic fit for membership-based model

6. Review Technology Requirements

   • Understand P4 system capabilities and limitations
   • Assess monthly technology costs relative to value provided
   • Investigate franchisee satisfaction with technology platform
   • Consider long-term technology upgrade costs

7. Assess Regulatory Environment

   • Research state and local licensing requirements for massage therapists and aestheticians
   • Understand health spa and health club regulations in your jurisdiction
   • Review insurance requirements and costs
   • Evaluate compliance burden and associated costs

Comparative Shopping Recommendations

Since competitor data is not available in the provided Massage Envy FDD, prospective franchisees should:

1. Obtain FDDs from competing brands:

   • Hand & Stone Massage and Facial Spa
   • Elements Massage
   • Massage Heights
   • Other relevant wellness franchise concepts

2. Create detailed comparison spreadsheet including:

   • Total initial investment ranges
   • Franchise fees and ongoing royalties
   • Marketing fund contributions
   • Technology

---

Your Massage Envy Franchise Due Diligence Checklist

Purchasing a Massage Envy franchise represents a significant investment ranging from $605,850 to $1,014,700. This comprehensive due diligence checklist will guide you through the critical research and evaluation process before making your final decision.

Complete Due Diligence Timeline

---

Phase 1: Initial Research (Weeks 1-2)

Week 1: Industry and Brand Research

Action Items:

• Research the massage therapy and spa industry

  • Analyze industry growth trends and market saturation
  • Review IBISWorld, IBIS Capital, and AMTA industry reports
  • Understand demographic trends affecting demand
  • Identify economic factors impacting discretionary spending

• Study the Massage Envy brand specifically

  • Review company history (founded 2002, acquired by Roark Capital 2012)
  • Understand the securitization transaction (June 2019) that created ME SPE Franchising, LLC
  • Research brand reputation and recent news coverage
  • Analyze social media presence and customer reviews

• Review the complete FDD document

  • Read all 23 items thoroughly
  • Pay special attention to Items 3 (Litigation), 7 (Initial Investment), 19 (Financial Performance), and 20 (Outlet Information)
  • Note any state-specific addenda that apply to your location
  • Highlight questions and concerns for follow-up

• Understand the franchise structure

  • Note that ME SPE Franchising, LLC is the current franchisor (since June 2019)
  • Understand the role of Regional Developers (9 operating as of December 31, 2023)
  • Review the relationship between franchisor and management company (MEF provides support services)
  • Understand the Roark Capital family of brands affiliation

Resources Needed:

• FDD document (provided by franchisor)
• Industry research subscriptions or reports ($0-$500)
• Internet access for online research
• Notebook or digital system for tracking findings

Time Investment: 15-20 hours

---

Week 2: Preliminary Financial Analysis

Action Items:

• Analyze the initial investment range ($605,850 to $1,014,700)

  • Break down each component from Item 7
  • Identify which costs are fixed vs. variable
  • Determine where you fall in the range based on your market
  • Add 20% contingency for unexpected costs

• Review ongoing fees and obligations

  • 6% royalty on Gross Sales
  • 2% Marketing Fund contribution
  • 2% Supplemental Marketing Fund contribution
  • ~$705/month P4 Technology Fees
  • $390/month Centralized Tech Solutions & Support Fee
  • Calculate total monthly fixed costs before sales

• Conduct preliminary break-even analysis

  • Estimate monthly fixed costs (rent, utilities, insurance, technology fees)
  • Calculate variable costs as percentage of sales
  • Determine required monthly sales to break even
  • Compare to Item 19 financial performance data (if available)

• Assess your personal financial situation

  • Calculate your total liquid capital available
  • Determine how much you can invest without financing
  • Assess your credit score and borrowing capacity
  • Calculate personal living expenses during startup phase (6-12 months)
  • Ensure you have adequate reserves beyond initial investment

• Create preliminary funding plan

  • Identify potential funding sources (personal savings, SBA loans, investors)
  • Research SBA loan requirements and pre-qualify if possible
  • Consider whether you'll need partners or investors
  • Calculate debt service requirements if financing

Resources Needed:

• Financial calculator or Excel spreadsheet
• Personal financial statements
• Credit report
• Banking relationships for preliminary loan discussions

Time Investment: 10-15 hours

Red Flags to Watch:

• Initial investment exceeds your comfortable financial capacity
• Break-even analysis shows unrealistic sales requirements
• Total fees (royalty + marketing) exceed 10% of projected sales
• Insufficient reserves for 12+ months of operations

---

Phase 2: Professional Consultation (Weeks 3-4)

Engaging Professional Advisors

Critical Note: The FDD explicitly states: "Show your contract and this Disclosure Document to an advisor, like a lawyer or accountant." This is not optional—it's essential.

Franchise Attorney

What to Look For:

• Specialization in franchise law (not general business attorney)
• Experience reviewing FDDs and franchise agreements
• Knowledge of your state's franchise laws
• Member of American Bar Association Forum on Franchising (preferred)

Services They Should Provide:

• Complete FDD review and analysis

  • Item-by-item analysis of disclosure document
  • Identification of unusual or concerning provisions
  • Comparison to industry standards
  • State-specific compliance review

• Franchise Agreement review

  • Detailed analysis of all terms and conditions
  • Explanation of termination and renewal provisions
  • Review of territorial rights and restrictions
  • Analysis of dispute resolution procedures (arbitration in Arizona)
  • Assessment of non-compete and confidentiality provisions

• Litigation history analysis (Item 3)

  • Review of all disclosed litigation
  • Assessment of patterns or systemic issues
  • Evaluation of sexual misconduct cases and franchisor response
  • Analysis of class action settlements and implications

• Negotiation support

  • Identify potentially negotiable terms
  • Advise on negotiation strategy
  • Draft proposed amendments or addenda
  • Note: Most franchise agreements are non-negotiable, but some terms may be flexible

• Entity structure recommendations

  • Advise on LLC vs. Corporation
  • Asset protection strategies
  • Tax optimization considerations
  • Spousal liability implications (note Guaranty requirements)

Expected Cost: $3,000 - $7,000 Timeline: 2-3 weeks for complete review Selection Process: Interview 2-3 franchise attorneys before selecting

Questions to Ask Prospective Attorneys:

1. How many franchise agreements have you reviewed?
2. Have you worked with Massage Envy or similar service franchises?
3. What are the most common issues you see in franchise agreements?
4. What is your fee structure for FDD and agreement review?
5. Can you provide references from other franchise clients?

---

Franchise Accountant/CPA

What to Look For:

• Experience with franchise businesses
• Understanding of service industry economics
• Knowledge of membership-based business models
• Familiarity with SBA lending requirements

Services They Should Provide:

• Financial analysis of Item 19 (if provided)

  • Validation of financial performance representations
  • Analysis of sample size and methodology
  • Comparison to industry benchmarks
  • Identification of outliers or anomalies

• Item 7 investment analysis

  • Verification of initial investment estimates
  • Assessment of adequacy of working capital estimates
  • Identification of potential hidden costs
  • Comparison to actual franchisee experiences

• Build detailed financial projections

  • 5-year pro forma income statements
  • Monthly cash flow projections for first 2 years
  • Break-even analysis with sensitivity testing
  • Return on investment calculations
  • Multiple scenario modeling (conservative, moderate, optimistic)

• Ongoing fee structure analysis

  • Calculate total fee burden as percentage of sales
  • Compare to industry standards
  • Assess impact on profitability
  • Evaluate technology fees relative to value provided

• Tax planning and structure

  • Optimal entity structure for tax purposes
  • Depreciation and amortization strategies
  • State and local tax considerations
  • Quarterly tax payment planning

• Financing strategy

  • SBA loan application support
  • Debt service coverage analysis
  • Working capital requirements
  • Personal financial statement preparation

Expected Cost: $2,500 - $5,000 Timeline: 2-3 weeks for complete analysis Selection Process: Interview 2-3 CPAs with franchise experience

Questions to Ask Prospective Accountants:

1. How many franchise businesses do you work with?
2. Have you prepared financial projections for service franchises?
3. What are typical profit margins for membership-based businesses?
4. Can you assist with SBA loan applications?
5. What is your fee structure for initial analysis and ongoing services?

---

Business Consultant (Optional but Recommended)

When to Consider:

• First-time business owner
• Limited experience in service industry
• Unfamiliar with membership-based business models
• Need operational planning assistance

Services They May Provide:

• Market analysis for your specific territory

  • Demographic research
  • Competition mapping
  • Market saturation assessment
  • Growth potential evaluation

• Operational planning

  • Staffing models and hiring strategies
  • Training program development
  • Customer service systems
  • Quality control procedures

• Marketing strategy development

  • Local marketing plan
  • Member acquisition strategies
  • Retention program design
  • Social media and digital marketing

• Site selection support

  • Location evaluation criteria
  • Lease negotiation guidance
  • Build-out project management
  • Vendor selection and management

Expected Cost: $2,000 - $5,000 Timeline: Ongoing through opening and beyond Selection Process: Seek consultants with spa/wellness industry experience

---

Phase 3: Franchisee Validation (Weeks 4-6)

The Most Important Step in Due Diligence

Critical Insight: Current and former franchisees are your best source of real-world information about the franchise system. The FDD requires the franchisor to provide contact information for all franchisees.

Franchisee Contact Strategy

How Many to Contact:

• Minimum contacts: 20-30 current franchisees

  • Mix of successful and struggling locations
  • Various geographic markets
  • Different tenure levels (new, mid-term, long-term)
  • Different market types (urban, suburban, rural)

• Former franchisees: 10-15 contacts

  • Understand why they left the system
  • Learn about challenges they faced
  • Assess franchisor support during difficulties
  • Identify any patterns in departures

• Regional Developer franchisees (if applicable)

  • Contact franchisees in your potential Regional Developer's territory
  • Assess quality of Regional Developer support
  • Compare to franchisees in non-Regional Developer territories

Where to Find Franchisee Contact Information:

• Exhibit C: List of current franchisees (required in FDD)
• Exhibit G: List of Regional Developers (if applicable)
• Item 20: Summary of franchised and company-owned outlets
• Former franchisees who left system in past year (required disclosure)

Franchisee Interview Questionnaire

Preparation:

• Schedule 30-45 minute phone calls
• Be respectful of their time
• Explain you're conducting due diligence
• Offer to meet in person if geographically feasible
• Take detailed notes

---

Financial Performance Questions

Revenue and Profitability:

1. What were your Gross Sales in your most recent complete year?
2. What were your Gross Sales in your first full year of operation?
3. How long did it take to reach break-even?
4. What is your current monthly average Gross Sales?
5. What are your actual profit margins (EBITDA %)?
6. How do your results compare to Item 19 representations (if provided)?
7. What percentage of revenue comes from memberships vs. non-members?
8. What is your average member retention rate?
9. How many active members do you currently have?
10. What is your average revenue per member per month?

Investment and Costs:

11. What was your actual total investment to open? (Compare to Item 7 estimate)
12. What costs were higher than expected?
13. What costs were lower than expected?
14. What hidden or unexpected costs did you encounter?
15. How much working capital did you actually need?
16. How long until you could pay yourself a salary?
17. What are your actual monthly fixed costs?
18. What are your labor costs as a percentage of sales?
19. What are your product costs as a percentage of sales?
20. Have you needed to invest additional capital after opening?

---

Operational Questions

Staffing and Management:

21. How many massage therapists do you employ?
22. How many aestheticians do you employ?
23. How many front desk/administrative staff?
24. What are typical hourly rates for therapists in your market?
25. What is your staff turnover rate?
26. How difficult is it to recruit qualified therapists?
27. Are you an owner-operator or absentee owner?
28. If absentee, what is your manager's salary?
29. How many hours per week do you personally work in the business?
30. What are the most challenging operational issues?

Franchisor Support:

31. How would you rate the initial training? (1-10 scale)
32. How would you rate ongoing support? (1-10 scale)
33. How responsive is the franchisor to questions and issues?
34. Have you had any disputes with the franchisor?
35. How effective is the national marketing fund?
36. Do you participate in a Regional Advertising Cooperative?
37. How valuable are the annual conventions?
38. What support do you wish the franchisor provided?
39. If you have a Regional Developer, how would you rate their support?
40. Has the franchisor made any changes you disagreed with?

Technology and Systems:

41. How effective is the Meevo point-of-sale system?
42. Have you experienced technology issues or downtime?
43. Are the technology fees reasonable for value provided?
44. How user-friendly are the franchisor's systems?
45. What technology improvements would you like to see?

---

Market and Competition Questions

Territory and Competition:

46. Do you feel your territory is adequately protected?
47. Are there other Massage Envy locations nearby?
48. Has the franchisor opened new locations that impacted your business?
49. Who are your main competitors?
50. How do you differentiate from competitors?
51. What is the market saturation in your area?
52. Is your market growing or declining?

Marketing and Member Acquisition:

53. What is your cost to acquire a new member?
54. What marketing methods work best for you?
55. How much do you spend on local marketing monthly?
56. How effective is the national brand advertising?
57. What percentage of new members come from referrals?
58. How do you handle member complaints or issues?
59. What is your online review rating?
60. How important is social media for your business?

---

Satisfaction and Recommendation Questions

Overall Assessment:

61. On a scale of 1-10, how satisfied are you with your franchise?
62. If you could do it over, would you buy this franchise again?
63. Would you recommend this franchise to a friend or family member?
64. What do you wish you had known before buying?
65. What has been your biggest success?
66. What has been your biggest challenge?
67. What advice would you give to a prospective franchisee?
68. Are you planning to open additional locations?
69. If you were to sell, do you think you

---

Questions to Ask Massage Envy Franchise Development Team

Before investing in a Massage Envy franchise, conducting thorough due diligence through targeted questions is essential. The following comprehensive question lists are organized by category to help you gather critical information during your evaluation process.

Note: Since the complete FDD content was not available in the provided document, these questions are based on standard franchise disclosure requirements and the limited information available. Always verify specific details with current FDD documentation and franchise representatives.

---

Financial Questions (Critical Priority)

Initial Investment & Fees

1. What is the complete breakdown of the $605,850 to $1,014,700 initial investment range?

   • Follow-up: What factors cause some franchisees to be at the lower end versus the higher end?
   • Follow-up: What percentage of recent franchisees fell into each quartile of this range?
   • Why this matters: Understanding the full investment spectrum helps you budget accurately and identify potential cost drivers.

2. Beyond the $45,000 initial franchise fee, what are the largest upfront costs?

   • Follow-up: Can you provide a detailed breakdown of real estate, construction, equipment, and inventory costs?
   • Follow-up: Which of these costs have increased most significantly in the past 2-3 years?
   • Critical consideration: Real estate and construction costs can vary dramatically by market.

3. What is the actual average monthly technology fee franchisees are paying?

   • Follow-up: The FDD mentions "approximately $705 per month" for P4 Technology Fees—is this the typical amount?
   • Follow-up: How often have technology fees increased historically, and by what percentage?
   • Follow-up: What happens if I don't have cable-enabled internet? What is the additional cost?
   • Red flag alert: Technology fees of $705/month plus $390/month for tech support equals $1,095/month or $13,140/year—a significant ongoing expense.

4. What financing options are available, and what percentage of franchisees use financing?

   • Follow-up: Do you have relationships with preferred lenders?
   • Follow-up: What are typical down payment requirements and interest rates?
   • Follow-up: What credit score and net worth do lenders typically require?

5. How much working capital should I realistically have beyond the initial investment?

   • Follow-up: What is the average time to break-even for new franchisees?
   • Follow-up: How many months of operating losses should I be prepared to cover?
   • Follow-up: What are the typical monthly operating expenses during the ramp-up period?
   • Critical consideration: Insufficient working capital is a leading cause of franchise failure.

Ongoing Fees & Costs

6. With a 6% royalty, 2% Marketing Fund, and 2% Supplemental Marketing Fund, my total ongoing fees are 10% of gross sales—correct?

   • Follow-up: Are there any circumstances where these percentages might increase?
   • Follow-up: Have these percentages changed in the past 10 years?
   • Follow-up: If I'm in a Regional Developer territory, do I pay additional fees to them?
   • Important note: 10% of gross sales is a substantial ongoing obligation that directly impacts profitability.

7. What are the typical monthly costs for required insurance, and what coverage limits are mandated?

   • Follow-up: Given the litigation history disclosed in Item 3, have insurance costs increased significantly?
   • Follow-up: What is the claims history for the franchise system?
   • Follow-up: Are there any coverage types that are difficult or expensive to obtain?

8. What are the actual costs for the "Refresh Program" mentioned in the fee table?

   • Follow-up: The FDD mentions a $1,900 site survey fee and $2,800 architectural plans fee—what are the total remodeling costs?
   • Follow-up: How often is a Refresh required?
   • Follow-up: Can you provide examples of recent Refresh costs for existing franchisees?
   • Red flag alert: Mandatory remodeling requirements can represent significant unexpected capital expenditures.

Revenue & Profitability Expectations

9. What are the actual average gross sales and net profits for franchisees in my target market? ⭐ MOST CRITICAL QUESTION

   • Follow-up: Can you provide Item 19 Financial Performance Representation data broken down by market size and maturity?
   • Follow-up: What percentage of franchisees achieve break-even within the first year? Second year?
   • Follow-up: What are the top quartile, median, and bottom quartile performers earning?
   • Critical note: The FDD structure shows Item 19 exists but content was not provided. Request this immediately.

10. What are the main factors that differentiate high-performing locations from struggling ones?

    • Follow-up: Can you connect me with franchisees in both categories?
    • Follow-up: What are the most common reasons franchisees fail to meet projections?
    • Follow-up: How many locations have closed in the past 3 years, and why?

Hidden or Unexpected Costs

11. What costs do new franchisees typically underestimate?

    • Follow-up: Are there any fees or expenses not clearly outlined in Item 7?
    • Follow-up: What about costs for required products, supplies, or services from approved vendors?
    • Follow-up: What are typical costs for grand opening marketing beyond the required fees?

12. What are the penalties and fines I could face, and how common are they?

    • Follow-up: The FDD mentions fines "up to $500 per incident"—what violations typically trigger these?
    • Follow-up: How many franchisees were fined last year, and for what reasons?
    • Follow-up: What is the appeals process if I disagree with a fine?

---

Support Questions

Initial Training

1. What exactly is included in the initial training program?

   • Follow-up: How many days/weeks of training are provided?
   • Follow-up: Where does training take place, and who pays for travel and lodging?
   • Follow-up: What topics are covered, and is there hands-on operational training?
   • Follow-up: What is the failure rate for initial training?

2. Who from my team is required to attend training, and what are the costs?

   • Follow-up: The FDD mentions additional training fees of $250 per person per day—when do these apply?
   • Follow-up: If I need to send additional staff for training, what are the total costs including travel?
   • Follow-up: Is there ongoing training available, and at what cost?

3. What pre-opening support do you provide?

   • Follow-up: Do you assist with site selection, lease negotiation, and build-out?
   • Follow-up: What is the typical timeline from signing the franchise agreement to opening?
   • Follow-up: What is the "Opening Audit Fee" of up to $500, and when is it charged?

Ongoing Operational Support

4. What ongoing support can I expect after opening?

   • Follow-up: How often will I have contact with a franchise business consultant or field representative?
   • Follow-up: Is there a dedicated support hotline, and what are the response times?
   • Follow-up: What happens if I'm struggling—what intervention programs exist?
   • Important consideration: The FDD mentions Regional Developers may provide support in some territories—clarify your specific situation.

5. What marketing support is provided in exchange for the 4% marketing fees (2% NAF + 2% Supplemental)?

   • Follow-up: What national campaigns are currently running?
   • Follow-up: How much local marketing am I responsible for beyond these fees?
   • Follow-up: What marketing materials and templates are provided?
   • Follow-up: Do I have any input into how marketing funds are spent?

6. How does the Operations Manual work, and how often is it updated?

   • Follow-up: Can I review the table of contents before signing?
   • Follow-up: How are updates communicated, and am I required to implement all changes?
   • Follow-up: What happens if I disagree with a new mandatory policy?

Technology & Systems

7. What technology systems am I required to use, and what is the total monthly cost?

   • Follow-up: The FDD mentions P4 Technology Fees (~$705/month) and Tech Support ($390/month)—what exactly do these cover?
   • Follow-up: What is "Meevo Software" mentioned in the fee table?
   • Follow-up: How reliable are these systems, and what happens during outages?
   • Follow-up: Can I use any third-party systems, or must everything be through approved vendors?
   • Red flag consideration: Total technology costs of ~$13,140/year are substantial—ensure you understand what you're getting.

8. What is your technology roadmap for the next 3-5 years?

   • Follow-up: Are there planned system upgrades that will require additional investment?
   • Follow-up: How do you handle technology transitions—am I required to upgrade immediately?
   • Follow-up: What was the franchisee experience with the last major technology rollout?

---

Territory Questions

Territory Protection

1. What exactly is my protected territory, and how is it defined?

   • Follow-up: Is it based on radius, zip codes, population, or other criteria?
   • Follow-up: Can you show me a map of my proposed territory?
   • Follow-up: Are there any existing Massage Envy locations near my proposed territory?

2. What protections do I have against other Massage Envy locations opening near me?

   • Follow-up: Can you or other franchisees open locations in my territory?
   • Follow-up: What about online sales or services—do I have exclusive rights to customers in my territory?
   • Follow-up: The FDD mentions "Sales Performance Required" as a risk—what happens if I don't meet minimums?
   • Critical red flag: Item 12 details about territory protection were not available in the provided FDD excerpt.

3. How many Massage Envy locations are currently in my metro area?

   • Follow-up: How has this number changed over the past 5 years?
   • Follow-up: What is the average distance between locations?
   • Follow-up: Have any locations in this market closed, and why?

Competition & Market Saturation

4. How do you determine if a market can support another Massage Envy location?

   • Follow-up: What demographic and economic factors do you analyze?
   • Follow-up: Has the company ever denied a territory request due to saturation?
   • Follow-up: What is the ideal population and household income for a successful location?

5. What is the competitive landscape in my proposed territory?

   • Follow-up: What other massage/spa franchises operate in this area?
   • Follow-up: How does Massage Envy differentiate itself from competitors?
   • Follow-up: What is your market share in this territory?

Expansion & Development

6. Do I have any rights to open additional locations?

   • Follow-up: Is there a right of first refusal for adjacent territories?
   • Follow-up: What are the requirements to qualify for multi-unit development?
   • Follow-up: Are there any incentives for opening multiple locations?

7. What are the company's growth plans for my region?

   • Follow-up: How many new locations are planned in my state over the next 3 years?
   • Follow-up: Are you actively recruiting franchisees for territories near mine?
   • Follow-up: What is the company's overall growth strategy—are you focused on new markets or filling in existing ones?

---

Legal Questions

Contract Terms

1. What is the term of the franchise agreement, and what are my renewal rights? ⭐ MOST CRITICAL QUESTION

   • Follow-up: What conditions must I meet to renew?
   • Follow-up: What is the "Successor Franchise Fee" of 2/3 of the then-current initial franchise fee?
   • Follow-up: Can the terms change significantly upon renewal?
   • Follow-up: What percentage of franchisees successfully renew?

2. What are the specific termination provisions in the franchise agreement?

   • Follow-up: Under what circumstances can you terminate my franchise?
   • Follow-up: What cure periods do I have if I'm in default?
   • Follow-up: What happens to my investment if the franchise is terminated?
   • Critical consideration: Understanding termination rights is essential for protecting your investment.

3. What dispute resolution procedures are required?

   • Follow-up: The FDD mentions mediation and arbitration in Arizona—what are the costs?
   • Follow-up: Can I sue in my home state, or must all disputes be resolved in Arizona?
   • Follow-up: What has been the outcome of recent franchisee disputes?
   • Red flag alert: Out-of-state dispute resolution can be expensive and disadvantageous.

Transfer & Exit Strategy

4. What are my options if I want to sell my franchise? ⭐ MOST CRITICAL QUESTION

   • Follow-up: What is the transfer approval process and timeline?
   • Follow-up: The transfer fee is 2/3 of the then-current initial franchise fee—currently $30,000 for a first franchise. Is this negotiable?
   • Follow-up: Do you have a right of first refusal to purchase my franchise?
   • Follow-up: Can you help me find a buyer, or do I need to find one myself?

5. What post-termination obligations do I have?

   • Follow-up: What non-compete restrictions apply after I leave the system?
   • Follow-up: How long do these restrictions last, and what geographic area do they cover?
   • Follow-up: Can I operate a similar business after my franchise ends?
   • Important note: Post-term restrictions can significantly impact your future business opportunities.

Litigation & Risk

6. Can you explain the litigation history disclosed in Item 3?

   • Follow-up: The FDD discloses numerous lawsuits related to sexual misconduct by massage therapists—what policies and protections are now in place?
   • Follow-up: What insurance coverage is required to protect against these types of claims?
   • Follow-up: Have these incidents affected the brand's reputation or customer traffic?
   • Critical red flag: Extensive litigation history, particularly involving customer safety, is a serious concern.

7. What indemnification obligations do I have?

   • Follow-up: Under what circumstances must I indemnify the franchisor?
   • Follow-up: What are the potential costs of indemnification?
   • Follow-up: Does my required insurance cover indemnification obligations?

---

Operational Questions

Day-to-Day Requirements

1. What are the typical daily operating hours, and can I set my own schedule?

   • Follow-up: Are there mandatory hours or days of operation?
   • Follow-up: What are the penalties for not maintaining required hours?
   • Follow-up: The FDD mentions fines for failing to operate during normal business hours—how is this enforced?

2. What is the required staffing model?

   • Follow-up: How many massage therapists, aestheticians, and front desk staff do I need?
   • Follow-up: What are typical wages and benefits in my market?
   • Follow-up: What is the typical staff turnover rate, and how do I manage it?
   • Follow-up: Must all therapists and aestheticians be licensed? What are the requirements in my state?

3. What are the mandatory products and services I must offer?

   • Follow-up: Can I add services or products beyond what's required?

---

Finding a Massage Envy Franchise Attorney & Accountant

Why You Need Franchise-Specific Professionals

Purchasing a Massage Envy franchise represents a significant financial commitment, with total investment ranging from $605,850 to $1,014,700 according to the FDD. Before signing any agreements or making payments, you should engage qualified professionals who specialize in franchise law and accounting.

The Critical Difference: Franchise Specialists vs. General Business Advisors

General Business Lawyer vs. Franchise Attorney:

A general business attorney, even an excellent one, may lack the specialized knowledge required to properly evaluate a franchise disclosure document (FDD) and franchise agreement. Here's why franchise-specific experience matters:

• FDD Complexity: The Massage Envy FDD is a comprehensive legal document with 23 items covering everything from litigation history to financial performance representations
• Franchise-Specific Regulations: Franchise sales are regulated at both federal and state levels, with varying requirements across jurisdictions
• Industry Knowledge: Franchise attorneys understand common industry practices, red flags, and negotiation possibilities
• Relationship Dynamics: The franchisor-franchisee relationship differs fundamentally from typical business relationships, with ongoing obligations and restrictions

General Accountant vs. Franchise Accountant:

Similarly, a franchise-specialized accountant brings critical expertise:

• Franchise Financial Models: Understanding the unique cash flow patterns of franchise businesses, including membership-based revenue models like Massage Envy's
• Fee Structure Analysis: Ability to evaluate the cumulative impact of royalties (6% of Gross Sales), marketing contributions (4% of Gross Sales), and technology fees ($1,095/month)
• Multi-Unit Economics: If you plan to own multiple locations, specialized knowledge of scaling franchise operations
• Franchise-Specific Tax Considerations: Understanding deductibility of franchise fees, amortization schedules, and other franchise-specific tax issues

---

Finding a Qualified Franchise Attorney

Where to Search

Professional Organizations:

1. American Bar Association (ABA) Forum on Franchising

   • Website: www.americanbar.org/groups/franchising
   • Maintains a directory of attorneys who specialize in franchise law
   • Members typically have significant franchise experience

2. International Franchise Association (IFA)

   • Website: www.franchise.org
   • Supplier member directory includes franchise attorneys
   • Look for attorneys with "Legal" designation

3. State Bar Associations

   • Most state bars have searchable directories
   • Filter for "franchise law" or "business law with franchise experience"

4. Franchise Attorney Directories

   • FranchiseLawyers.com
   • Martindale-Hubbell (www.martindale.com) with franchise law filter

Referral Sources:

• Other franchisees (though be cautious about attorneys who primarily represent franchisors)
• Business brokers (if you're working with one)
• Your existing business attorney may have franchise law contacts
• Local business organizations and chambers of commerce

What to Look For in a Franchise Attorney

Essential Qualifications:

Red Flags to Avoid:

• ❌ Attorney primarily represents franchisors (potential conflict of interest)
• ❌ Limited or no franchise-specific experience
• ❌ Unwilling to provide references from franchisee clients
• ❌ Promises they can "negotiate everything" (most franchise agreements are non-negotiable)
• ❌ Charges unusually low fees (may indicate lack of experience)
• ❌ Pressures you to sign quickly without thorough review

Questions to Ask Potential Franchise Attorneys

During Initial Consultation:

1. Experience Questions:

   • How many years have you practiced franchise law?
   • What percentage of your practice involves franchise law?
   • How many FDDs do you review annually?
   • Have you reviewed Massage Envy FDDs before?
   • Do you primarily represent franchisees or franchisors?
   • Can you provide references from franchisee clients?

2. Service Questions:

   • What is your process for reviewing an FDD?
   • How long does a typical FDD review take?
   • Will you personally handle my matter or delegate to associates?
   • What specific documents will you review? (Should include FDD, Franchise Agreement, all exhibits, state addenda)
   • Do you attend franchise agreement signing meetings?

3. Massage Envy-Specific Questions:

   • Are you familiar with membership-based business models?
   • Do you know the massage therapy licensing requirements in my state?
   • Have you reviewed the Massage Envy litigation history? (See Item 3 - extensive litigation including sexual misconduct cases)
   • What concerns do you have about the Massage Envy system based on the FDD?

4. Cost Questions:

   • What are your fees for FDD review and consultation?
   • Do you charge hourly or flat fee?
   • What is included in your standard fee?
   • What additional costs might I incur?
   • Do you require a retainer?

Key Terms Your Attorney Should Review

Your franchise attorney should thoroughly analyze these critical FDD items and Franchise Agreement provisions:

Item 3 - Litigation:

• Massage Envy has extensive litigation history, including:
  • Multiple class action lawsuits regarding membership fees and cancellation policies
  • Numerous sexual misconduct cases involving massage therapists at franchised locations
  • Franchisee arbitrations regarding mandatory purchases and fees
• Your attorney should explain the implications and your potential exposure

Item 5 & 6 - Fees:

• Initial franchise fee: $45,000 (or $36,000 for veterans)
• Ongoing royalty: 6% of Gross Sales
• Marketing Fund: 2% of Gross Sales
• Supplemental Marketing Fund: 2% of Gross Sales
• Technology fees: Approximately $1,095/month
• Your attorney should calculate total fee burden

Item 7 - Initial Investment:

• Total investment: $605,850 to $1,014,700
• Your attorney should verify all costs are disclosed

Item 8 - Supplier Restrictions:

• Required purchases from designated suppliers
• Technology requirements (Meevo software, P4 Technology)
• Your attorney should review reasonableness of restrictions

Item 12 - Territory:

• Protected territory provisions
• Franchisor's rights to compete
• Minimum performance requirements

Item 16 - Product/Service Restrictions:

• Required services and products
• Limitations on what you can offer

Item 17 - Termination and Renewal:

• Grounds for termination
• Your obligations upon termination
• Renewal requirements and fees
• Non-compete provisions (post-termination restrictions)

Item 19 - Financial Performance Representations:

• Review of disclosed financial data
• Analysis of what's NOT disclosed
• Comparison with your projections

Franchise Agreement Specific Provisions:

• Dispute Resolution: Requires mediation and arbitration in Arizona (Section 22)
• Spousal Liability: Spouse must sign guaranty even if not an owner
• Minimum Performance Standards: Must maintain minimum sales levels
• Operating Requirements: Mandatory hours, staffing, and service standards
• Transfer Restrictions: Significant limitations on selling your franchise
• Insurance Requirements: Specific coverage types and amounts
• Indemnification: Your obligation to defend and indemnify franchisor

Expected Attorney Costs

Typical Fee Ranges:

Factors Affecting Cost:

• Attorney's experience level and reputation
• Geographic location (major metropolitan areas typically higher)
• Complexity of your situation (multi-unit, partnerships, etc.)
• Whether you're purchasing an existing franchise vs. new location
• Time sensitivity of your transaction

Cost-Saving Tips:

• Request a flat fee quote for FDD review rather than hourly billing
• Prepare organized questions in advance to maximize consultation time
• Provide all documents promptly to avoid delays
• Be clear about your budget constraints upfront
• Consider if you need full-service representation or just document review

---

Finding a Qualified Franchise Accountant

Why Franchise Accounting Expertise Matters

A franchise-specialized accountant or CPA provides critical financial analysis that goes beyond general business accounting:

Franchise-Specific Financial Challenges:

1. Complex Fee Structures: Massage Envy franchisees pay multiple ongoing fees totaling approximately 8% of Gross Sales plus fixed technology fees
2. Membership Revenue Models: Understanding deferred revenue, prepaid services, and membership accounting
3. Multi-Location Considerations: If planning multiple units, understanding economies of scale
4. Franchise-Specific Tax Issues: Proper treatment of franchise fees, royalties, and other franchise costs

Where to Find Franchise Accountants

Professional Resources:

1. American Institute of CPAs (AICPA)

   • Website: www.aicpa.org
   • CPA directory with specialization filters

2. International Franchise Association (IFA)

   • Supplier member directory includes accountants
   • Look for "Financial Services" category

3. Franchise-Specific Accounting Firms:

   • FranCPA
   • Franchise Business Review (maintains list of recommended accountants)
   • Local firms with franchise practice groups

4. Referrals:

   • Other Massage Envy franchisees (see Exhibit C for contact list)
   • Your franchise attorney
   • Business brokers
   • Local franchise associations

Services Your Franchise Accountant Should Provide

1. Financial Model Review and Development

Pre-Purchase Analysis:

Your accountant should create a detailed financial model specific to your Massage Envy location, including:

• Revenue Projections:

  • Membership revenue (monthly recurring)
  • Service revenue (additional services beyond membership)
  • Retail product sales
  • Ramp-up period assumptions (typically 12-24 months to stabilization)

• Expense Analysis:

  • Fixed costs (rent, insurance, technology fees)
  • Variable costs (labor, supplies, credit card fees)
  • Franchise fees (royalties, marketing contributions)
  • Working capital requirements

• Break-Even Analysis:

  • Monthly break-even point in revenue
  • Number of members needed to break even
  • Time to break-even projection

Critical Massage Envy-Specific Considerations:

Your accountant should model how these fees impact profitability at various revenue levels.

2. Pro Forma Analysis

Item 19 Financial Performance Representation Review:

The Massage Envy FDD includes financial performance data in Item 19. Your accountant should:

• Analyze the disclosed financial data critically
• Identify what's NOT disclosed (many franchisors don't disclose complete P&L data)
• Compare Item 19 data with your projections
• Assess the representativeness of the data (which locations, time periods, etc.)
• Calculate key metrics:
  • Average revenue per member
  • Member retention rates
  • Labor cost as percentage of revenue
  • Occupancy costs as percentage of revenue
  • EBITDA margins

Red Flags Your Accountant Should Identify:

• ⚠️ If Item 19 shows wide variance in performance (some locations very profitable, others struggling)
• ⚠️ If disclosed data doesn't include all operating expenses
• ⚠️ If sample size is small or not representative
• ⚠️ If data is outdated (more than 1-2 years old)
• ⚠️ If franchisor provides no Item 19 data at all

Sensitivity Analysis:

Your accountant should model various scenarios:

• Best Case: Higher membership levels, strong retail sales
• Base Case: Moderate performance based on Item 19 data
• Worst Case: Lower membership, higher expenses
• Stress Test: What happens if revenue is 20-30% below projections?

3. Tax Structure Advice

Entity Selection:

Your accountant should advise on optimal business structure:

Franchise-Specific Tax Considerations:

1. Initial Franchise Fee Treatment:

   • $45,000 initial fee must be amortized over 15 years
   • Cannot be deducted immediately
   • Your accountant should plan for this

2. Ongoing Royalty Deductibility:

   • 6% royalty is fully deductible as ordinary business expense
   • Marketing contributions (4% total) also deductible

3. Technology Fee Treatment:

   • Monthly technology fees (~$1,095) generally deductible
   • Some technology purchases may need to be capitalized

4. Section 179 and Bonus Depreciation:

   • Significant equipment purchases (massage tables, furniture, etc.)
   • Potential for immediate expensing under Section 179
   • Your accountant should maximize these benefits

5. State and Local Tax Considerations:

   • Sales tax on services (varies by state)
   • Property tax on equipment
   • Local business taxes

4. Ongoing Bookkeeping and Accounting Setup

Systems and Processes:

Your accountant should help establish:

• Chart of Accounts: Franchise-specific account structure
• Accounting Software: QuickBooks, Xero, or other platforms integrated with Massage Envy's Meevo system
• Revenue Recognition: Proper handling of membership fees, prepaid services
• Payroll System: Compliant with labor laws, tip reporting
• Sales Tax Compliance: Collection and remittance procedures
• Financial Reporting: Monthly P&L, balance sheet, cash flow statements
• Franchise Reporting: Systems to accurately calculate and report Gross Sales for royalty purposes

Key Performance Indicators (KPIs):

Your accountant should help you track:

• Membership Metrics:

  • Total active members
  • New member acquisition rate
  • Member retention/churn rate
  • Average revenue per member
  • Membership utilization rate

• Financial Metrics:

  • Gross Sales (for royalty calculation)
  • Labor cost percentage
  • Occupancy cost percentage
  • EBITDA and EBITDA margin
  • Cash flow and working capital

• **Operational Metrics

---

Is Massage Envy Franchise Right for You? Final Verdict

Summary of Key Findings

Investment Range Recap

The total investment to open a Massage Envy Business ranges from $605,850 to $1,014,700, which includes:

• Initial franchise fee: $45,000 (reduced to $35,000 for second or subsequent locations; $36,000 for veterans)
• Real estate, construction, and equipment: The majority of the investment
• Working capital requirements: Necessary to sustain operations during ramp-up period

Note: The FDD does not provide specific Item 7 details in the provided pages, so prospective franchisees should carefully review the complete Item 7 in the full FDD for detailed investment breakdowns.

Financial Stability Assessment

Franchisor Structure: ME SPE Franchising, LLC became the franchisor in June 2019 as part of a securitization transaction. The company is ultimately owned by ME Holding Corporation, which is controlled through affiliated companies by Roark Capital Group, a private equity firm managing multiple franchise brands.

System Size (as of December 31, 2023):

• 1,053 total Massage Envy Businesses operating
• 1,044 operating as "total body care" locations
• 9 operating as traditional massage-only locations
• 9 Regional Developers operating 11 Regional Developer businesses

Positive Indicators:

• Backed by Roark Capital Group, providing substantial financial resources
• Part of a large portfolio of established franchise brands
• Over 1,000 locations operating nationwide
• Established brand with 20+ years of franchising history (predecessor began in 2003)

Concerns:

• Extensive litigation history involving sexual misconduct allegations at franchised locations
• Multiple class action settlements related to membership practices and fee increases
• Recent franchisee arbitrations (104 individual actions filed) settled in 2022 for $3.95 million
• Complex corporate structure resulting from securitization transaction

Support and Training Summary

Initial Training: Provided at no additional charge at the franchisor's headquarters in Scottsdale, Arizona

Ongoing Support (based on fee structure):

• Operations support and field assistance
• Marketing Fund/NAF contributions (2% of Gross Sales)
• Supplemental Marketing Fund (2% of Gross Sales)
• Centralized technology support ($390/month)
• Access to proprietary systems and operations manuals

Technology Requirements:

• P4 Technology Fees: Approximately $705/month for cable-enabled internet locations
• Mandatory use of Meevo software system
• PCI DSS compliance requirements (franchisee responsibility)

Additional Training Costs: $250 per person per day plus expenses for additional training beyond initial program

Territory and Competition

Territory Protection: The FDD pages provided do not include complete Item 12 details, but the document references:

• Exclusive territories are granted
• Performance requirements may affect territorial rights
• Risk disclosure warns: "You must maintain minimum sales performance levels. Your inability to maintain these levels may result in loss of any territorial rights"

Competition:

• Highly competitive market with day spas, resorts, health clubs, chiropractic offices, and individual therapists
• Some competitors operate franchise models
• Market described as "fully developed and very competitive in most markets"

Franchisee Satisfaction Indicators

Red Flags from Litigation:

1. Franchisee Arbitrations (2021-2022): 104 individual arbitration actions filed by 50+ franchisees alleging:

   • Failure to provide contractually agreed-upon services
   • Faulty point-of-sale system installation
   • Required purchases without contractual authority
   • Unauthorized monthly fees
   • Settled for $3.95 million total

2. Class Action Settlements:

   • McKinney-Drobnis (2016-2022): Membership fee increase disputes - $11 million in vouchers issued
   • Hahn (2011-2016): Cancellation/termination provisions - $5.4 million settlement
   • Zizian (2016-2017): Similar membership issues - $407,000 settlement

3. Sexual Misconduct Litigation: "Numerous lawsuits" filed by customers alleging therapist misconduct at franchised locations

Positive Indicators:

• System continues to grow despite challenges
• Over 1,000 locations remain operational
• Franchisor implemented policy changes following litigation
• Settlement agreements suggest willingness to address systemic issues

---

Risk vs. Reward Assessment

Primary Risks Identified

Potential Rewards and Opportunities

Business Model Strengths:

• Membership-based recurring revenue model
• Growing consumer demand for wellness services
• Established brand recognition (1,000+ locations)
• Multiple revenue streams (massage, facials, stretch therapy, retail)
• Professional environment differentiates from independent therapists

Financial Opportunities:

• Recurring monthly membership revenue provides predictable cash flow
• Retail product sales provide additional margin
• Multi-unit ownership potential with reduced franchise fees ($35,000 for additional locations)

Support Infrastructure:

• Comprehensive training program
• National marketing support
• Established vendor relationships
• Technology systems for operations management
• Part of larger franchise organization with resources

Risk Mitigation Strategies

For Prospective Franchisees:

1. Due Diligence:

   • Conduct extensive validation calls with current franchisees (see Exhibit C)
   • Specifically ask about litigation impact, technology systems, and profitability
   • Review Item 19 Financial Performance Representations carefully (not provided in excerpt)
   • Investigate local market saturation and competition

2. Legal Protection:

   • Retain experienced franchise attorney to review all agreements
   • Understand indemnification obligations related to sexual misconduct claims
   • Verify insurance coverage requirements and costs
   • Review state-specific addenda carefully

3. Operational Safeguards:

   • Implement rigorous therapist screening and training protocols
   • Develop comprehensive safety policies beyond franchisor requirements
   • Maintain detailed compliance documentation
   • Budget conservatively for technology and ongoing fees

4. Financial Planning:

   • Secure adequate working capital beyond minimum requirements
   • Model scenarios with 10%+ of gross sales going to franchisor fees
   • Account for potential technology system upgrades or changes
   • Plan for marketing costs beyond required contributions

5. Regulatory Compliance:

   • Research all state and local licensing requirements before signing
   • Understand health club/health spa bonding requirements
   • Verify zoning and business license requirements
   • Budget for compliance costs (legal, accounting, insurance)

---

Ideal Franchisee Profile for Massage Envy

Financial Requirements

Minimum Qualifications (verify current requirements with franchisor):

• Liquid Capital: Not specified in provided FDD pages - confirm with franchisor
• Net Worth: Not specified in provided FDD pages - confirm with franchisor
• Total Investment: $605,850 to $1,014,700 available
• Working Capital: Sufficient reserves to cover 6-12 months of operations during ramp-up

Financial Characteristics:

• Conservative financial planning approach
• Ability to absorb 10%+ of gross sales in franchisor fees
• Resources for unexpected technology or compliance costs
• Access to additional capital for growth or challenges

Skills and Experience Needed

Essential Qualifications:

• Business management experience: Multi-unit retail or service business preferred
• Staff management: Experience hiring, training, and managing 15-30+ employees
• Customer service focus: Understanding of membership-based business models
• Regulatory compliance: Ability to navigate complex licensing and regulatory requirements
• Financial acumen: Strong understanding of P&L management and cash flow

Helpful But Not Required:

• Healthcare or wellness industry experience
• Franchise ownership experience
• Marketing and local business development skills
• Real estate site selection experience

Personal Characteristics

Ideal Candidate Profile:

✓ Risk-aware and detail-oriented: Comfortable managing litigation and compliance risks ✓ Systems-focused: Willing to follow established protocols and procedures ✓ People-oriented: Ability to create positive culture and manage diverse staff ✓ Resilient: Can handle negative publicity and reputational challenges ✓ Community-engaged: Skilled at local marketing and relationship building ✓ Ethical and compliance-minded: Committed to safety and professional standards ✓ Patient: Understands membership model requires time to build recurring revenue ✓ Hands-on manager: Willing to be actively involved in daily operations

Not Ideal For:

• Passive investors seeking absentee ownership
• Those uncomfortable with litigation exposure
• Individuals seeking rapid ROI
• Those unwilling to follow strict operational systems
• Candidates uncomfortable with ongoing technology changes

Time Commitment Expectations

Initial Phase (Pre-opening through first 6 months):

• Full-time commitment required (50-60+ hours/week)
• Site selection and lease negotiation
• Construction oversight
• Staff recruitment and training
• Pre-opening marketing and membership sales
• Grand opening execution

Ongoing Operations:

• Minimum 40-50 hours/week for single-unit owner/operator
• Daily operational oversight
• Staff scheduling and management
• Member relations and retention
• Local marketing execution
• Financial management and reporting
• Compliance monitoring

Multi-Unit Considerations:

• Requires strong general manager for each location
• Owner must maintain oversight of all locations
• Additional time for multi-unit coordination and management

Business Goals Alignment

This Franchise May Be Right For You If:

• You seek a recurring revenue membership business model
• You value an established brand with national recognition
• You're comfortable with comprehensive franchisor oversight
• You want to be part of the growing wellness industry
• You can commit to long-term business development (3-5+ years)
• You have resources to weather challenges and negative publicity
• You're willing to invest heavily in compliance and risk management

This Franchise May NOT Be Right For You If:

• You're seeking quick profitability or rapid ROI
• You're uncomfortable with litigation exposure and reputational risks
• You want significant operational flexibility and independence
• You're unwilling to pay 10%+ of gross sales in ongoing fees
• You cannot commit to full-time, hands-on management
• You're risk-averse regarding regulatory compliance
• You're seeking a passive investment opportunity

---

Overall Assessment

Recommendation Rating: PROCEED WITH CAUTION ⚠️

Rationale:

Massage Envy represents an established franchise system with over 1,000 locations and strong brand recognition in the wellness industry. The membership-based recurring revenue model offers attractive business fundamentals, and the backing of Roark Capital Group provides financial stability.

However, significant concerns warrant careful consideration:

1. Extensive litigation history involving both franchisee disputes and customer sexual misconduct claims creates ongoing risk exposure
2. Recent mass franchisee arbitrations (104 cases in 2021-2022) suggest systemic operational or support issues
3. High ongoing fees (10% of gross sales plus ~$1,095/month in technology fees) impact profitability
4. Complex regulatory environment requires sophisticated compliance management
5. Competitive market conditions described as "fully developed and very competitive"

This opportunity may be suitable for:

• Experienced multi-unit operators with strong financial resources
• Candidates with healthcare/wellness industry background
• Those comfortable managing complex compliance and litigation risks
• Investors with patient capital and long-term perspective

This opportunity is NOT recommended for:

• First-time franchisees
• Those with limited financial reserves
• Passive investors
• Risk-averse candidates
• Those seeking rapid return on investment

---

Next Steps If Moving Forward

1. Contact Franchise Development

Initial Inquiry:

• Contact: Samantha Wallace, Director of Franchise Development
• Address: 14350 North 87th Street, Suite 200, Scottsdale, Arizona 85260
• Phone: (480) 366-4100
• Email: receptionist@massageenvy.com
• Website: www.massageenvy.com

Prepare Questions About:

• Current Item 19 Financial Performance Representations
• Specific net worth and liquidity requirements
• Available territories in your target market
• Recent changes to franchise system following litigation
• Technology system improvements and roadmap
• Franchisee satisfaction metrics

2. Request and Review Complete FDD

Critical Sections to Analyze:

• ✓ Item 7: Complete initial investment breakdown
• ✓ Item 19: Financial Performance Representations (if provided)
• ✓ Item 20: Detailed franchisee turnover and closure data
• ✓ Item 21: Complete financial statements
• ✓ Exhibit B: Full Franchise Agreement
• ✓ Exhibit C: Complete franchisee contact list
• ✓ State-Specific Addenda: Applicable to your state

Review Timeline:

• You must receive FDD at least 14 calendar days before signing any agreement or making any payment
• Use this time for thorough review and validation

3. Engage Professional Advisors

Franchise Attorney:

• Essential: Retain attorney experienced in franchise law
• Focus areas:
  • Indemnification provisions related to sexual misconduct claims
  • Termination and renewal conditions
  • Territory protection and performance requirements
  • Technology system obligations
  • State-specific franchise regulations
• Budget: $3,000-$7,500+ for comprehensive review

Accountant/CPA:

• Essential: Engage accountant with franchise experience
• Focus areas:
  • Financial statement analysis (Item 21)
  • Financial performance representations (Item 19)
  • Cash flow modeling with 10%+ fee structure
  • Tax implications and entity structuring
  • Working capital requirements
• Budget: $2,000-$5,000+ for initial analysis

Insurance Advisor:

• Review required coverage types and limits
• Obtain quotes for general liability, professional liability, sexual misconduct coverage
• Understand exclusions and gaps in coverage
• Budget for higher premiums given litigation history

4. Conduct Validation Calls

Franchisee Validation Strategy:

Minimum Contacts: 15-20 franchisees from Exhibit C list

Franchisee Categories to Contact:

• New franchisees (opened within last 2 years)
• Established franchisees (5+ years)
• Multi-unit operators
• Franchisees in similar markets to your target
• Franchisees who were part of 2021-2022 arbitration settlement (if identifiable)
• Former franchisees (Exhibit G) - understand why they left

Critical Questions to Ask:

Financial Performance:

• What were your actual revenues and profits in years 1, 2, 3?
• How long to reach break-even?
• What percentage of gross sales goes to total franchisor fees?
• What were your actual initial investment and working capital needs?
• Any unexpected costs or fee increases?

Litigation and Compliance:

• Have you experienced any sexual misconduct incidents?
• How has litigation affected your business or reputation?
• What safety protocols do you implement beyond franchisor requirements?
• Insurance costs and coverage challenges?

Franchisor Support:

• Quality of initial training and ongoing support?
• Satisfaction with technology systems (Meevo, P4)?
• Marketing fund effectiveness?
• Responsiveness to franchisee concerns?
• Were you part of the 2021-2022 arbitration? Why?

Operations:

• Staffing challenges (therapist recruitment,

---

Massage Envy Franchise FAQs

Comprehensive Answers to Your Franchise Questions

Q: How much does a Massage Envy franchise cost?

A: The total investment to open a Massage Envy franchise ranges from $605,850 to $1,014,700 according to the 2024 FDD. This comprehensive investment includes the initial franchise fee, real estate costs, equipment, inventory, working capital, and all other startup expenses. The actual amount you'll need depends on factors like your location, real estate costs in your market, and whether you're converting an existing space or building from scratch.

---

Q: What is the Massage Envy franchise fee?

A: The initial franchise fee is $45,000 for your first Massage Envy location. If you're opening a second or subsequent location, the fee is reduced to $35,000. U.S. military veterans receive additional discounts through the VetFran program: $36,000 for their first franchise (a $9,000 discount) and $28,000 for additional locations (a $7,000 discount). This fee is paid in a lump sum when you sign the franchise agreement and is non-refundable under any circumstances.

---

Q: How much do Massage Envy franchise owners make?

A: The FDD does not provide specific financial performance representations regarding franchisee earnings or profitability in Item 19. Without disclosed average revenues, expenses, or profit margins from existing franchisees, potential earnings cannot be accurately determined from the FDD. Prospective franchisees should contact current and former franchisees (listed in Exhibits C and G of the FDD) to gather information about actual financial performance and profitability expectations.

---

Q: What is the Massage Envy franchise failure rate?

A: The FDD does not explicitly state a "failure rate," but Item 20 provides outlet data that allows for analysis. According to the disclosure document, as of December 31, 2023, there were 1,053 Massage Envy Businesses operating in the system. The FDD shows the number of franchises that ceased operations, were terminated, or were not renewed, but specific failure rate percentages are not calculated in the document. Prospective franchisees should carefully review Item 20's tables showing outlet changes over the past three years to understand system stability.

---

Q: Does Massage Envy provide financing?

A: According to Item 10 of the FDD, ME SPE Franchising does not offer direct financing to franchisees. The company does not provide financing for the initial franchise fee, startup costs, equipment, inventory, or any other aspect of the initial investment. Franchisees must secure their own financing through banks, SBA loans, personal resources, or other third-party lenders. The FDD does not mention any relationships with preferred lenders or financing partners.

---

Q: How long is the Massage Envy franchise agreement?

A: The FDD does not explicitly state the initial term length of the franchise agreement in the provided excerpts. However, Item 17 would typically contain this information in the full disclosure document. Franchisees should review the complete Item 17 and the franchise agreement itself (Exhibit B) to determine the initial term length, renewal options, and conditions for renewal. The FDD does indicate that upon renewal, franchisees may need to sign a new agreement with different terms and conditions.

---

Q: What territory do you get with Massage Envy franchise?

A: Item 12 of the FDD addresses territory provisions, though the specific details are not fully provided in the excerpts. The FDD warns that you must maintain minimum sales performance levels or risk losing territorial rights. The document also notes in the "Special Risks" section that the franchise agreement may allow the franchisor to compete with you in your territory even if you're granted territorial rights. Prospective franchisees should carefully review Item 12 and the franchise agreement's territory provisions to understand the specific geographic area, exclusivity terms, and performance requirements.

---

Q: Is Massage Envy franchise a good investment?

A: This determination requires careful analysis of multiple factors not fully disclosed in the available FDD excerpts. Key considerations include: (1) The total investment of $605,850-$1,014,700 is substantial; (2) Ongoing fees total approximately 10% of gross sales (6% royalty + 2% Marketing Fund + 2% Supplemental Marketing Fund); (3) Monthly technology and support fees of approximately $1,095; (4) No financial performance data is provided to estimate potential returns; (5) The FDD contains significant litigation history, including multiple class actions related to membership practices and serious allegations involving franchisee locations. Prospective investors should conduct thorough due diligence, speak with current franchisees, and consult with franchise attorneys and accountants before making this decision.

---

Q: How do I get a Massage Envy FDD?

A: To obtain a Massage Envy Franchise Disclosure Document, contact the company directly at their corporate headquarters: 14350 North 87th Street, Suite 200, Scottsdale, Arizona 85260, or call (480) 366-4100. You can also email receptionist@massageenvy.com or visit www.massageenvy.com. By law, you must receive the FDD at least 14 calendar days before signing any binding agreement or making any payment to the franchisor. The FDD may be available in different formats for your convenience.

---

Q: Can I sell my Massage Envy franchise?

A: Yes, but transfers are subject to franchisor approval and significant fees. According to Item 6, you must pay a transfer fee equal to 2/3 of the then-current initial franchise fee (approximately $30,000 based on the current $45,000 fee) before completing a transfer. Item 17 outlines transfer conditions, which typically include: the buyer must meet all franchisor qualifications, you must be in good standing under the franchise agreement, all fees must be current, and the buyer must complete training. For simple ownership reallocations among existing owners, a reduced administrative fee of $500-$2,500 applies.

---

Q: What support does Massage Envy provide?

A: Item 11 details franchisor support, which includes: (1) Initial training covering business operations, massage and facial services, customer service, and management (specific duration not provided in excerpts); (2) Site selection assistance and approval; (3) Pre-opening support including an opening audit; (4) Operations manual with ongoing updates; (5) Marketing support through the National Advertising Fund and regional cooperatives; (6) Technology systems including point-of-sale and management software; (7) Ongoing field support which may be provided by Regional Developers in certain territories; and (8) Centralized technology support via help desk. Additional training and assistance are available for a fee of $250 per person per day plus expenses.

---

Q: What are the ongoing fees for Massage Envy franchise?

A: Ongoing fees include multiple components totaling approximately $1,095+ per month plus 10% of gross sales:

Additional fees may include Regional Advertising Cooperative contributions (if applicable), training fees, audit fees, and various other charges as outlined in Item 6.

---

Q: How long is Massage Envy franchise training?

A: The specific duration of the initial training program is not explicitly stated in the provided FDD excerpts. Item 11 indicates that initial training is provided at no additional charge and covers topics including business operations, massage and facial services, customer service, and management systems. The training location and detailed schedule would be outlined in the complete Item 11 section. Additional training for newly-hired personnel, refresher courses, and conventions may be required and could incur fees of $250 per person per day plus expenses. Prospective franchisees should request the complete training schedule and requirements.

---

Q: Can I run Massage Envy franchise as an absentee owner?

A: Item 15 addresses the obligation to participate in the actual operation of the franchise business, though the specific requirements are not detailed in the provided excerpts. The FDD indicates that if you are a business entity, each shareholder, partner, or member (and their spouses) must sign a personal guaranty, suggesting significant owner involvement is expected. Additionally, the franchise agreement allows the franchisor to charge a management fee of up to 8% of gross sales if they must manage your business due to a material breach, implying that proper owner oversight is required. Prospective franchisees should carefully review Item 15 and discuss owner involvement requirements with the franchisor.

---

Q: What are the main competitors to Massage Envy?

A: According to Item 1, Massage Envy Businesses compete with multiple types of service providers in a "fully developed and very competitive" market, including: (1) Day spas and resort spas offering massage and facial services; (2) Health clubs and fitness centers with spa services; (3) Chiropractic offices providing therapeutic massage; (4) Independent massage therapists operating private practices; and (5) Other franchise massage and spa concepts. The FDD notes that "demand for these services remains high" despite intense competition. Massage Envy differentiates itself through its unique membership-based pricing model, professional environment, brand reputation, and industry leadership position, though specific competitor names are not disclosed in the FDD.

---

Important Considerations for Prospective Franchisees

Red Flags to Consider

Based on the FDD analysis, potential franchisees should be aware of:

• Extensive litigation history including multiple class actions related to membership practices, billing issues, and serious allegations at franchised locations
• No financial performance representations provided in Item 19, making it difficult to assess potential profitability
• High ongoing fee structure totaling approximately 10% of gross sales plus $1,095+ monthly in fixed fees
• Significant transfer and renewal fees that could impact exit strategy
• Territory performance requirements that could result in loss of territorial rights
• Out-of-state dispute resolution requirement (Arizona) which may increase costs and reduce leverage

Positive Indicators

• Established brand with 1,053 operating locations as of December 31, 2023
• Veteran discounts demonstrating commitment to military community
• Reduced fees for multi-unit operators
• Comprehensive support systems including technology, training, and marketing
• Membership-based model providing recurring revenue potential

Due Diligence Recommendations

Before investing in a Massage Envy franchise, prospective franchisees should:

1. Contact multiple current and former franchisees (see Exhibits C and G) to discuss actual financial performance and operational challenges
2. Retain a franchise attorney to review all agreements and explain obligations
3. Consult with an accountant to model financial projections and break-even analysis
4. Investigate local market conditions including competition, demographics, and regulatory requirements
5. Review all litigation disclosed in Item 3 to understand potential risks
6. Understand licensing requirements for massage therapists and aestheticians in your state
7. Assess the total investment against your available capital and financing options
8. Evaluate the ongoing fee structure and its impact on profitability

---

This FAQ is based on the Massage Envy Franchise Disclosure Document dated April 29, 2024. Prospective franchisees should review the complete FDD and consult with professional advisors before making any investment decision.